9
AINOAeA?NOAAIIUE EIIEOAO ?INNEENEIE OAAeA?AOeEE II AUNOAIO IA?ACIAAIETH
EO?NIAAss ?AAIOA
Ii eo?no:
“A?aaeaeaineee i?ioeann”
Ia oaio:
“Noaeaaiua ?anoiaeu e noaeaaiua oo?aou”
Iineaa
2003
IEAI:
Aaaaeaiea
Aeaaa 1. Noaeaaiua ?anoiaeu
§1. Iiiyoea noaeaaiuo ?anoiaeia
§2. Ii?yaeie ii?aaeaeaiey, oieaou ainiioeeiu Inaiaiaeaeaiey io
ainiioeeiu.
§3. Ecaea?aeee naycaiiua n ?aniio?aieai aeaea
Aeaaa 2. Noaeaaiua oo?aou
§1. Iaeiaeaiea noaeaaiuo oo?aoia
§2. Neiaeaiea eee oiaiueoaiea noaeaaiiai oo?aoa
Caeeth/aiea
Nienie eniieueciaaiiuo enoi/ieeia
I?aaiaua aeou
Eeoa?aoo?a
Aaaaeaiea
Ioi?aaeaiea i?aainoaeey, eae e ethaay ae?oaay ainoaea?noaaiiay
aeayoaeueiinoue, o?aaoao cia/eoaeueiuo athaeaeaoiuo cao?ao. *anoue eo
ia?aeeaaeuaaaony ia oece/aneeo e th?eaee/aneeo eeoe, ia?auathueony ca
caueoie naieo i?aa a noaeu iauae th?enaeeeoeee.
Noaeaaiua ?anoiaeu ninoiyo ec ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu e ecaea?aeae,
naycaiiuo n ?anniio?aieai aeaea.
Oeaeueth acuneaiey noaeaaiuo ?anoiaeia yaeyaony:
a) /anoe/iia aiciauaiea ainoaea?noao cao?ao ia iaania/aiea
ooieoeeiie?iaaiey noaeaaiie nenoaiu;
a) aiciauaiea ?anoiaeia, naycaiiuo n ?acae?aoaeuenoaii eiie?aoiiai
aeaea:
– ainoaea?noao a nayce n iiianaiiuie noaeii ecaea?aeeaie;
– eeoeai, ieacuaathuei niaeaenoaea a inouanoaeaiee i?aainoaeey
(eiiiainaoeey cao?ao ia i?iaaaeaiea yenia?oecu, aiciaa?aaeaeaiea
yenia?oai, ia?aaiae/eeai, aiciauaiea ?anoiaeia naeaeaoaeae e ae?.);
a) i?aaeoi?aaeaeaiea iaiainiiaaiiuo ia?auaiee a noae, iiaoaeaeaiea eeoe
a aeia?iaieueiii ii?yaeea eniieieoue naith iaycaiiinoue.
Aeaaa 1. Noaeaaiua ?anoiaeu
§1. Iiiyoea e ninoaa noaeaaiuo ?anoiaeia
Iiae noaeaaiuie ?anoiaeaie iiieiathony cao?aou, iiianaiiua noi?iiaie
i?e ?anniio?aiee aeaea. Eiaeaenii noaeaaiua ?anoiaeu ?acaeaeaiu ia aeaa
a?oiiu – ainoaea?noaaiioth iioeeio e ecaea?aeee, naycaiiua n
?anniio?aieai aeaea. ?anoiaeu, naycaiiua n i?eioaeeoaeueiui eniieiaieai
noaeaaiiai ?aoaiey, Eiaeaen e /eneo noaeaaiuo ?anoiaeia ia ioiineo.
Niaeanii no. 1 Caeiia i ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeia iiae ainoaea?noaaiiie
iioeeiie iiieiaaony iaycaoaeueiue e aeaenoaothuee ia anae oa??eoi?ee
?inneeneie Oaaea?aoeee ieaoaae, aceiaaiue ca niaa?oaiea th?eaee/anee
cia/eiuo aeaenoaee eeai ca auaea/o aeieoiaioia oiieiiii/aiiuie ia oi
i?aaiaie eee aeieaeiinoiuie eeoeaie. Ainoaea?noaaiiay iioeeia aceiaaony
n iiaeaaaaiuo a noaeu iauae th?enaeeeoeee eneiauo e eiuo cayaeaiee e
aeaeia, a oii /enea ni ano?a/iuo eneiauo cayaeaiee; n cayaeaiee i
iiaoi?iie auaea/a noaeaaiiai i?eeaca; n cayaeaiee a?aaeaeai e
i?aaiecaoeee ii aeaeai, aicieeathuei ec ioaee/iuo i?aaiioiioaiee; n
cayaeaiee ii aeaeai iniaiai i?iecaiaenoaa; n eannaoeeiiiuo aeaeia ia
?aoaiey noaea; n iaaeci?iuo aeaeia ii aeaeai, eioi?ua ia auee
iaaeaeiaaiu a eannaoeeiiiii ii?yaeea; ca iiaoi?ioth auaea/o eiiee
(aeoaeeeaoia) ?aoaiee, ii?aaeaeaiee, iinoaiiaeaiee noaea, eiiee
(aeoaeeeaoia) ae?oaeo aeieoiaioia ec aeaea.
Ieaoaeueueee ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu – a?aaeaeaia ?inneeneie
Oaaea?aoeee, eiino?aiiua a?aaeaeaia e eeoea aac a?aaeaeainoaa, a oaeaea
th?eaee/aneea eeoea, ia?auathueany ca niaa?oaieai th?eaee/anee cia/eiuo
aeaenoaee eee auaea/ae aeieoiaioia (no. 2 Caeiia i ainoaea?noaaiiie
iioeeia). Niaeanii no. 3 iacaaiiiai Caeiia ainoaea?noaaiiay iioeeia
aceiaaony n eneiauo e eiuo cayaeaiee e aeaeia, iiaeaaaaiuo a noaeu iauae
th?enaeeeoeee, a?aeo?aaeiua noaeu e Eiinoeoooeeiiiue Noae ?O, a oaeaea
ca auaea/o aeieoiaioia oeacaiiuie noaeaie.
Ninoaa ecaea?aeae, naycaiiuo n ?anniio?aieai aeaea, ia?a/eneai a no. 94
AIE.
Iniiaiia ioee/ea ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu io ecaea?aeae, naycaiiuo n
?anniio?aieai aeaea, caeeth/aaony a oii, /oi ?acia? ainoaea?noaaiiie
iioeeiu ii?aaeaeyaony a ii?yaeea, onoaiiaeaiiii caeiiii (a i?ioeaioao io
oeaiu enea eee ieieiaeueiiai ?acia?a iieaou o?oaea), a naia iioeeia
ca/eneyaony a aeioiae oaaea?aeueiiai eee ianoiiai athaeaeaoa. ?acia?
ecaea?aeae, naycaiiuo n ?anniio?aieai aeaea, ii?aaeaeyaony ?aaeueiuie
cao?aoaie noi?ii ia inouanoaeaiea oao eee eiuo i?ioeannoaeueiuo
aeaenoaee e yaeythony eiiiainaoeeae eeoeai, eo iiianoei, e eeoue a
eneeth/eoaeueiuo neo/ayo iie iiaeeaaeao ca/eneaieth a athaeaeao (ni. no.
103 AIE).
Aeo oaaea?aeueiiai caeiiiaeaoaeuenoaa i iaeiaao e nai?ao, ?aaoee?othuei
?acia? e ii?yaeie oieaou ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu, – oaea oiiieiaaoeeny
Caeii i ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeia. Niaeanii iacaaiiiio Caeiio,
ainoaea?noaaiiay iioeeia oiea/eaaaony a ?oaeyo a aaiee (eo oeeeaeu), a
oaeaea iooai ia?a/eneaiey noii ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu ni n/aoa
ieaoaeueueea /a?ac aaiee (eo oeeeaeu). I?eai aaieaie (eo oeeeaeaie)
ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu inouanoaeyaony ai anao neo/ayo n auaea/ae
eaeoaioeee onoaiiaeaiiie oi?iu (i. 1 no. 6 Caeiia). Ii aeaeai,
?anniao?eaaaiui noaeaie iauae th?enaeeeoeee, ainoaea?noaaiiay iioeeia
oiea/eaaaony aei iiaea/e niioaaonoaothuaai cayaeaiey (aeaeiau) eee
eannaoeeiiiie aeaeiau, a oaeaea i?e auaea/a noaeii eiiee aeieoiaioia
(iiaei. 1 i. 2 no. 6 Caeiia).
?acia?u ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu ii aeaeai, ?anniao?eaaaiui a noaeao
iauae th?enaeeeoeee, onoaiiaeaiu i. 1 no. 4 Caeiia i ainoaea?noaaiiie
iioeeia. Iie aa?uee?othony a caaeneiinoe io oa?aeoa?a cayaeaiiuo
o?aaiaaiee eee io nouanoaa oao aeaenoaee, eioi?ua aeieaeai inouanoaeoue
noae. Oae, iai?eia?, n eneiauo cayaeaiee eiouanoaaiiiai oa?aeoa?a i?e
oeaia enea aei 1 iei. ?oa. ainoaea?noaaiiay iioeeia ninoaaeyao 5% io
oeaiu enea; n eneiauo cayaeaiee iaeiouanoaaiiiai oa?aeoa?a, a oaeaea n
eneiauo cayaeaiee eiouanoaaiiiai oa?aeoa?a, ia iiaeeaaeaueo ioeaiea –
10% io ieieiaeueiiai ?acia?a iieaou o?oaea – aeey a?aaeaeai; 10-e?aoiue
?acia? ieieiaeueiiai ?acia?a iieaou o?oaea – aeey th?eaee/aneeo eeoe. Ca
eneiaua cayaeaiey, niaea?aeauea iaeiia?aiaiii o?aaiaaiey eiouanoaaiiiai
e iaeiouanoaaiiiai oa?aeoa?a, aceiaaony iaeiia?aiaiii ainoaea?noaaiiay
iioeeia, onoaiiaeaiiay aeey eneiauo cayaeaiee eiouanoaaiiiai oa?aeoa?a e
aeey eneiauo cayaeaiee iaeiouanoaaiiiai oa?aeoa?a.
N eannaoeeiiiuo aeaeia ia ?aoaiey noaea ainoaea?noaaiiay iioeeia
ninoaaeyao 50% io ?acia?a ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu, aceiaaiie i?e
iiaea/a eneiauo cayaeaiee (aeaeia) iaeiouanoaaiiiai oa?aeoa?a, a ii
nii?ai eiouanoaaiiiai oa?aeoa?a – io ?acia?a ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu,
en/eneaiiie ec noiiu, inia?eaaaiie noi?iiie eee ae?oaei eeoeii,
o/anoaothuei a aeaea.
§2. Ii?yaeie ii?aaeaeaiey, oieaou ainiioeeiu Inaiaiaeaeaiey io
ainiioeeiu.
No. 89 AIE onoaiaaeeaaao neo/ae inaiaiaeaeaiey ioaeaeueiuo eaoaai?ee
eeoe io oieaou ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu. I?e yoii neaaeoao eiaoue a
aeaeo, /oi i. 7 no. 13 Iaeiaiaiai eiaeaena ?O io 31.07.98 N 146-OC (a
?aae. io 30.12.01) ainoaea?noaaiiay iioeeia ioianaia e oaaea?aeueiui
iaeiaai e nai?ai, eioi?ua iiaoo onoaiaaeeaaoueny, aaiaeeoueny e
aceiaoueny ia iniiaaiee ii?i naiiai Iaeiaiaiai eiaeaena ?O e i?eiyouo a
niioaaonoaee n iei oaaea?aeueiuo caeiiia i iaeiaao e nai?ao (i. 1 no.
1), e eaeiaui AIE ia ioiineony. Iiyoiio i?e i?eiaiaiee iieiaeaiee /. 1
no. 89 AIE ia i?aeoeea aiciiaeiu eieeecee n niioaaonoaothueie
iieiaeaieyie oaaea?aeueiiai caeiiiaeaoaeuenoaa i iaeiaao e nai?ao.
Aii?inu inaiaiaeaeaiey io oieaou ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu ii aeaeai,
?anniao?eaaaiui a noaeao iauae th?enaeeeoeee, o?aaoee?iaaiu i. 2 no. 5
Caeiia ?O i ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeia. I?e yoii neaaeoao o/eouaaoue, /oi
iniiaaiey inaiaiaeaeaiey io oieaou ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu,
ia?a/eneaiiua a Caeiia e a /. 1 No. 89 AIE, ia anaaaea oiaeaeanoaaiiu.
Oae, n iaeiie noi?iiu, a i. 2 no. 5 Caeiia ia i?aaeoniio?aiu oaeea
iniiaaiey inaiaiaeaeaiey io oieaou ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu, eioi?ua
niaea?aeaony a i. 9, 10, 15, 16, 19 /. 1 no. 89 AIE. N ae?oaie noi?iiu,
i?eaaaeaiiue a /. 1 no. 89 AIE ia?a/aiue iniiaaiee inaiaiaeaeaiey io
oieaou ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu iaiieiue, iineieueeo niaeanii i. 2 no. 5
Caeiia i ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeia inaiaiaeaeathony io oieaou
ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu:
oaaea?aeueiue i?aai eniieieoaeueiie aeanoe, inouanoaeythuee oi?aaeaiea
ainoaea?noaaiiui ?aca?aii, aai oa??eoi?eaeueiua i?aaiu, i?aaei?eyoey,
o/?aaeaeaiey e i?aaiecaoeee nenoaiu ainoaea?noaaiiiai ?aca?aa, a oaeaea
i?aaiu oi?aaeaiey e iiae?acaeaeaiey Ainoaea?noaaiiie i?ioeaiiiaea?iie
neoaeau Ieienoa?noaa ?O ii aeaeai a?aaeaeaineie iai?iiu, /?acau/aeiui
neooaoeeyi e eeeaeaeaoeee iineaaenoaee noeoeeiuo aaaenoaee i?e
inouanoaeaiee naieo ooieoeee, onoaiiaeaiiuo caeiiiaeaoaeuenoaii ?O, – ii
eneai, naycaiiui n ia?ooaieai eo i?aa;
iauanoaaiiua i?aaiecaoeee eiaaeeaeia, eo o/?aaeaeaiey,
o/aaii-i?iecaiaenoaaiiua i?aaiecaoeee e iauaaeeiaiey – ii anai eneai;
enooeu – ii eneai ia eno?aaiaaiee ec iacaeiiiiai aeaaeaiey eiouanoaa,
eiathuaai enoi?e/aneoth, ooaeiaeanoaaiioth eee eioth oeaiiinoue;
th?eaee/aneea eeoea e a?aaeaeaia – i?e iiaea/a a noae cayaeaiee ia
ion?i/ea eee i ?ann?i/ea eniieiaiey ?aoaiee, ia eciaiaiee niiniaa e
ii?yaeea eniieiaiey ?aoaiee, i iiai?ioa eniieiaiey ?aoaiey,
ainnoaiiaeaiee i?iiouaiiuo n?ieia, ia?aniio?a ?aoaiey, ii?aaeaeaiey eee
iinoaiiaeaiey noaea ii aiiaue ioe?uaoeiny ianoiyoaeuenoaai; i ia?aniio?a
cai/iiai ?aoaiey noaeii, auianoei yoi ?aoaiea; aeaeia ia aeaenoaey
noaeaaiiai eniieieoaey, a oaeaea aeaeia ia iinoaiiaeaiey ii aeaeai ia
aaeieieno?aoeaiuo i?aaiia?ooaieyo, auianaiiuo oiieiiii/aiiuie ia oi
i?aaiaie; /anoiuo aeaeia ia ii?aaeaeaiey noaea, a oii /enea ia
iaania/aiee enea eee i caiaia iaeiiai aeaea iaania/aiey ae?oaei, i
i?ae?auaiee eee i?einoaiiaeaiee aeaea, ia ioeaca a neiaeaiee eee
oiaiueoaiee ?acia?a oo?aoa, iaeiaeaiiiai noaeii;
a?aaeaeaia – n eannaoeeiiiuo aeaeia ii oaieiaiui aeaeai, a eioi?uo
inia?eaaaony i?aaeeueiinoue acuneaiey iaoa?eaeueiiai oua?aa,
i?e/eiaiiiai i?anooieaieai; Iaineiiiue oiiae ?inneeneie Oaaea?aoeee e
aai i?aaiu – ii eneai i acuneaiee n a?aaeaeai iaycaoaeueiuo ieaoaaeae;
?aaaeeeoe?iaaiiua eeoea e eeoea, i?eciaiiua iino?aaeaaoeie io
iieeoe/aneeo ?ai?annee, – i?e ia?auaiee ii aii?inai, aicieeathuei a
nayce n i?eiaiaieai Caeiia ?O io 18.10.91 N 1761-1 “I ?aaaeeeoaoeee
aea?oa iieeoe/aneeo ?ai?annee” (a ?aae. io 07.08.2000), ca eneeth/aieai
nii?ia iaaeaeo yoeie eeoeaie e eo ianeaaeieeaie;
auioaeaeaiiua ia?anaeaioeu e aaaeaioeu – ii aeaeiaai ia ioeac a
?aaeno?aoeee oiaeaoaenoaa i i?eciaiee eo auioaeaeaiiuie ia?anaeaioeaie
eee aaaeaioeaie;
aaoa?aiu Aaeeeie Ioa/anoaaiiie aieiu, aaoa?aiu aiaauo aeaenoaee ia
oa??eoi?eyo ae?oaeo ainoaea?noa, aaoa?aiu aiaiiie neoaeau, aaoa?aiu
i?aaiia aioo?aiieo aeae, i?ieo?aoo?u, thnoeoeee e noaeia, aaoa?aiu
o?oaea, ia?auathueany ca caueoie naieo i?aa, onoaiiaeaiiuo Oaaea?aeueiui
caeiiii io 12.01.95 N 5-OC “I aaoa?aiao” (a ?aae. io 25.07.02);
eeeaeaeaoeeiiiua eiiennee – ii eneai i acuneaiee i?in?i/aiiuo
caaeieaeaiiinoae e aeaaeoi?ai aeieaeieea a iieueco iio?aaeoaeae;
a?aaeaeaia – i?e ia?auaiee a noae n eneaie i aiciauaiee oauoeia,
naycaiiuo n iaaica?aoii a n?iee, i?aaeoniio?aiiua aeiaiai?aie eee
o/?aaeeoaeueiuie aeieoiaioaie, aeaiaaeiuo eee eiouanoaaiiuo aeeaaeia,
aianaiiuo a aeoeeiia?iua iauanoaa, oiaa?euanoaa, aaiee e ae?oaea
eiiia?/aneea i?aaiecaoeee;
o/?aaeaeaiey e i?aaiu oaieiaii-eniieieoaeueiie nenoaiu – ii eneai i
aiciauaiee aeiiieieoaeueiuo cao?ao, naycaiiuo n i?ana/aieai iiaaaa
niaea?aeaueony iiae no?aaeae iiaeic?aaaaiuo eee iaaeiyaiuo, a ?aaii
inoaeaeaiiuo e ia?aie/aieth naiaiaeu, a?anoo eee eeoaieth naiaiaeu, eo
?icuneii, a oaeaea ea/aieai a neo/aa oiuoeaiiiai i?e/eiaiey a?aaea
naiaio caei?iaueth;
enooeu – i?e ?anniio?aiee a noaeao aeae i caueoa i?aa e caeiiiuo
eioa?ania ?aaaiea.
E?iia oiai, neaaeoao eiaoue a aeaeo, /oi niaeanii i. 1 no. 5 Caeiia i
ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeia io oieaou ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu ii aeaeai,
?anniao?eaaaiui a noaeao iauae th?enaeeeoeee, inaiaiaeaeathony Aa?ie
Niaaoneiai Nithca, Aa?ie ?inneeneie Oaaea?aoeee, iieiua eaaaea?u i?aeaia
Neaau, o/anoieee e eiaaeeaeu Aaeeeie Ioa/anoaaiiie aieiu, a oaeaea
eeoea, eiathuea i?aai ia yoo eueaioo a niioaaonoaee n Caeiiii ?O io
15.05.91 N 1244-1 “I nioeeaeueiuo aa?aioeyo a?aaeaeaiai, iiaeaa?aoeiny
aicaeaenoaeth ?aaeeaoeee aneaaenoaea eaoano?iou ia *a?iiaueueneie AYN”
(a ?aae. io 25.07.02), Oaaea?aeueiui caeiiii io 26.11.98 N 175-OC “I
nioeeaeueiie caueoa a?aaeaeai, iiaeaa?aoeony aicaeaenoaeth ?aaeeaoeee
aneaaenoaea aaa?ee a 1957 aiaeo ia i?iecaiaenoaaiiii iauaaeeiaiee “Iaye”
e na?inia ?aaeeiaeoeaiuo iooiaeia a ?aeo Oa/a” (a ?aae. io 29.12.01),
Oaaea?aeueiui caeiiii io 19.08.95 N 149-OC “I nioeeaeueiie caueoa
a?aaeaeai, iiaeaa?aoeony ?aaeeaoeeiiiiio aicaeaenoaeth aneaaenoaea
yaea?iuo eniuoaiee ia Naieiaeaoeineii iieeaiia” e Iinoaiiaeaieai
Aa?oiaiiai Niaaoa ?O io 27.12.91 N 2123-1 “I ?ani?ino?aiaiee aeaenoaey
Caeiia ?NON? “I nioeeaeueiie caueoa a?aaeaeai, iiaeaa?aoeony
aicaeaenoaeth ?aaeeaoeee aneaaenoaea eaoano?iou ia *a?iiaueueneie AYN”
ia a?aaeaeai ec iiae?acaeaeaiee iniaiai ?enea”.
* 2 no. 89 AIE i?aaeoniao?eaaao, /oi ainoaea?noaaiiay iioeeia aceiaaony
eeoue ca iiaoi?ioth auaea/o eiiee noaeaaiuo iinoaiiaeaiee. Niaeanii
iiaei. 11 i. 1 no. 4 Caeiia i ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeia ca iiaoi?ioth
auaea/o eiiee (aeoaeeeaoia) ?aoaiee, ii?aaeaeaiee, iinoaiiaeaiee noaea,
eiiee (aeoaeeeaoia) ae?oaeo aeieoiaioia ec aeaea, auaeaaaaiuo noaeii ii
i?inueaa noi?ii eee ae?oaeo eeoe, o/anoaothueo a aeaea, a oaeaea ca
auaea/o eiiee (aeoaeeeaoia) iacaaiiuo aeieoiaioia, auaeaaaaiuo noaeii ii
i?inueaa caeioa?aniaaiiuo eeoe, ainoaea?noaaiiay iioeeia aceiaaony a
?acia?a 1% io ieieiaeueiiai ?acia?a iieaou o?oaea ca no?aieoeo
aeieoiaioa.
Io oieaou ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu inaiaiaeaeathony th?eaee/aneea eeoea
e a?aaeaeaia – ca auaea/o ei aeieoiaioia a nayce n aeaeaie i acuneaiee
aeeiaioia (ni. iiaei. 7 i. 2 no. 5 Caeiia i ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeia).
3. I?aai ia noaeaaioth caueoo – eiinoeoooeeiiiia i?aai, cae?aieaiiia a
no. 46 Eiinoeoooeee. ?acia? iioeeiu ia aeieaeai neoaeeoue i?aiyonoaeai
aeey a?aaeaeaieia a caueoa ia?ooaiiuo i?aa e naiaiae. Niaeanii iniiaiui
ia/aeai caeiiiaeaoaeuenoaa i iaeiaao e nai?ao iaaeiionoeiu iaeiae e
nai?u, i?aiyonoaothuea ?aaeecaoeee a?aaeaeaiaie naieo eiinoeoooeeiiiuo
i?aa; i?e onoaiiaeaiee iaeiaia o/eouaaaony oaeoe/aneay niiniaiinoue
iaeiaiieaoaeueueea e oieaoa iaeiaa (i. 1, 3 no. 3 Iaeiaiaiai eiaeaena ?O
io 31.07.98. N 146-OC (a ?aae. io 30.12.01)). Iniiauaaynue ia yoeo
ia/aeao, /. 3 No. 89 AIE aini?iecaiaeeo ii?io, niaea?aeauothny a
iineaaeiai aac. i. 2 no. 5 Caeiia i ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeia e
i?aaeinoaaeyao noaeuea (noaeo) i?aai a caaeneiinoe io eiouanoaaiiiai
iieiaeaiey a?aaeaeaieia inaiaiaeeoue iineaaeiaai io oieaou
ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu e iiieii iniiaaiee, ia?a/eneaiiuo a /. 1 no. 89
AIE.
I?aai ia noaeaaioth caueoo – eiinoeoooeeiiiia i?aai, cae?aieaiiia a no.
46 Eiinoeoooeee. ?acia? iioeeiu ia aeieaeai neoaeeoue i?aiyonoaeai a
caueoa ia?ooaiiuo i?aa e naiaiae. A ioee/ea io /. 3 no. 89 AIE, eioi?ay
aeiioneaao inaiaiaeaeaiea io oieaou ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu ii ?aoaieth
noaea oieueei a?aaeaeai, ii?ia no. 90 iicaieyao o/anoue eiouanoaaiiia
iieiaeaiea noi?ii ia oieueei a?aaeaeaieia, ii e th?eaee/aneiai eeoea,
yaeythuaainy noi?iiie ii aeaeo, e naeaeaoue aeey ieo iaiaa
ia?aiaieoaeueiui ianaiea noaeaaiuo ?anoiaeia. Ion?i/ea eee ?ann?i/ea ii
oieaoa iaeiaa, e eaeiaui ioiineony ainoaea?noaaiiay iioeeia,
i?aaenoaaeyao niaie eciaiaiea n?iea oieaou iaeiaa i?e iaee/ee
i?aaeoniio?aiiuo caeiiii iniiaaiee, ia n?ie io iaeiiai aei oanoe
ianyoeaa niioaaonoaaiii n aaeeiia?aiaiiie eee iiyoaiiie oieaoie
iaeiaiieaoaeueueeii noiiu caaeieaeaiiinoe (i. 1 no. 64 Iaeiaiaiai
eiaeaena ?O).
?aoaiea i i?aaeinoaaeaiee ion?i/ee eee ?ann?i/ee ii oieaoa
ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu i?eieiaaony noaeii (noaeueae), /oi iiieii no.
90 AIE i?aaeoniio?aii oaeaea iineaaeiei aac. i. 2 no. 5 Caeiia i
ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeia.
Ii?yaeie i?aaeinoaaeaiey ion?i/ee (?ann?i/ee) ii oieaoa ainoaea?noaaiiie
iioeeiu aeaoaeueii i?iienai a no. 64 Iaeiaiaiai eiaeaena ?O. A
/anoiinoe, cayaeaiea i i?aaeinoaaeaiee ion?i/ee (?ann?i/ee) ii oieaoa
iaeiaa n oeacaieai iniiaaiee oaeiai i?aaeinoaaeaiey iiaeaaony a
niioaaonoaothuee oiieiiii/aiiue i?aai, o.a. a noae. E cayaeaieth
i?eeaaathony aeieoiaiou, iiaeoaa?aeaeathuea eiouanoaaiiia iieiaeaiea
noi?ii, eioi?ia aeaeaao iaaiciiaeiui aaeeiia?aiaiioth oieaoo
ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu aei iiaea/e niioaaonoaothuaai cayaeaiey
(aeaeiau). Eiiey oeacaiiiai cayaeaiey iai?aaeyaony caeioa?aniaaiiui
eeoeii a 10-aeiaaiue n?ie a iaeiaiaue i?aai ii ianoo aai o/aoa. Noae
(noaeuey) aeieaeai i?eiyoue ?aoaiea i i?aaeinoaaeaiee ion?i/ee eee
?ann?i/ee ii oieaoa iaeiaa eee ia ioeaca a aa i?aaeinoaaeaiee a oa/aiea
iaeiiai ianyoea ni aeiy iieo/aiey cayaeaiey caeioa?aniaaiiiai eeoea.
Ii oiaeaoaenoao caeioa?aniaaiiiai eeoea noae (noaeuey) ai?aaa i?eiyoue
?aoaiea i a?aiaiiii (ia ia?eiae ?anniio?aiey cayaeaiey i i?aaeinoaaeaiee
ion?i/ee eee ?ann?i/ee) i?einoaiiaeaiee oieaou noiiu caaeieaeaiiinoe
caeioa?aniaaiiui eeoeii.
?aoaiea i i?aaeinoaaeaiee ion?i/ee eee ?ann?i/ee ii oieaoa iaeiaa
aeieaeii niaea?aeaoue oeacaiea ia noiio caaeieaeaiiinoe, iaeia, ii
oieaoa eioi?iai i?aaeinoaaeyaony ion?i/ea eee ?ann?i/ea, n?iee e
ii?yaeie oieaou noiiu caaeieaeaiiinoe e ia/eneyaiuo i?ioeaioia. Eiiey
?aoaiey i i?aaeinoaaeaiee ion?i/ee eee ?ann?i/ee ii oieaoa
ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu eee ia ioeaca a aa i?aaeinoaaeaiee a
o?aoaeiaaiue n?ie ni aeiy i?eiyoey oaeiai ?aoaiey iai?aaeyaony noaeii
(noaeueae) caeioa?aniaaiiiio eeoeo e a iaeiaiaue i?aai ii ianoo o/aoa
yoiai eeoea.
?aoaiea ia ioeaca a i?aaeinoaaeaiee ion?i/ee eee ?ann?i/ee ii oieaoa
iaeiaa aeieaeii auoue iioeae?iaaiiui e iiaeao auoue iaaeaeiaaii
caeioa?aniaaiiui eeoeii a ii?yaeea, onoaiiaeaiiii caeiiiaeaoaeuenoaii
?O.
No. 90 AIE i?aaeoniio?aia aiciiaeiinoue oiaiueoaiey ?acia?a
ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu, iaeiaei ie Iaeiaiaue eiaeaen ?O, ie Caeii i
ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeia, ie Eino?oeoeey Ainiaeianeoaeau ?O io 15.05.96
N 42 ii i?eiaiaieth iacaaiiiai Caeiia ia niaea?aeao eaeeo-eeai
iieiaeaiee, ?aaeaiaioe?othueo ii?yaeie oiaiueoaiey ?acia?a
ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu.
Niaeanii iiaei. 1 i. 1 no. 4 Caeiia i ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeia ii eneai
eiouanoaaiiiai oa?aeoa?a ?acia? ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu ii?aaeaeyaony a
i?ioeaioiii ioiioaiee e oeaia enea, a nayce n /ai /. 1 no. 90 AIE
onoaiaaeeaaao iiae?iaiua i?aaeea ii?aaeaeaiey oeaiu enea aeey en/eneaiey
?acia?a iiaeeaaeauae oieaoa ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu. Ioaeaeueiua neo/ae
ii?aaeaeaiey oeaiu enea niaea?aeaony oaeaea a Eino?oeoeee
Ainiaeianeoaeau ?O io 15.05.96 N 42 ii i?eiaiaieth Caeiia ?O “I
ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeia”. Iai?eia?, n eneiauo cayaeaiee i ?anoi?aeaiee
a?aea n iaeiia?aiaiiui ?acaeaeii eiouanoaa iioeeia aceiaaony e ca
?anoi?aeaiea a?aea, e ca ?acaeae eiouanoaa (i. 10 /. 1 no. 90 AIE). N
eneiauo cayaeaiee i i?aaa nianoaaiiinoe ia eiouanoai, i i?eciaiee i?aaa
ia aeieth a eiouanoaa, i auaeaea aeiee ec iauaai eiouanoaa (i. 9 /. 1
no. 90 AIE), anee nii? i i?eciaiee i?aaa nianoaaiiinoe ia yoi eiouanoai
ia ?aoaeny noaeii, ainoaea?noaaiiay iioeeia aceiaaony eae n cayaeaiee
eiouanoaaiiiai oa?aeoa?a, iiaeeaaeaueo ioeaiea. N eneiauo cayaeaiee ia
eno?aaiaaiee ianeaaeieeaie i?eiaaeeaaeauae ei aeiee eiouanoaa, anee nii?
i i?eciaiee i?aaa nianoaaiiinoe ia yoi eiouanoai noaeii ?aiaa aue
?ac?aoai, ainoaea?noaaiiay iioeeia aceiaaony eae n eneiauo cayaeaiee
eiouanoaaiiiai oa?aeoa?a, ia iiaeeaaeaueo ioeaiea (i. 24, 25
auoaiacaaiiie Eino?oeoeee).
Niaeanii i. 6 /. 2 no. 131 AIE a oii neo/aa, eiaaea ene iiaeeaaeeo
ioeaiea, a eneiaii cayaeaiee aeieaeia auoue oeacaia oeaia enea e ?an/ao
acuneeaaaiuo (inia?eaaaiuo) aeaiaaeiuo noii. Oaeei ia?acii, ii?aaeaeeoue
oeaio enea enoaoe aeieaeai aua ia noaaeee iiaeaioiaee eneiaiai cayaeaiey
Eiiiaioa?ee e A?aaeaeaineiio i?ioeannoaeueiiio eiaeaeno ?inneeneie
Oaaea?aoeee (Ioa. ?aae. A.I.Eaeeaa), TH?aeo-Ecaeao, 2002. Aeaaa 7.
Ionooieoue io oeacaiiie a cayaeaiee oeaiu enea e ii?aaeaeeoue aa
naiinoiyoaeueii i?e i?eiyoee eneiaiai cayaeaiey noaeuey iiaeao ia
oieueei oiaaea, eiaaea oeaia enea yaii ia niioaaonoaoao ia oieueei
aeaenoaeoaeueiie noieiinoe eiouanoaa, ii e eiaaea iia ia niioaaonoaoao
acuneeaaaiui aeaiaaeiui noiiai e ieaoaaeai. Ii?aaeaeyy aeaenoaeoaeueioth
noieiinoue eiouanoaa, noaeuey iiaeao i?eaioe?iaaoueny ia aai ?uii/ioth
noieiinoue, iiae eioi?ie iiieiaaony iaeaieaa aa?iyoiay oeaia, ii eioi?ie
eiouanoai iiaeao auoue io/oaeaeaii ia ioe?uoii ?uiea a oneiaeyo
eiieo?aioeee, eiaaea noi?iiu naeaeee aeaenoaotho ?acoiii, ?aniieaaay
anae iaiaoiaeeiie eioi?iaoeeae, a ia aaee/eia oeaiu naeaeee ia
io?aaeathony eaeea-eeai /?acau/aeiua ianoiyoaeuenoaa (no. 3
Oaaea?aeueiiai 3aeiia io 29.07.98 N 135-OC “Ia ioeaii/iie aeayoaeueiinoe
a ?inneeneie Oaaea?aoeee” (a ?aae. io 21.03.02).
Iiaeao neiaeeoueny oaeay neooaoeey, eiaaea a iiiaio i?aaeuyaeaiey enea
enoaoe ia a ninoiyiee oi/ii ii?aaeaeeoue oeaio enea, ia iniiaaiee
eioi?ie aoaeao ?ann/eouaaoueny ?acia? iiaeeaaeauae oieaoa
ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu. Iai?eia?, a aeiaiai?a iiaeeciaiiiai
niaea?aeaiey n eaeaeeaaieai noi?iiu aeiaiai?eeenue, /oi iiaeeciaiiia
niaea?aeaiea inouanoaeyaony a oi?ia auieao a oa/aiea aeecie a?aaeaeaieia
ia?eiaee/aneeo aeaiaaeiuo ieaoaaeae (no. 603 AE). Ii eaeie-eeai i?e/eia
ieaoaeueuee ?aiou i?ae?aoee naiaa?aiaiii auiea/eaaoue ii?aaeaeaiiua
aeiaiai?ii aeaiaaeiua noiiu. A yoii neo/aa iieo/aoaeue ?aiou iiaeao
ia?aoeoueny a noae n o?aaiaaieai i acuneaiee i?e/eoathueony aio
aeaiaaeiuo noii n ieaoaeueueea ?aiou. Ia iniiaaiee i. 5 /. 1 no. 91 AIE
oeaia enea a yoii neo/aa aoaeao ii?aaeaeyoueny enoiaey ec niaieoiiinoe
anao i?e/eoathueony enooeo ieaoaaeae ca 3 aiaea. I?e yoii a iiiaio oaeie
iaoieaou iiaeao eciaieoueny ieieiaeueiue ?acia? iieaou o?oaea. Ia
iniiaaiee no. 318 AE noiia, auiea/eaaaiay ii aeaiaaeiiio iaycaoaeuenoao
iaiin?aaenoaaiii ia niaea?aeaiea a?aaeaeaieia, n oaaee/aieai
onoaiiaeaiiiai caeiiii ieieiaeueiiai ?acia?a iieaou o?oaea
i?iii?oeeiiaeueii oaaee/eaaaony. A iiaeiaiie neooaoeee i?e i?eiyoee
eneiaiai cayaeaiey e ii?aaeaeaiee oeaiu enea noaeuey iiaeao
i?eaioe?iaaoueny ia noiio, oeacaiioth a aeiaiai?a iiaeeciaiiiai
niaea?aeaiey, a a i?ioeanna ?ac?aoaiey aeaea oeaia enea aoaeao ooi/iaia
e niioaaonoaaiii aeiiea/aia ainoaea?noaaiiay iioeeia.
*anoue 1 no. 39 AIE i?aaeinoaaeyao enooeo i?aai oaaee/eoue ?acia?
eneiauo o?aaiaaiee oaea iinea iiaea/e e i?eiyoey noaeueae eneiaiai
cayaeaiey. *anoue 2 no. 92 AIE onoaiaaeeaaao ii?yaeie ia?an/aoa
ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu a caaeneiinoe io oaaee/aiiie oeaiu enea. I?e
yoii a ioee/ea io no. 84 AIE ?NON?, eioi?ay iiaeiaiuo iieiaeaiee ia
niaea?aeaea, iiaue AIE onoaiaaeeaaao ii?aaeaeaiiua naieoeee – aei
iiiaioa i?aaenoaaeaiey enooeii aeieacaoaeuenoa aeiieaou ainoaea?noaaiiie
iioeeiu (eaeoaioeee onoaiiaeaiiie oi?iu, auaeaiiie aaieii (aai
oeeeaeii)) ?anniio?aiea aeaea i?einoaiaaeeaaaony Ainoaea?noaaiiay
iioeeia i?e ia?auaiee a noaeu iauae th?enaeeeoeee (E.I. E?ueaiiaa,
“A?aaeaeaiei e i?aai”, N 5, iae 2002 a.).
A /. 1 no. 93 AIE ia?a/eneythony neo/ae, eiaaea oiea/aiiay
ainoaea?noaaiiay iioeeia iiaeeaaeeo aica?aoo. Iaiaoiaeeii ioiaoeoue, /oi
ia?a/aiue oaeeo neo/aaa a ioieoa aeai eae en/a?iuaathuee. Eiua neo/ae
aica?aoa ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu iiaoo auoue i?aaeoniio?aiu oieueei
oaaea?aeueiuie caeiiaie. A oeaeii a ioieoa aini?iecaaaeaiu iniiaaiey
aica?aoa ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu, niaea?aeaueany a i. 4 no. 6 Caeiia i
ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeia. Aianoa n oai neaaeoao ia?aoeoue aieiaiea ia
iiaei. 4 i. 4 no. 6 oeacaiiiai Caeiia, niaeanii eioi?iio
ainoaea?noaaiiay iioeeia oaeaea iiaeeaaeeo aica?aoo a neo/aa ioeaca
eeoe, oieaoeaoeo ainoaea?noaaiioth iioeeio, io niaa?oaiey th?eaee/anee
cia/eiiai aeaenoaey eee io iieo/aiey aeieoiaioa aei ia?auaiey a i?aai,
niaa?oathuee aeaiiia th?eaee/anee cia/eiia aeaenoaea. Iaeiaei a oii
neo/aa, anee iinea i?aaeuyaeaiey enea enoaoe e ?anniio?aieth aeaea
eioa?an oo?aoeo, oi i?aaa ia aica?ao ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu ii eiaoue
ia aoaeao.
*. 3 no. 93 AIE onoaiaaeeaaao ii?yaeie aica?aoa ainoaea?noaaiiie
iioeeiu. Niaeanii i. 3 no. 6 Caeiia i ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeia a aeioiae
oaaea?aeueiiai athaeaeaoa ii ianoo iaoiaeaeaiey aaiea, i?eiyaoaai
ieaoaae, ca/eneyaony ainoaea?noaaiiay iioeeia ii aeaeai, ?anniao?eaaaiui
Aa?oiaiui Noaeii ?O. A inoaeueiuo neo/ayo ainoaea?noaaiiay iioeeia
ca/eneyaony a aeioiae ianoiiai athaeaeaoa ii ianoo iaoiaeaeaiey aaiea,
i?eiyaoaai ieaoaae.
I?e aiaeeca /. 3 no. 93 AIE neaaeoao eiaoue a aeaeo, /oi ii?yaeie
aica?aoa eceeoia oiea/aiiuo noii ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu ?aaoee?oaony
oaeaea ae. 12 Iaeiaiaiai eiaeaena ?O e Caeiiii i ainoaea?noaaiiie
iioeeia. Niaeanii i. 8 no. 78 Iaeiaiaiai eiaeaena ?O cayaeaiea i
aica?aoa noiiu eceeoia oiea/aiiiai iaeiaa iiaeao auoue iiaeaii a oa/aiea
3 eao ni aeiy oieaou oeacaiiie noiiu. Aica?ao oiea/aiiie a oaaea?aeueiue
athaeaeao ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu i?iecaiaeeony ii cayaeaieyi,
iiaeaaaaiui a iaeiaiaue i?aai, a oa/aiea aiaea ni aeiy auianaiey
niioaaonoaothuaai ii?aaeaeaiey noaea (i. 5 no. 6 Caeiia i
ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeia). Ainoaea?noaaiiay iioeeia, iiaeeaaeauay
aica?aoo, aeieaeia auoue auaeaia a?aaeaeaieio eee th?eaee/aneiio eeoeo a
oa/aiea iaeiiai ianyoea ni aeiy i?eiyoey ?aoaiey i aa aica?aoa
niioaaonoaothuei oeiainiaui eee iaeiaiaui i?aaiii.
§3. Ecaea?aeee naycaiiua n ?aniio?aieai aeaea
Anee ainoaea?noaaiioth iioeeio iiaeii ?anniao?eaaoue eae ii?aaeaeaiioth
eiiiainaoeeth cao?ao ainoaea?noaa ia niaea?aeaiea noaeaaiie aeanoe, oi
ecaea?aeee, naycaiiua n ?anniio?aieai aeaea, a aieueoeinoaa neo/aaa
iiaeeaaeao aiciauaieth a iieueco eeoe, oaeea ecaea?aeee iiianoeo. A
aeaiioth a?oiio aoiaeyo ?aciiia?aciua ?anoiaeu, iaeie ec eioi?uo
niinianoaotho aeinoeaeaieth a aeaea enoeiu, ananoi?iiiaio, i?aaeeueiiio
e naiaa?aiaiiiio ?anniio?aieth e ?ac?aoaieth aeaea (aac. 2, 3, 5, 6),
ae?oaea aea iinyo ii?aaeaeaiiue i?aaaioeaiue oa?aeoa? (aac. 7),
i?aaeinoa?aaay a?aaeaeai iiaeaaaoue iaiainiiaaiiua enee eeai iaia?aiii
caoyaeaaoue noaeaaiue i?ioeann.
Ii n?aaiaieth n AIE ?NON? ia?a/aiue ecaea?aeae, naycaiiuo n
?anniio?aieai aeaea, nouanoaaiii ?anoe?eeny. E?iia oiai, a ioee/ea io
AIE ?NON?, a iiaii AIE ia?a/aiue oaeeo ecaea?aeae yaeyaony ioe?uoui,
iaeiaei i?eciaoue oa eee eiua ?anoiaeu ecaea?aeeaie, naycaiiuie n
?anniio?aieai aeaea, iiaeao oieueei noae.
I?aaeaea anaai eeoeai, niinianoaothuei inouanoaeaieth i?aainoaeey, –
naeaeaoaeyi, yenia?oai, niaoeeaeenoai e ia?aaiae/eeai – eiiiaine?othony
i?iecaaaeaiiua eie ?anoiaeu, iaiaoiaeeiua aeey yaee a noae e eniieiaiey
aiceiaeaiiuo ia ieo iaycaiiinoae.
Ii?yaeie e ?acia?u aiciauaiey ?anoiaeia e auieaou aiciaa?aaeaeaiey
eeoeai a nayce n eo auciaii a noae o?aaoee?iaaiu Eino?oeoeeae i ii?yaeea
e ?acia?ao aiciauaiey ?anoiaeia e auieaou aiciaa?aaeaeaiey eeoeai a
nayce n eo auciaii a i?aaiu aeiciaiey, i?aaeaa?eoaeueiiai neaaenoaey,
i?ieo?aoo?o eee a noae, ooaa?aeaeaiiie iinoaiiaeaieai Niaaoa Ieieno?ia
?NON? io 14.07.90 N 245 (a ?aae. io 02.03.93) (aeaeaa – Eino?oeoeey).
Niaeanii i. 5 Eino?oeoeee naeaeaoaeyi, yenia?oai, niaoeeaeenoai e
ia?aaiae/eeai iiea/eaaaony eae i?iacae e ianoo yaee a noae, oae e
ia?aoiue i?iacae e ianoo iinoiyiiiai aeeoaeuenoaa. ?acia? auieao
ii?aaeaeyaony ia iniiaaiee i?iacaeiuo aeieoiaioia, ii ia iiaeao
i?aauoaoue noieiinoue i?iacaea a ieaoeea?oiii (eoiaeiii) aaaiia ii
aeaeaciie aei?iaa; eeai, anee eeoei aeiae?aaony aiaeiui o?ainii?oii, –
noieiinoue i?iacaea a eathoao, iiea/eaaaiuo ii V-VIII a?oiiai oa?eoiuo
noaaie ia noaeao ii?neiai oeioa, e a eathoa III eaoaai?ee ia noaeao
?a/iiai oeioa. I?iacae ii oinnaeiui e a?oioiaui aei?iaai iiea/eaaaony a
i?aaeaeao noieiinoe i?iacaea o?ainii?oii iauanoaaiiiai iieueciaaiey
(e?iia oaene); i?e iieueciaaiee aicaeooiui o?ainii?oii aiciauaaony
noieiinoue aeeaoa iau/iiai (oo?enoe/aneiai) eeanna.
Iiieii ?anoiaeia ia i?iacae i?e i?aaenoaaeaiee niioaaonoaothueo
aeieoiaioia aiciauathony no?aoiaua ieaoaaee ii ainoaea?noaaiiiio
iaycaoaeueiiio no?aoiaaieth iannaaee?ia ia o?ainii?oa, noieiinoue
i?aaeaa?eoaeueiie i?iaeaaee i?iacaeiuo aeieoiaioia, a oaeaea cao?aou ca
iieueciaaiea a iiacaeao iinoaeueiuie i?eiaaeeaaeiinoyie. E?iia oiai,
iiea/eaathony ?anoiaeu ii i?iacaeo aaoio?ainii?oii (e?iia oaene) e
aeaeaciiaei?iaeiie noaioeee, i?enoaie, ay?iae?iio, anee iie iaoiaeyony
ca /a?oie ianaeaiiiai ioieoa.
N ?ac?aoaiey noaea naeaeaoaeyi, yenia?oai, niaoeeaeenoai e ia?aaiae/eeai
i?e iai?aaenoaaeaiee i?iacaeiuo aeieoiaioia iiea/eaaaony ieieiaeueiay
noieiinoue i?iacaea iaaeaeo ianoii iinoiyiiiai aeeoaeuenoaa e ianoii
yaee.
Aiciauaiea ?anoiaeia ii iaeio aeeeiai iiiauaiey, iieaoa nooi/iuo
naeaeaoaeyi, yenia?oai, niaoeeaeenoai e ia?aaiae/eeai ca aeie auciaa a
noae aeeth/aao a?aiy a iooe, auoiaeiua e i?acaeie/iua aeie, a oaeaea
a?aiy auioaeaeaiiie inoaiiaee a iooe, iiaeoaa?aeaeaiiie
niioaaonoaothueie aeieoiaioaie e i?iecaiaeeony i?eiaieoaeueii e
ii?yaeeo, onoaiiaeaiiiio caeiiiaeaoaeuenoaii i aiciauaiee
eiiaiaee?iai/iuo ?anoiaeia. Niaeanii i?eeaco Ieienoa?noaa oeiainia ?O io
06.07.01 N 49i “Ia eciaiaiee ii?i aiciauaiey eiiaiaee?iai/iuo ?anoiaeia
ia oa??eoi?ee ?inneeneie Oaaea?aoeee” (a ?aae. io 09.11.01 N 91i) n 1
yiaa?y 2002 a. aaaaeaiu a aeaenoaea neaaeothuea ii?iu aiciauaiey
eiiaiaee?iai/iuo ?anoiaeia:
iieaoa iaeia aeeeiai iiiauaiey inouanoaeyaony ii oaeoe/aneei ?anoiaeai,
iiaeoaa?aeaeaiiui niioaaonoaothueie aeieoiaioaie, ii ia aieaa 550 ?oa. a
nooee. I?e ionoonoaee iiaeoaa?aeaeathueo aeieoiaioia ?anoiaeu ii iaeio
aeeeiai iiiauaiey aiciauathony a ?acia?a 12 ?oa. a nooee;
iieaoa nooi/iuo i?iecaiaeeony a ?acia?a 100 ?oa. ca eaaeaeue aeaiue
iaoiaeaeaiey a eiiaiaee?iaea.
Iiaeeaaeeo aiciauaieth ieaoa ca a?iie?iaaiea iano a ainoeieoeao a
?acia?a 50% io aiciauaaiie noieiinoe ianoa ca nooee. Nooi/iua ia
auiea/eaathony, anee o ia?a/eneaiiuo a AIE eeoe eiaaony aiciiaeiinoue
aaeaaeiaaii aica?auaoueny e ianoo iinoiyiiiai aeeoaeuenoaa (i. 6
Eino?oeoeee).
Iiieii ?anoiaeia ii yaea naeaeaoaeyi eiiiaine?oaony e iioa?y a?aiaie.
?aaioathuei a?aaeaeaiai-naeaeaoaeyi i?aaeoniio?aii nio?aiaiea n?aaeiaai
ca?aaioea ii ianoo eo ?aaiou ca ana a?aiy, cao?a/aiiia eie a nayce n
auciaii a noae. Niaeanii i. 2 Eino?oeoeee n?aaeiee ca?aaioie nio?aiyaony
ca ana ?aai/ea aeie iaaeaee ii a?aoeeo, onoaiiaeaiiiio ii ianoo
iinoiyiiie ?aaiou.
Aiciaa?aaeaeaiea naeaeaoaeyi, ia ninoiyuei a o?oaeiauo ioiioaieyo, ca
ioaea/aiea eo io iau/iuo caiyoee auiea/eaaaony a ?acia?a nooi/iuo,
onoaiiaeaiiuo aeey neoaeaaiuo eiiaiaee?iaie (i. 8 Eino?oeoeee).
Auieaoa aiciaa?aaeaeaiey ca o?oae yenia?oia e niaoeeaeenoia iinoaaeaia
a caaeneiinoue io oiai, auiieiytho ee iie oaeoth ?aaioo a ?aieao naieo
neoaeaaiuo iaycaiiinoae eae ?aaioieee ainoaea?noaaiiie i?aaiecaoeee eee
iao. Ainoaea?noaaiiua i?aaiecaoeee a iaeanoe yenia?oiie aeayoaeueiinoe –
ainoaea?noaaiiua noaeaaii-yenia?oiua o/?aaeaeaiey, niaoeeaeece?iaaiiua
o/?aaeaeaiey oaaea?aeueiuo i?aaiia eniieieoaeueiie aeanoe, i?aaiia
eniieieoaeueiie aeanoe noauaeoia ?O, nicaeaiiua aeey iaania/aiey
eniieiaiey iieiiii/ee noaeia, noaeae, i?aaiia aeiciaiey, eeoe,
i?iecaiaeyueo aeiciaiea, neaaeiaaoaeae e i?ieo?i?ia iin?aaenoaii
i?aaiecaoeee e i?iecaiaenoaa noaeaaiie yenia?oecu, a oaeaea yenia?oiua
iiae?acaeaeaiey, nicaeaiiua oaaea?aeueiuie i?aaiaie eniieieoaeueiie
aeanoe eee i?aaiaie eniieieoaeueiie aeanoe noauaeoia ?O (no. 11
Oaaea?aeueiiai caeiia io 31.05.01 N 73-OC “I ainoaea?noaaiiie
noaeaaii-yenia?oiie aeayoaeueiinoe a ?inneeneie Oaaea?aoeee”.
Aiciaa?aaeaeaiea auiea/eaaaony eeoue a oii neo/aa, eiaaea ?aaioa ia
aoiaeeo a e?oa neoaeaaiuo iaycaiiinoae yenia?oia e niaoeeaeenoia.
Auieaoa aiciaa?aaeaeaiey aiaooaoiui yenia?oai ca i?iaaaeaiea yenia?oecu,
niaoeeaeenoai ca o/anoea a noaeaaiii ?acae?aoaeuenoaa i?iecaiaeeony
niaeanii caeeth/aiiiio aeiaiai?o (i. 9 Eino?oeoeee).
I?aainoaeea ii a?aaeaeaineei aeaeai inouanoaeyaony ia iniiaa
ninoycaoaeueiinoe noi?ii (no. 12 AIE). Aeaiiue i?eioeei, a /anoiinoe,
icia/aao, /oi eaaeaeay ec noi?ii iaycaia i?aaenoaaeoue e aeieacaoue oa
ianoiyoaeuenoaa, ia eioi?uo iia iniiauaaao naie o?aaiaaiey eee
aic?aaeaiey. Aeey yoiai iiaeao iio?aaiaaoueny i?iaaaeaiea yenia?oecu,
i?eaea/aiea naeaeaoaeae eee niaoeeaeenoia. A ea/anoaa iauaai i?aaeea AIE
i?aaeoniao?eaaao, /oi noaeaaiua ?anoiaeu ianoo noi?iiu (ni. /. 1 no.
98), iiyoiio eiae/iui i?aaenoaaeyaony aiceiaeaiea ia ieo e aaaine?iaaiey
oaeeo ?anoiaeia. Aei oao ii?, iiea aeaei ia aoaeao ?anniio?aii e
?ac?aoaii ii nouanoao, ia i?aaenoaaeyaony aiciiaeiui ii?aaeaeeoue, eae
?ani?aaeaeyony noaeaaiua ?anoiaeu iaaeaeo noi?iiaie, iiyoiio AIE
cae?aieyao, /oi i?aaeaa?eoaeueioth iieaoo ?anoiaeia inouanoaeyao oa
noi?iia, eioi?ay cayaeea niioaaonoaothuoth i?inueao, a i?e niaianoiie
i?inueaa – noi?iiu a ?aaiuo /anoyo.
*anoueth 2 no. 96 AIE eciaiai nouanoaiaaaoee ?aiaa ii?yaeie aiciauaiey
?anoiaeia i?e auiieiaiee i?ioeannoaeueiuo aeaenoaee ii eieoeeaoeaa
noaea. Niaeanii /. 1 no. 88 AIE ?NON? ?anoiaeu, iaiaoiaeeiua ia
i?iaaaeaiea niioaaonoaothueo aeaenoaee, aaaine?iaaeenue noi?iiaie. N
i?eiyoeai AIE a oii neo/aa, anee ia?a/eneaiiua a /. 2 no. 96 AIE
i?ioeannoaeueiua aeaenoaey niaa?oathony ii eieoeeaoeaa noaea, ?anoiaeu
ii eo iieaoa aiceaaathony ia niioaaonoaothuee athaeaeao. Niaeanii /. 3
no. 4 caeiia i noaeaaiie nenoaia Aa?oiaiue Noae ?O, aa?oiaiua noaeu
?anioaeee, e?aaaua e iaeanoiua noaeu, noaeu ai?iaeia oaaea?aeueiiai
cia/aiey, noaeu aaoiiiiiie iaeanoe e aaoiiiiiuo ie?oaia, ?aeiiiua noaeu,
aiaiiua e niaoeeaeece?iaaiiua noaeu ioiinyony e oaaea?aeueiui noaeai e
ninoaaeytho nenoaio oaaea?aeueiuo noaeia iauae th?enaeeeoeee, iiyoiio
?anoiaeu, i?iecaaaeaiiua ii eieoeeaoeaa yoeo noaeia, aiceaaathony ia
oaaea?aeueiue athaeaeao. Ie?iaua noaeuee ioiinyony e noaeai noauaeoia ?O
e yaeythony noaeueyie iauae th?enaeeeoeee noauaeoia ?O (/. 4 no. 4
Caeiia i noaeaaiie nenoaia). I?aaenoaaeyaony, /oi eiaiii ia yoii
iniiaaiee /. 2 no. 96 AIE i?aaeoniao?eaaao, /oi a neo/aa iacia/aiey
i?ioeannoaeueiuo aeaenoaee ie?iauie noaeueyie iaiaoiaeeiua aeey eo
i?iecaiaenoaa ?anoiaeu aiceaaathony ia athaeaeao niioaaonoaothuaai
noauaeoa ?O. A aeaiiie /anoe iieiaeaiey AIE iiaoo aieoe a i?ioeai?a/ea n
Oaaea?aeueiui caeiiii io 10.02.99 N 30-OC “I oeiaine?iaaiee noaeia
?inneeneie Oaaea?aoeee”. Niaeanii i. 1 no. 1 iacaaiiiai Caeiia noaeu
?inneeneie Oaaea?aoeee oeiaine?othony oieueei ca n/ao n?aaenoa
oaaea?aeueiiai athaeaeaoa.
Niaa?oaiea ia?a/eneaiiuo a no. 96 AIE i?ioeannoaeueiuo aeaenoaee
i?ecaaii niinianoaiaaoue aeinoeaeaieth enoeiu e auianaieth i?aainoaeiiai
e iainiiaaiiiai ?aoaiey, iiyoiio noi?iia ia iiaeao eeoeoueny oaeie
aiciiaeiinoe a nayce n ionoonoaeai n?aaenoa ia iieaoo niioaaonoaothueo
aeaenoaee. A aeaiiii neo/aa iia aeieaeia ia?aoeoueny e noaeo (ie?iaiio
noaeuea) n i?inueaie i iacia/aiee ii?aaeaeaiiiai i?ioeannoaeueiiai
aeaenoaey e oiaeaoaenoaiaaoue ia inaiaiaeaeaiee io oieaou iaiaoiaeeiuo
?anoiaeia eee ia oiaiueoaiee eo ?acia?a. Eco/ea i?aaenoaaeaiiua noi?iiie
aeieacaoaeuenoaa oyaeaeiai eiouanoaaiiiai iieiaeaiey, noae aeieaeai
i?eiyoue ?aoaiea ia oaeiaeaoai?aiee niioaaonoaothuaai oiaeaoaenoaa eee
ia ioeaca a iai. Niaeanii no. 104 AIE ii?aaeaeaiea noaea iiaeao auoue
iaaeaeiaaii. Anee ?aoaiea ia inaiaiaeaeaiee noi?iiu io oieaou noaeaaiuo
?anoiaeia (oiaiueoaiee eo ?acia?a) i?eieiaaony oaaea?aeueiui noaeii
iauae th?enaeeeoeee, oaeea ?anoiaeu inouanoaeythony ca n/ao n?aaenoa
oaaea?aeueiiai athaeaeaoa; anee niioaaonoaothuaa ?aoaiea i?eieiaao
ie?iaie noaeuey – ca n/ao n?aaenoa athaeaeaoa noauaeoa ?O.
Iaeia ec aaaeiaeoeo aa?aioee i?aaeeueiiai e naiaa?aiaiiiai ?anniio?aiey
e ?ac?aoaiey a?aaeaeaineeo aeae – ycue, ia eioi?ii aaaeaony
a?aaeaeaineia noaeii?iecaiaenoai. Eeoeai, o/anoaothuei a aeaea e ia
aeaaeathuei ycueii, ia eioi?ii aaaeaony a?aaeaeaineia
noaeii?iecaiaenoai, iaania/eaaaony i?aai iieueciaaoueny oneoaaie
ia?aaiae/eea (/. 2 no. 9 AIE), iieaoa oneoa eioi?iai inouanoaeyaony ca
n/ao n?aaenoa niioaaonoaothuaai athaeaeaoa. A aeaiiii neo/aa neaaeoao
ia?aoeoue iniaia aieiaiea ia oio oaeo, /oi iieaoa oneoa ia?aaiae/eea
inouanoaeyaony oieueei ca n/ao athaeaeaoiuo n?aaenoa, noi?iiu a ianaiee
aeaiiuo ?anoiaeia ia o/anoaotho (n?. /. 1 no. 95 e /. 1 no. 96).
?acia?u noii, iiaeeaaeaueo auieaoa naeaeaoaeyi, ia?aaiae/eeai, a oaeaea
yenia?oai e niaoeeaeenoai, e ii?yaeie eo auieaou onoaiiaeaiu
Eino?oeoeeae i ii?yaeea e ?acia?ao aiciauaiey ?anoiaeia e auieaou
aiciaa?aaeaeaiey eeoeai a nayce n eo auciaii a i?aaiu aeiciaiey,
i?aaeaa?eoaeueiiai neaaenoaey, i?ieo?aoo?o eee a noae, ooaa?aeaeaiiie
iinoaiiaeaieai Niaaoa Ieieno?ia ?NON? io 14.07.90 N 245 (a ?aae. io
02.03.93 Eiiiaioa?ee e A?aaeaeaineiio i?ioeannoaeueiiio eiaeaeno
?inneeneie Oaaea?aoeee (Ioa. ?aae. A.I.Eaeeaa), TH?aeo-Ecaeao, 2002.
Aeaaa 7. Auieaoa aiciaa?aaeaeaiey naeaeaoaeyi, ia?aaiae/eeai, a oaeaea
yenia?oai e niaoeeaeenoai ca auiieiaiioth eie ?aaioo, a oaeaea
aiciauaiea oeacaiiui eeoeai ?anoiaeia ii yaea niaeanii ?acae. IV
iacaaiiie Eino?oeoeee i?iecaiaeeony ii ii?aaeaeaieth noaea. Noiiu,
iiaeeaaeauea auieaoa ia?a/eneaiiui eeoeai, auiea/eaathony noaeii
iaiaaeeaiii ii auiieiaiee yoeie eeoeaie naieo iaycaiiinoae iacaaeneii io
oaeoe/aneiai iieo/aiey e acuneaiey ni noi?ii noaeaaiuo ?anoiaeia ii
a?aaeaeaineei aeaeai.
Aiciauaiea ?anoiaeia aiaiiineoaeaueo, aucuaaaiuo a noae a ea/anoaa
naeaeaoaeae, yenia?oia, niaoeeaeenoia e ia?aaiae/eeia (noieiinoue
i?iacaea e ianoo auciaa e ia?aoii, ?anoiaeu ii iaeio aeeeiai iiiauaiey,
nooi/iua), i?iecaiaeeony ii o?aaiaaieth aieneiauo /anoae ii
onoaiiaeaiiui ii?iai. Naiei aiaiiineoaeauei noae ieeaeeo ?anoiaeia ia
aiciauaao.
No. 98 AIE onoaiaaeeaaao ii?yaeie ?ani?aaeaeaiey noaeaaiuo ?anoiaeia
iaaeaeo noi?iiaie. A ea/anoaa iauaai i?aaeea cae?aieaii, /oi a?aiy
?anoiaeia, e eioi?ui ioiineony eae ainoaea?noaaiiay iioeeia, oae e
ecaea?aeee, naycaiiua n ?anniio?aieai aeaea, ianao noi?iia, i?iea?aaoay
aeaei, eeai eaaeaeay ec noi?ii i?iii?oeeiiaeueii ?acia?o
oaeiaeaoai?aiiuo o?aaiaaiee. I?e yoii neaaeoao eiaoue a aeaeo, /oi
i?aaeea, onoaiiaeaiiua /. 1 no. 98 AIE, ?ani?ino?aiythony oaeaea ia
nienooeia, niioaao/eeia e o?aoueeo eeoe, cayaeythueo naiinoiyoaeueiua
o?aaiaaiey ia i?aaeiao nii?a.
*anoe 2 e 3 no. 98 AIE ?ani?ino?aiytho ii?yaeie ?ani?aaeaeaiey
noaeaaiuo ?anoiaeia iaaeaeo noi?iiaie, onoaiiaeaiiue aeey noaeia ia?aie
einoaioeee, ia neo/ae ?ani?aaeaeaiey noaeaaiuo ?anoiaeia, iiianaiiuo
noi?iiaie i?e ?anniio?aiey aeaea a aiaeeyoeeiiiie e eannaoeeiiiie
einoaioeeyo.
Niaeanii /. 5 no. 198 AIE ?aciethoeaiay /anoue ?aoaiey noaea aeieaeia
niaea?aeaoue oeacaiea ia ?ani?aaeaeaiea noaeaaiuo ?anoiaeia. A oii
neo/aa, eiaaea noae auoanoiyuae einoaioeee ?ac?aoaao aeaei ii nouanoao,
ii oaeaea aeieaeai niioaaonoaothuei ia?acii ?aoeoue aii?in i iiaii
?ani?aaeaeaiee noaeaaiuo ?anoiaeia. AIE ?NON? a no. 90 iaeiicia/ii
onoaiaaeeaae, /oi ?aoaiea i ia?a?ani?aaeaeaiee noaeaaiuo ?anoiaeia
i?eieiae noae auoanoiyuae einoaioeee. Niaeanii /. 3 no. 98 AIE a oii
neo/aa, anee auoanoiyuay noaeaaiay einoaioeey ia eciaieea ?aoaiea a
/anoe ?ani?aaeaeaiey noaeaaiuo ?anoiaeia, oaeia ?aoaiea aeieaeai
i?eiyoue noae ia?aie einoaioeee. Aeaiiay iiaaeea aucuaaao ii?aaeaeaiiua
niiiaiey, iineieueeo i?aaeinoaaeyao ieaeanoiyuaio noaeo i?eieiaoue
?aoaiea, eioi?ia ii nooe i?iecaiaeii io ?aoaiey noaea auoanoiyuae
einoaioeee. E?iia oiai, iaiiiyoii, eae aeaiiay ii?ia aoaeao
ei??aniiiaee?iaaoueny n iieiaeaieyie /. 1 no. 201 AIE, niaeanii eioi?ie
noae, i?eiyaoee ?aoaiea ii aeaeo, iiaeao ii naiae eieoeeaoeaa eee ii
cayaeaieth eeoe, o/anoaothueo a aeaea, i?eiyoue aeiiieieoaeueiia ?aoaiea
a oii neo/aa, eiaaea ei ia ?ac?aoai aii?in i noaeaaiuo ?anoiaeao.
A oii neo/aa, eiaaea noae eannaoeeiiiie einoaioeee ii ?acoeueoaoai
?anniio?aiey eannaoeeiiiie aeaeiau (i?aaenoaaeaiey) ioiaieo ?aoaiea
noaea ia?aie einoaioeee iieiinoueth eee a /anoe e iai?aaeo aeaei ia
iiaia ?anniio?aiea a noae ia?aie einoaioeee (no. 361 Eiaeaena), ?aoaiea
i ?ani?aaeaeaiee noaeaaiuo ?anoiaeia i?eieiaao noae ia?aie einoaioeee.
Ii?iu i acuneaiee eiiiainaoeee ca iioa?th a?aiaie iinyo i?aaaioeaiue
oa?aeoa?, iineieueeo i?aaeoniao?eaatho iaaeaaii?eyoiua i?aaiaua
iineaaenoaey aeey noi?ii, ceioiio?aaeythueo naieie i?ioeannoaeueiuie
i?aaaie. Aiaeiae/iay ii?ia niaea?aeaeanue e a no. 92 AIE ?NON?:
eiiiainaoeey acuneeaaeanue ca oaeoe/aneoth iioa?th a?aiaie, i?e/ai
ii?aaeaeaiea ?acia?a oaeie eiiiainaoeee auei ioaeaii ia oniio?aiea
noaea. Eae aeaeii ec oaenoa AIE nio?aiai aiaeiae/iue iiaeoiae.
Iaaeia?iniaanoiinoue niaa?oaiey aeiiaiie noi?iiie aeaenoaee,
ia?a/eneaiiuo a no. 91 AIE, a oaeaea iaee/ea oaeoe/aneie iioa?e a?aiaie
o ae?oaie noi?iiu aeieaeiu auoue iiaeoaa?aeaeaiu aeieacaoaeuenoaaie. I?e
ii?aaeaeaiee ?acia?a oaeie eiiiainaoeee noae ii aiaeiaee iiaeao
ainiieueciaaoueny i?aaeeaie, cae?aieaiiuie a /. 2 no. 95 AIE.
Aeey aiciauaiey ?anoiaeia ia iieaoo oneoa i?aaenoaaeoaey noi?iia, a
iieueco eioi?ie ninoiyeinue ?aoaiea, aeieaeia ia?aoeoueny n
niioaaonoaothuei ienueiaiiui oiaeaoaenoaii a noae, oeacaa noiio
aiciauaiey e i?eeiaeea aeieoiaiou, iiaeoaa?aeaeathuea iiianaiiua
?anoiaeu. Oae, iai?eia?, anee a ea/anoaa i?aaenoaaeoaey noi?iiu a noaea
aunooiae aaeaieao, ii inouanoaeye caueoo aa eioa?ania ia iniiaaiee
aeiaiai?a ii?o/aiey. Nouanoaaiiuie oneiaeyie oaeiai aeiaiai?a yaeythony
oneiaey auieaou aeiaa?eoaeai aiciaa?aaeaeaiey ca ieacuaaaioth
th?eaee/aneoth iiiiuue, a oaeaea ii?yaeie e ?acia? eiiiainaoeee
?anoiaeia aaeaieaoa, naycaiiuo n eniieiaieai ii?o/aiey (i. 4 no. 25
Caeiia ia aaeaieaoo?a). Ia iniiaaiee i?aaenoaaeaiiiai oiaeaoaenoaa i
i?enoaeaeaiee n ae?oaie noi?iiu ?anoiaeia a i?aaeaeao, ii?aaeaeaiiuo
aeiaiai?ii, noae aeieaeai aoaeao auianoe niioaaonoaothuaa ii?aaeaeaiea.
A oii neo/aa, anee noiia ieaaeaony iaii?aaaeaiii aieueoie, noae aeieaeai
aoaeao ii?aaeaeeoue iiaoth noiio, i?eaioe?oynue ia n?aaeiee o?iaaiue
iieaou iiaeiaiuo oneoa i?e n?aaieiuo ianoiyoaeuenoaao.
Niaeanii i. 1 no. 26 Caeiia ia aaeaieaoo?a th?eaee/aneay iiiiuue
a?aaeaeaiai ?inneeneie Oaaea?aoeee, n?aaeiaaeooaaie aeioiae eioi?uo
ieaea aaee/eiu i?iaeeoi/iiai ieieioia, onoaiiaeaiiiai caeiiii noauaeoa
?O, ieacuaaaony aanieaoii a neaaeothueo neo/ayo:
1) enooeai – ii ?anniao?eaaaiui noaeaie ia?aie einoaioeee aeaeai i
acuneaiee aeeiaioia, aiciauaiee a?aaea, i?e/eiaiiiai nia?oueth
ei?ieeueoea, oaa/ueai eee eiui iia?aaeaeaieai caei?iauey, naycaiiui n
o?oaeiaie aeayoaeueiinoueth;
2) aaoa?aiai Aaeeeie Ioa/anoaaiiie aieiu – ii aii?inai, ia naycaiiui n
i?aaei?eieiaoaeueneie aeayoaeueiinoueth;
3) a?aaeaeaiai ?inneeneie Oaaea?aoeee – i?e ninoaaeaiee cayaeaiee i
iacia/aiee iainee e iiniaee;
4) a?aaeaeaiai ?inneeneie Oaaea?aoeee, iino?aaeaaoei io iieeoe/aneeo
?ai?annee, – ii aii?inai, naycaiiui n ?aaaeeeoaoeeae.
I?e yoii Caeii ia aaeaieaoo?a (i. 8 no. 25) i?aaeoniao?eaaao iieaoo
o?oaea aaeaieaoa ca n/ao n?aaenoa oaaea?aeueiiai athaeaeaoa eeoue a oii
neo/aa, eiaaea aaeaieao o/anoaoao a ea/anoaa caueoieea a oaieiaiii
noaeii?iecaiaenoaa ii iacia/aieth i?aaiia aeiciaiey, i?aaeaa?eoaeueiiai
neaaenoaey, i?ieo?i?a eee noaea. Ai anao inoaeueiuo neo/ayo ?anoiaeu
iiea/eaathony aaeaieaoneei ia?aciaaieai, /eaiii (o/?aaeeoaeai) eioi?iai
aaeaieao yaeyaony, e oaeia iauaaeeiaiea a i?aaeoniio?aiiii a /. 2 no.
100 AIE neo/aa eiaao i?aai ia niioaaonoaothuoth eiiiainaoeeth iiianaiiuo
?anoiaeia.
Ia iniiaaiee /. 1 no. 39 AIE enooeo i?eiaaeeaaeeo oaeia aaaeiia
?anii?yaeeoaeueiia i?aai i?aaeiaoii nii?a, eae ioeac io enea, o.a.
enoaoe ioeacuaaaony io naiaai iaoa?eaeueii-i?aaiaiai o?aaiaaiey e
ioaao/eeo e oo?a/eaaao eioa?an e i?iaeieaeaieth i?ioeanna. A yoii neo/aa
enoaoe ia oieueei ia iieo/aao eiiiainaoeeth io ioaao/eea ca iiianaiiua
?anoiaeu, ii e iaycai aicianoeoue iineaaeiaio ana ?anoiaeu, naycaiiua n
aaaeaieai aeaea. Anee aea ioaao/ee ia iniiaaiee /. 1 no. 39 AIE i?eciaao
ene e, ia aeiaeeaeaynue auianaiey ?aoaiey, a aeia?iaieueiii ii?yaeea
oaeiaeaoai?eo o?aaiaaiey enooea, enoaoe iiaeao i?ineoue o noaea
i?enoaeeoue n ioaao/eea aiciauaiea anao iiianaiiuo ii aeaeo noaeaaiuo
?anoiaeia.
Ia iniiaaiee /. 1 no. 39 AIE noi?iiu iiaoo ieii/eoue aeaei ie?iaui
niaeaoaieai. Ie?iaia niaeaoaiea i?aaenoaaeyao niaie niaeaoaiea noi?ii i
i?ae?auaiee noaeaaiiai nii?a ia ii?aaeaeaiiuo oneiaeyo. Oneiaey
oi?ioee?othony ia iniiaaiee acaeiiuo onooiie noi?ii, iooai i?eciaiey
ioaao/eeii ni?aaaaeeeainoe o?aaiaaiee enooea (/anoe o?aaiaaiee) e
iaeiia?aiaiii niaeaoaiey enooea n iaeioi?uie aic?aaeaieyie ioaao/eea
i?ioea cayaeaiiuo o?aaiaaiee. A aeaiiii neo/aa aiceiaeeoue noaeaaiua
?anoiaeu ia iaeio noi?iio auei au iani?aaaaeeeai, iiyoiio /. 2 no. 101
AIE i?aaeoniao?eaaao, /oi a ie?iaii niaeaoaiee oaeaea aeieaeiu
niaea?aeaoueny oneiaey i ii?yaeea ?ani?aaeaeaiey noaeaaiuo ?anoiaeia.
Anee ie?iaia niaeaoaiea iiaeiaiuo iieiaeaiee ia niaea?aeeo, /. 2 no. 101
AIE onoaiaaeeaaao i?aaeea, eioi?uie aeieaeai ?oeiaiaenoaiaaoueny noae
i?e ?ani?aaeaeaiee noaeaaiuo ?anoiaeia iaaeaeo enooeii e ioaao/eeii.
A ioee/ea io ?ani?aaeaeaiey noaeaaiuo ?anoiaeia, i?aaeoniio?aiiuo no.
98 AIE, eioi?ua aiciauathony ca n/ao n?aaenoa noi?ii, no. 102 AIE
onoaiaaeeaaao neo/ae aiciauaiey noi?iiai noaeaaiuo ?anoiaeia ca n/ao
n?aaenoa niioaaonoaothuaai athaeaeaoa. Niaeanii /. 2 no. 45 e /. 2 no.
46 AIE i?ieo?i? e eiua eeoea, eioi?ui i?aaeinoaaeaii i?aai ia?auaoueny a
noae a caueoo i?aa, naiaiae e io?aiyaiuo caeiiii eioa?ania ae?oaeo eeoe,
i?e niioaaonoaothuai ia?auaiee a noae inaiaiaeaeathony io oieaou
noaeaaiuo ?anoiaeia. Anee a oaeiaeaoai?aiee cayaeaiiuo o?aaiaaiee (eo
/anoe) iacaaiiui eeoeai aoaeao ioeacaii, /. 1 no. 102 AIE cae?aieyao ca
ioaao/eeii i?aai o?aaiaaoue aiciauaiey ca n/ao n?aaenoa
niioaaonoaothuaai athaeaeaoa iiianaiiuo ?anoiaeia, i?iii?oeeiiaeueiuo
oie /anoe eneiauo o?aaiaaiee, a eioi?ie enooeo auei ioeacaii.
I?e yoii ?anoiaeu ii ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeia a neo/aa ia?auaiey a
Aa?oiaiue Noae ?O eiaeaony ia oaaea?aeueiue athaeaeao, ai anao
inoaeueiuo neo/ayo – ia ianoiue athaeaeao. Niaeanii /. 2 no. 96 AIE
ecaea?aeee, naycaiiua n ?anniio?aieai aeaea, eiiiaine?othony ca n/ao
n?aaenoa oaaea?aeueiiai athaeaeaoa, ca eneeth/aieai neo/aaa ?anniio?aiey
aeaea ie?iaui noaeueae – oiaaea iie aiciauathony ca n/ao n?aaenoa
athaeaeaoa noauaeoa ?O, ia oa??eoi?ee eioi?iai aeaenoaoao ie?iaie
noaeuey.
?anniio?aiea noaeaie eneia ia inaiaiaeaeaiee eiouanoaa io a?anoa –
aaaeiay aa?aioey io?aiu eioa?ania ainoaea?noaa e eiouanoaaiiuo i?aa
i?aaiecaoeee e a?aaeaeai.
A?ano ia eiouanoai iiaeao auoue iaeiaeai a ii?yaeea i?eiaiaiey ia? ii
iaania/aieth enea, ia?auaiey acuneaiey ia eiouanoai aeieaeieea ai
eniieiaiea ?aoaiey noaea, eeai eiaaea iioa?eonii i?iecaaaeaia iienue eae
ia?a ii io?aia ianeaaenoaaiiiai eiouanoaa, a oaeaea a eiuo
i?aaeoniio?aiiuo caeiiii neo/ayo. Niaeanii i. 4 iinoaiiaeaiey Ieaioia
Aa?oiaiiai Noaea NNN? io 31.03.78 N 4 “I i?eiaiaiee caeiiiaeaoaeuenoaa
i?e ?anniio?aiee noaeaie aeae ia inaiaiaeaeaiee eiouanoaa io a?anoa
(eneeth/aiee ec iiene)” (a ?aae. io 30.11.90) ene ia inaiaiaeaeaiee
eiouanoaa io a?anoa iiaeao auoue i?aaeuyaeai nianoaaiieeii, a oaeaea
eeoeii, aeaaeathuei a neeo caeiia eee aeiaiai?a eiouanoaii, ia
i?eiaaeeaaeauei aeieaeieeo. Ioaao/eeaie ii oaeei eneai yaeythony
aeieaeiee, o eioi?iai i?iecaaaeai a?ano eiouanoaa, e oa i?aaiecaoeee eee
eeoea, a eioa?anao eioi?uo iaeiaeai a?ano ia eiouanoai. Iiianaiiua
enooeii ?anoiaeu aiciauathony ca n/ao athaeaeaoiuo n?aaenoa Aiciauaiea
?anoiaeia ia i?aaenoaaeoaeuenoai a noaea (O.A. Naaeiei, “Aooaaeoa?neee
o/ao”, N 19, ieoya?ue 2002 a.)
.
No. 103 AIE onoaiaaeeaaao ii?yaeie aiciauaiey noaeaaiuo ?anoiaeia,
iiianaiiuo noaeii i?e ?anniio?aiee aeaea. E oaeei ?anoiaeai ioiinyony
ainoaea?noaaiiay iioeeia e ecaea?aeee, naycaiiua n ?anniio?aieai aeaea,
io oieaou eioi?uo enoaoe eee ioaao/ee auee inaiaiaeaeaiu ia iniiaaiee
no. 89, /. 3 no. 96 AIE, a oaeaea i. 1, 2 no. 5 Caeiia i
ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeia. I?aaenoaaeyaony, /oi aiaeiae/iia i?aaeei
aeieaeii aeaenoaiaaoue e i?e i?eiyoee noaeii ia iniiaaiee no. 90 e /. 3
no. 96 AIE ?aoaiey ia oiaiueoaiee ?acia?a ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu eee
ecaea?aeae, naycaiiuo n ?anniio?aieai aeaea.
Oae, iai?eia?, a neo/aa, anee enoaoe ia?aoeeny e noaeo n i?inueaie i
i?iaaaeaiee yenia?oecu a iaainoaea?noaaiiie yenia?oiie i?aaiecaoeee e
iaeiia?aiaiii a nayce n oyaeaeui iaoa?eaeueiui iieiaeaieai
oiaeaoaenoaiaae ia oiaiueoaiee ?acia?a noii, eioi?ua ii aeieaeai
caieaoeoue ca i?iaaaeaiea oaeie yenia?oecu, e noae oaeoth yenia?oeco
iacia/ee, oi aiciauaiea yenia?oo ?anoiaeia ii yaea a noae e auieaoa
aiciaa?aaeaeaiey ca ?aaioo /anoe/ii aoaeoo i?iecaiaeeoueny ec n?aaenoa
athaeaeaoa. Iaeiaei anee aiineaaenoaee ?aoaiea ii aeaeo aoaeao auianaii
a iieueco enooea, oi noae aeieaeai i?enoaeeoue ioaao/eeo aiciauaiea
auiea/aiiuo ec athaeaeaoa n?aaenoa.
Ioaeaeueiua iieiaeaiey no. 103 AIE iaaeinoaoi/ii niaeaniaaiu n ae?oaeie
noaoueyi AIE. Oae, no. 103 AIE onoaiaaeeaaao, /oi noiiu, acuneaiiua n
i?iea?aaoae i?ioeann noi?iiu, ca/eneythony a oaaea?aeueiue athaeaeao.
Iaeiaei a neo/aa, eiaaea ia iniiaaiee aac. 2 /. 2 no. 96 AIE
ii?aaeaeaiiua i?ioeannoaeueiua aeaenoaey i?iecaiaeyony ii eieoeeaoeaa
ie?iaiai noaeuee, niioaaonoaothuea ?anoiaeu inouanoaeythony ca n/ao
n?aaenoa athaeaeaoa noauaeoa ?O, ia oa??eoi?ee eioi?iai aeaenoaoao
ie?iaie noaeuey, a nayce n /ai iaiiiyoii, ii/aio eiiiainaoeey aoaeao
ca/eneyoueny a oaaea?aeueiue athaeaeao, a ia a athaeaeao noauaeoa ?O, ca
n/ao eioi?iai oaeea aeaenoaey auee inouanoaeaiu. Oaeaea aucuaaao aii?inu
iieiaeaiea /. 4 no. 100 AIE, niaeanii eioi?iio a oii neo/aa, anee iaa
noi?iiu inaiaiaeaeaiu io oieaou noaeaaiuo ?anoiaeia, ecaea?aeee,
iiianaiiua noaeii a nayce n ?anniio?aieai aeaea, aiciauathony ca n/ao
n?aaenoa oaaea?aeueiiai athaeaeaoa, a oi a?aiy eae ia iniiaaiee /. 2 e 3
no. 96 AIE noaeaaiua ?anoiaeu, io eioi?uo noi?iiu auee inaiaiaeaeaiu ii
?aoaieth ie?iaiai noaeuee, iiaeeaaeao aiciauaieth ca n/ao n?aaenoa
athaeaeaoa noauaeoa ?O.
*anoiay aeaeiaa ia ii?aaeaeaiea noaea (noaeuee) iiaeao auoue iiaeaia a
oa/aiea aeanyoe aeiae ni aeiy auianaiey niioaaonoaothuaai ii?aaeaeaiey.
Ii?yaeie iiaea/e e ?anniio?aiey /anoiie aeaeiau o?aaoee?iaai no. 331-335
(ii?aaeaeaiey ie?iaiai noaeuee) e no. 371-375 (ii?aaeaeaiey noaea ia?aie
einoaioeee) AIE.
Niaeanii iiaei. 16 i. 2 no. 5 Caeiia i ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeia
th?eaee/aneea eeoea e a?aaeaeaia i?e iiaea/a a noae /anoiuo aeaeia ia
ii?aaeaeaiey noaea inaiaiaeaeathony io oieaou ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu.
Aeaaa 2. Noaeaaiua oo?aou
§1. Iaeiaeaiea noaeaaiuo oo?aoia
Noaeaaiue oo?ao i?aaenoaaeyao niaie aeaiaaeiia acuneaiea, iaeaaaaiia
noaeii a ii?yaeea e ?acia?ao, i?aaeoniio?aiiuo AIE, a nayce n
iaeniieiaieai eeai iaiaaeeaaeauei eniieiaieai aiceiaeaiiuo ia
ii?aaeaeaiiuo eeoe i?ioeannoaeueiuo iaycaiiinoae. AIE i?aaeoniao?eaaao
i?eiaiaiea naieoeee a aeaea iaeiaeaiey noaeaaiuo oo?aoia:
ca iaauiieiaiea o?aaiaaiey noaea i i?aaenoaaeaiee aeieacaoaeuenoa ii
i?e/eiai, i?eciaiiui noaeii iaoaaaeeoaeueiuie (/. 3 no. 57);
ia?ooaiea iaeiaeaiiiai a ?aieao ia? ii iaania/aieth enea cai?aoa
niaa?oaoue ii?aaeaeaiiua aeaenoaey (/. 2 no. 140);
ia?ooaiea ii?yaeea a noaeaaiii canaaeaiee (/. 3 no. 159); oeeiiaiea
ia?aaiae/eea io yaee a noae eee io iaaeeaaeauaai eniieiaiey naieo
iaycaiiinoae (/. 4 no. 162);
iayaeo a noaeaaiia canaaeaiea ii iaoaaaeeoaeueiui i?e/eiai naeaeaoaey,
yenia?oa, niaoeeaeenoa, ia?aaiae/eea (/. 2 no. 168);
iaeniieiaiea iaycaiiinoe niiaueoue i ia?ao, i?eiyouo ii /anoiiio
ii?aaeaeaieth noaea (/. 2 no. 226);
iayaeo a noaeaaiia canaaeaiea, a eioi?ii ?anniao?eaaaony aeaei,
aicieeoaa ec ioaee/iuo i?aaiioiioaiee, i?aaenoaaeoaey i?aaia
ainoaea?noaaiiie aeanoe, i?aaia ianoiiai naiioi?aaeaiey eee
aeieaeiinoiiai eeoea, yaea eioi?uo auea i?eciaia noaeii iaycaoaeueiie
(/. 4 no. 246);
iai?aaenoaaeaiea aeieaeiinoiuie eeoeaie eno?aaoaiuo noaeii
aeieacaoaeuenoa ii aeaeai, aicieeathuei ec ioaee/iuo i?aaiioiioaiee (/.
2 no. 249).
Oo?ao ca oo?aoo aeieaeiinoiui eeoeii eniieieoaeueiiai aeieoiaioa
iaeaaaaony noaeaaiui i?enoaaii-eniieieoaeai, iinoaiiaeaiea eioi?iai
iiaeao auoue iaaeaeiaaii a noae (no. 431 AIE).
Iacaaiiua noaouee (ca eneeth/aieai no. 431) onoaiaaeeaatho, /oi oo?aou
acuneeaathony a ?acia?a aei 10 onoaiiaeaiiuo oaaea?aeueiui caeiiii
ieieiaeueiuo ?acia?ia iieaou o?oaea. Niaeanii no. 5 Oaaea?aeueiiai
caeiia io 19.06.2000 N 82-OC “I ieieiaeueiii ?acia?a iieaou o?oaea” (a
?aae. io 29.04.02) en/eneaiea oo?aoia, inouanoaeyaiia a niioaaonoaee n
caeiiiaeaoaeuenoaii ?O a caaeneiinoe io ieieiaeueiiai ?acia?a iieaou
o?oaea, i?iecaiaeeony n 1 yiaa?y 2001 a. enoiaey ec aaciaie noiiu,
?aaiie 100 ?oa.
I iaeiaeaiee oo?aoa noae auiineo ii?aaeaeaiea. Iaeiaeaiea oo?aoa ia
inaiaiaeaeaao niioaaonoaothueo aeieaeiinoiuo eeoe e a?aaeaeai io
iaycaiiinoe niaa?oeoue oeacaiiia noaeii aeaenoaea (i?aaenoaaeoue
aeieacaoaeuenoaa, i?eiyoue ia?u ii /anoiiio ii?aaeaeaieth noaea e ae?.).
I?e?iaea noaeaaiuo oo?aoia iaiaeiicia/ia e aucuaaao iiiai/eneaiiua
aeeneonnee i?aaiaaaeia. Iaeie neeiiiu ?anniao?eaaoue noaeaaiua oo?aou
eae ia?u aaeieieno?aoeaiie ioaaonoaaiiinoe. Aeaiiay oi/ea c?aiey eiaao
i?aai ia nouanoaiaaiea, oai aieaa /oi EiAI i?aaeoniao?eaaao iaeiaeaiea
aaeieieno?aoeaiuo acuneaiee ca ?yae aiaeiae/iuo aeayiee. Oae, iai?eia?,
no. 17.3 EiAI i?aaeoniao?eaaao aaeieieno?aoeaioth ioaaonoaaiiinoue a
aeaea oo?aoa ca iaeniieiaiea caeiiiiai ?anii?yaeaiey noaeuee eee
noaeaaiiai i?enoaaa i i?ae?auaiee aeaenoaee, ia?ooathueo onoaiiaeaiiua a
noaea i?aaeea (n?. n /. 3 no. 159 AIE). No. 17.4 EiAI i?aaeoniao?eaaao
iaeiaeaiea aaeieieno?aoeaiiai oo?aoa ia aeieaeiinoiia eeoei ca
inoaaeaiea aac ?anniio?aiey /anoiiai ii?aaeaeaiey noaea (i?aaenoaaeaiey
noaeuee) eee iai?eiyoea ia? ii ono?aiaieth oeacaiiuo a ii?aaeaeaiee
(i?aaenoaaeaiee) ia?ooaiee caeiia (n?. n /. 2 no. 226 AIE). I?e yoii
oo?aou ca i?aaiia?ooaiey, i?aaeoniio?aiiua ia?a/eneaiiuie noaoueyie
EiAI, onoaiiaeaiu a ?acia?a io 5 aei 10 ieieiaeueiuo ?acia?ia iieaou
o?oaea. Eae aoaeoo niaeaniaaiu ii?iu aeaoo eiaeaenia ia i?aeoeea,
iieaaeao a?aiy e i?aaii?eiaieoaeueiay i?aeoeea.
Ae?oaea i?aaeii/eoatho ?anniao?eaaoue i?aaeoniio?aiiua AIE naieoeee eae
iniaue aeae ioaaonoaaiiinoe – a?aaeaeaineoth i?ioeannoaeueioth
ioaaonoaaiiinoue. I?ioeannoaeueiua naieoeee iiaeeaaeao i?eiaiaieth e
eeoeai, eioi?ua naieie aeaenoaeyie (aacaeaenoaeai) i?aiyonoaotho
ii?iaeueiiio oa/aieth noaeaaiiai i?ioeanna. I?aaeaea anaai, yoi eeoea,
o/anoaothuea a aeaea, a oaeaea naeaeaoaee, yenia?ou, niaoeeaeenou,
ia?aaiae/eee. A eneeth/eoaeueiuo neo/ayo, eioi?ua aeieaeiu auoue
i?aaeoniio?aiu caeiiii, noaeaaiua oo?aou iiaoo iaeaaaoueny e ia
aeieaeiinoiuo eeoe, ia o/anoaothueo a ?anniio?aiee aeaea (/. 2 no. 226,
/. 2 no. 249 AIE). Ie no. 105 AIE, ie ae?oaea noaouee AIE ia ?ane?uaatho
iiiyoea “aeieaeiinoiia eeoei”. A aeaiiii neo/aa aeey oyniaiey niunea
aeaiiiai iiiyoey i?aaenoaaeyaony aiciiaeiui ia?aoeoueny e no. 2.4 EiAI
?O, niaeanii eioi?ie iiae aeieaeiinoiui eeoeii iiieiaaony eeoei,
iinoiyiii, a?aiaiii eee a niioaaonoaee ni niaoeeaeueiuie iieiiii/eyie
inouanoaeythuaa ooieoeee i?aaenoaaeoaey aeanoe, o.a. iaaeaeaiiia a
onoaiiaeaiiii caeiiii ii?yaeea ?anii?yaeeoaeueiuie iieiiii/eyie a
ioiioaiee eeoe, ia iaoiaeyueony a neoaeaaiie caaeneiinoe io iaai, a
?aaii eeoei, auiieiythuaa i?aaiecaoeeiiii-?anii?yaeeoaeueiua eee
aaeieieno?aoeaii-oicyenoaaiiua ooieoeee a ainoaea?noaaiiuo i?aaiao,
i?aaiao ianoiiai naiioi?aaeaiey, ainoaea?noaaiiuo e ioieoeeiaeueiuo
i?aaiecaoeeyo, a oaeaea a Aii?oaeaiiuo Neeao, aieneao e aieineeo
oi?ie?iaaieyo ?O.
A oeaeyo aiceiaeaiey ioaaonoaaiiinoe ia iaiin?aaenoaaiiiai ia?ooeoaey
ii?i i?ioeannoaeueiiai caeiiiaeaoaeuenoaa, a oaeaea aeey oiai, /oiau
noeioee?iaaoue aeieaeiinoiuo eeoe e iia?aoeaiiio auiieiaieth caeiiiuo
o?aaiaaiee noaea, i?aaeoniio?aiiuo AIE, /. 2 no. 105 AIE
i?aaeoniao?eaaao, /oi oo?ao acuneeaaaony ec ee/iuo n?aaenoa
aeieaeiinoiuo eeoe.
I?aaenoaaeyaony, /oi ii?io, cae?aieaiioth a /. 2, neaaeoao oieeiaaoue
?anoe?eoaeueii. Eae neaaeoao ec aeiioacu /. 2, aa aeaenoaea
?ani?ino?aiyaony eeoue ia aeieaeiinoiuo eeoe, ia o/anoaothueo a
?anniio?aiee aeaea. Aianoa n oai e a oii neo/aa, eiaaea oaeea eeoea
iaiin?aaenoaaiii o/anoaotho a ?anniio?aiee aeaea, oo?aou, iaeiaeaiiua ia
ieo ca ia?ooaiea i?aaeoniio?aiiuo oaaea?aeueiui caeiiii iaycaiiinoae,
oaeaea aeieaeiu acuneeaaoueny ec eo ee/iuo n?aaenoa.
Ii?aaeaeaiey (iinoaiiaeaiey) i iaeiaeaiee noaeaaiuo oo?aoia ii
a?aaeaeaineei aeaeai ia?auathony e i?eioaeeoaeueiiio eniieiaieth ii
enoa/aiee 10 nooie iinea eo auianaiey, anee oo?ao ia oiea/ai
aeia?iaieueii e ia iinooieea i?inueaa iaeacaiiiai i neiaeaiee eee
oiaiueoaiee ?acia?a oo?aoa, a a neo/aa iinooieaiey oaeie i?inueau –
iinea anooieaiey a caeiiioth neeo iinoaiiaeaiey noaeuee ii aii?ino
neiaeaiey eee oiaiueoaiey ?acia?a oo?aoa (i. 150 A?aiaiiie eino?oeoeee
ii aeaeii?iecaiaenoao a ?aeiiiii noaea, ooaa?aeaeaiiie I?eeacii
Aaia?aeueiiai aee?aeoi?a Noaeaaiiai aeaia?oaiaioa i?e Aa?oiaiii Noaea ?O
io 29.01.99 N 8 (a ?aae. io 15.10.01) Eiiiaioa?ee e A?aaeaeaineiio
i?ioeannoaeueiiio eiaeaeno ?inneeneie Oaaea?aoeee (Ioa. ?aae.
A.I.Eaeeaa), TH?aeo-Ecaeao, 2002. Aeaaa 7.
§2. Neiaeaiea eee oiaiueoaiea noaeaaiiai oo?aoa
A ioee/ea io aaeieieno?aoeaiuo oo?aoia ii?aaeaeaiey noaea i iaeiaeaiee
noaeaaiuo oo?aoia ia iiaoo auoue iaaeaeiaaiu. Eeoei, ia eioi?ia iaeiaeai
oo?ao, iiaeao i?ineoue noae eeoue i neiaeaiee eee oiaiueoaiee oo?aoa.
No. 106 AIE ii?aaeaeyao ii?yaeie neiaeaiey e oiaiueoaiey noaeaaiiai
oo?aoa. Iiae neiaeaieai neaaeoao iiieiaoue inaiaiaeaeaiea io oieaou
oo?aoa. Iineieueeo oo?ao iaeaaaaony ca aeiiaiua aeaenoaey, oi eeoei, ia
eioi?ia iaeiaeai oo?ao, aeieaeii i?aaenoaaeoue aeieacaoaeuenoaa
ionoonoaey naiae aeiu a niaa?oaiee ii?aaeaeaiiiai aeaenoaey eeai a
aacaeaenoaee. Oiaiueoaiea ?acia?a oo?aoa aiciiaeii a oii neo/aa, anee ii
ia niioaaonoaoao oyaeanoe niaa?oaiiiai aeayiey eee i?e iaeiaeaiee oo?aoa
noae ia o/ae eaeeo-eeai ianoiyoaeuenoa. Ia?aiia/aeueii eeoeo, eioi?ia
n/eoaao, /oi ia iaai iaiainiiaaiii iaeiaeai oo?ao, i?aaeinoaaeaii i?aai
ia?aoeoueny n niioaaonoaothuei cayaeaieai iaiin?aaenoaaiii a noae,
eioi?ue oaeie oo?ao iaeiaeee. Cayaeoaeue aeieaeai auoue ecaauai i
a?aiaie e ianoa noaeaaiiai canaaeaiey ii ?anniio?aieth niioaaonoaothuaai
cayaeaiey. A oii neo/aa, eiaaea noae naiaai ?aoaiey ia eciaieo e auianao
ii?aaeaeaiea ia ioeaca neiaeeoue noaeaaiue oo?ao eee oiaiueoeoue aai
?acia?, ia oaeia ii?aaeaeaiea iiaeao auoue iiaeaia /anoiay aeaeiaa a
ii?yaeea, i?aaeoniio?aiiii no. 331-335 (ii?aaeaeaiey ie?iaiai noaeuee) e
no. 371-375 (ii?aaeaeaiey noaea ia?aie einoaioeee) AIE.
Caeeth/aiea
Noaeaaiuie ?anoiaeaie iacuaathony aeaiaaeiua cao?aou, naycaiiua n
?anniio?aieai a?aaeaeaineiai aeaea e eniieiaieai noaeaaiiai ?aoaiey.
Noaeaaiua ?anoiaeu ninoiyo ec ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu e ecaea?aeae,
naycaiiuo n ?anniio?aieai aeaea (no. 79 AIE).
Iieaoa noaeaaiuo ?anoiaeia aiceiaeaia caeiiii ia eeoe, eiathueo i?yiie
iaoa?eaeueii-i?aaiaie eioa?an a enoiaea aeaea, — enooea e ioaao/eea. I?e
nio/anoee iaycaiiinoue iieaou noaeaaiuo ?anoiaeia aiceaaaaony ia
eaaeaeiai nio/anoieea i?e niaa?oaiee ei i?ioeannoaeueiuo aeaenoaee.
O?aouee eeoea, cayaeythuea naiinoiyoaeueiua o?aaiaaiey ia i?aaeiao
nii?a, a ii aeaeai iniaiai i?iecaiaenoaa -cayaeoaee oaeaea aeieaeiu
iiea/eaaoue noaeaaiua ?anoiaeu, oae eae ianoo iaycaiiinoe enooea.
Aiceaaay ia anao caeioa?aniaaiiuo eeoe yoo iaycaiiinoue, caeiiiaeaoaeue
i?aaeaea anaai enoiaeeo ec iaiaoiaeeiinoe /anoe/iiai aiciauaiey
?anoiaeia, eioi?ua ainoaea?noai auioaeaeaii ianoe ii niaea?aeaieth
noaeae e aniiiiaaoaeueiiai ia?niiaea noaeia, ii oeiaine?iaaieth ae?oaeo
cao?ao noaeia, iaiaoiaeeiuo aeey iaania/aiey eo ii?iaeueiie
aeayoaeueiinoe, ?anniio?aiey a?aaeaeaineeo aeae e eniieiaiey ?aoaiee ii
aeaeo. Aaaeiia cia/aiea eiaao i?aaeoi?aaeaeaiea ia?auaiey a noae n
caaaaeiii iainiiaaoaeueiuie o?aaiaaieyie, eeai n iniiaaoaeueiuie
o?aaiaaieyie, ii aac aeinoaoi/iuo iiaiaeia, eeai n aannii?iuie
o?aaiaaieyie, iiaoaeaeay aeieaeieeia aeia?iaieueii auiieiyoue naie
iaycaoaeuenoaa ia?aae e?aaeeoi?aie, iineieueeo a neo/aa ?anniio?aiey
aeaea a noaea ia ieo eyaeao iaycaiiinoue aiciauaiey noaeaaiuo ?anoiaeia.
Eeoeo, eioi?iio ioeacaii a oaeiaeaoai?aiee aai o?aaiaaiee, noaeaaiua
?anoiaeu ia aiciauathony. Noi?iia, i?iea?aaoay aeaei, aiciauaao
i?ioeaiie noi?iia iiianaiiua ath ?anoiaeu.
O/anoieee i?ioeanna e ae?oaea eeoea, oae eee eia/a naycaiiua n
?anniao?eaaaiui a noaea a?aaeaeaineei aeaeii, iiaoo auoue iiaeaa?aioou
noaeii oo?aoo.
Noaeaaiue oo?ao — aeaiaaeiia acuneaiea ca oeeiiaiea o/anoieeia i?ioeanna
eee ae?oaeo eeoe io auiieiaiey i?ioeannoaeueiuo iaycaiiinoae eee
ii?o/aiee noaea, a oaeaea ca ia?ooaiea ii?yaeea a caea noaeaaiiai
canaaeaiey, iaoaaaeaiea e noaeo.
Noae ai?aaa iaeiaeeoue oo?ao oieueei a no?iai ii?aaeaeaiiuo caeiiii
neo/ayo e onoaiiaeaiiuo ?acia?ao. Oo?aou, iaeiaeaiiua noaeii eee
noaeueae ia aeieaeiinoiuo eeoe ainoaea?noaaiiuo i?aaei?eyoee,
o/?aaeaeaiee, i?aaiecaoeee, eieoicia, eiuo eiiia?aoeaiuo i?aaiecaoeee,
eo iauaaeeiaiee, ae?oaeo iauanoaaiiuo i?aaiecaoeee, acuneeaathony ec eo
ee/iuo n?aaenoa
Nienie eniieueciaaiiuo enoi/ieeia
I?aaiaua aeou
A?aaeaeaineee i?ioeannoaeueiue eiaeaen ?O io 14 iiya?y 2002 a. N 138-OC
(AIE ?O). Aeaaa 7
O?oaeiaie eiaeaen ?inneeneie Oaaea?aoeee io 30 aeaeaa?y 2001 a. N 197-OC
(n eci. e aeii. io 24, 25 ethey 2002 a.). Noaouey 393
Oaaea?aeueiue caeii io 19 ethey 1997 a. N 105-OC “I aianaiee eciaiaiee e
aeiiieiaiee a Caeii ?inneeneie Oaaea?aoeee “I ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeia”
Caeii ?O io 27 ai?aey 1993 a. N 4866-I “Ia iaaeaeiaaiee a noae aeaenoaee
e ?aoaiee, ia?ooathueo i?aaa e naiaiaeu a?aaeaeai” (n eci. e aeii. io 14
aeaeaa?y 1995 a.)
I?eeac Ieithnoa ?O io 19 oaa?aey 2002 a. N 52 “I ii?iaoeaiuo aeoao
Ieienoa?noaa thnoeoeee NNN? e Ieienoa?noaa thnoeoeee ?NON?”
Iaci? noaeaaiie i?aeoeee Aa?oiaiiai Noaea ?O ca ia?aue eaa?oae 1997 a.
(ii a?aaeaeaineei aeaeai) (ooa. iinoaiiaeaieai I?aceaeeoia Aa?oiaiiai
Noaea ?O io 14 iay 1997 a.)
Ienueii IO? io 13 iay 1997 a. N AA-09-11/3654-EI “Ia oieaoa ainiioeeiu”
Ienueii Ainiaeianeoaeau ?O io 28 ai?aey 1997 a. “Eioi?iaoeey ia
eciaiaiee ?aeaeceoia ii oieaoa ainoaea?noaaiiie iioeeiu”
Eeoa?aoo?a
“?ani?aaeaeaiea noaeaaiie iioeeiu iaaeaeo athaeaeaoaie” (O?ioeiia A.,
?inneeneay thnoeoeey”, 2000, N 1)
Aiciauaiea ?anoiaeia ia i?aaenoaaeoaeuenoai a noaea (O.A. Naaeiei,
“Aooaaeoa?neee o/ao”, N 19, ieoya?ue 2002 a.)
Oaia?ue noaeeoueny n IIN ?innee iiaeii ca aai n/ao. Eiiiaioa?ee e
ii?aaeaeaieth Eiinoeoooeeiiiiai Noaea ?O (A.A. Ieeiiia, “Aeaaaoo”, N 9,
iae 2002 a.)
A?aeo?aaeiua e noaeaaiua ?anoiaeu: io?aaeaiea a o/aoa (I.A. Aa?aiiaa,
“Aeaaaoo”, N 10, iae 2000 a.)
Eiiiaioa?ee e A?aaeaeaineiio i?ioeannoaeueiiio eiaeaeno ?inneeneie
Oaaea?aoeee (Ioa. ?aae. A.I.Eaeeaa), TH?aeo-Ecaeao, 2002. Aeaaa 7
Ainoaea?noaaiiay iioeeia i?e ia?auaiee a noaeu iauae th?enaeeeoeee (E.I.
E?ueaiiaa, “A?aaeaeaiei e i?aai”, N 5, iae 2002 a.)
Ainoaea?noaaiiay iioeeia ii aeaeai, ?anniao?eaaaiui noaeaie iauae
th?enaeeeoeee (E.I. E?ueaiiaa, “Iaeiaiaue aanoiee”, N 8, aaaono 2002 a.)
Нашли опечатку? Выделите и нажмите CTRL+Enter
