.

Ставлення кадетів до Української державності в період Центральної Ради (березень-липень 1917 р.)

Язык: украинский
Формат: курсова
Тип документа: Word Doc
0 2498
Скачать документ

E?e?y Ua?a?i,

ani??aio eaoaae?e anana?oiuei? ?noi??? I?eea?iaonueeiai iaoe?iiaeueiiai
oi?aa?neoaoo ?i. Aaneey Noaoaieea, i. ?aaii-O?aie?anuee

Noaaeaiiy eaaeao?a aei oe?a?inueei? aea?aeaaiino? a ia??iae
Oeaio?aeueii? ?aaee (aa?acaiue-eeiaiue 1917 ?.)

O noaoo? aiae?co?oueny noaaeaiiy eiinoeoooe?eii-aeaiie?aoe/ii? ia?o??
aei oe?a?inueeiai iaoe?iiaeueii-aecaieueiiai ?ooo a ia??iae
aa?aciy-eeiiy 1917 ?. Aaoi? noaa?aeaeo?, ui naia caia?a/aiiy eaaeaoaie
aaoiiii?? Oe?a?ie coiiaeei eeiiaao o?yaeiao e?eco, ine?eueee aiie
?icaeyaeaee oe?a?inueea ieoaiiy ye caa?ico ?iciaaeo “?aeeii? ?
iaiiae?eueii?” ?in??.

Ethoiaaa ?aaiethoe?y noaea aaaeeeaei aei?iaoaaiiyi aeey
eiinoeoooe?eii-aeaiie?aoe/ii? ia?o??. Iie?oe/i? iiae?? aeiaaaee aaea ia
o?eueee oai?aoe/ieo ?ic?iaie ae??oaiiy noni?eueieo i?iaeai, a ??oo/eo
i?aeoe/ieo e?ie?a, ni?yiiaaieo ia ?o ?ica’ycaiiy. Ao?eeaniaith i’yoith
aeey eaaeao?a noaei iaoe?iiaeueia ieoaiiy, cie?aia oe?a?inueea, yea
coiiaeei aeo?ae i?i?no??a-eaaeao?a c Oei/aniaiai o?yaeo o eeii? 1917 ?.

O ?aaeyinuee?e ?noi??ia?ao?? caia?a/oaaeinue oe?a?inueea ieoaiiy ye
oaeoi? aeoiaeo i?i?no??a c Oei/aniaiai o?yaeo, yeee coiiaea eeiiaao
e?eco. O?yaeiaa e?eca iia’ycoaaeanue c a?enueeiaeie iaaaea/aie,
i?aaiaiiyi eaaeao?a anoaiiaeoe ?aeeiiaeaaeaey [1]. Iacaiaea eaaeao?a c
iie?oeeith o?yaeo a oe?a?inueeiio ieoaii? ?icaeyaeaeanue ye oi?iaeueiee
i?ea?ae aeoiaeo i?i?no??a, ye /eiiee oeneo ia iie?oe/ieo noia?iee?a –
ana??a ? iaioiaee?a [2]. No/ani? aeine?aeieee, i?eae?eyth/e cia/io oaaao
i?ioeano ia?aaiai??a Oeaio?aeueii? ?aaee ? Oei/aniaiai o?yaeo, iica
iieai naiai iaoeiaiai ci?o caeeoathoue i?iaeaio noaaeaiiy
Eiinoeoooe?eii-aeaiie?aoe/ii? ia?o?? aei oe?a?inueeiai ieoaiiy i?ney
Ethoiaai? ?aaiethoe??, o? ia?o?ei? aioo??oi? noia?a/iino? ? aeaaaoe, ye?
oi/eeenue iaaeiei iiceoe?? uiaei oe?a?inueei? aea?aeaaiino? [3].

Iaoa noaoo? – aena?oeaiiy iiceoe?? eiinoeoooe?eii-aeaiie?aoe/ii? ia?o??
aei oe?a?inueeiai ieoaiiy i?ioyaii aa?aciy-eeiiy 1917 ?. a oiiaao
?icaoaeiae oe?a?inueei? aea?aeaaiino? ? ia?aaiai?iiai i?ioeano i?ae
i?noeaaeie ? oeaio?aeueieie i?aaiaie aeaaee.

I?ney Ethoiaai? ?aaiethoe?? eaaeaoe acyee aeoeaio o/anoue o oi?ioaaii?
i?aai?a iiai? aeaaee. Aiie io?eiaee 5 i?noeue o Oei/aniaiio o?yae?
ia?oiai neeeeaiiy (aa?acaiue-ea?oaiue 1917 ?), 3 i?noey o eiae?oe?eiiio
o?yae? (ea?oaiue-eeiaiue 1917 ?.). Aeoeaiith aoea ia?o?eia
ae?yeuei?noue: i?aai?ciaoaaee i?oeiae, aeaiiino?aoe??, i?iaiaeeee
c’?caee, ye? iaee ia iao? c’ynoaaoe iiceoe?th ia?o?? aei ?aae?e iiaiai
oi?iaoo. Ia VII c’?cae? (25-28 aa?aciy 1917 ?.) aoee aianai? ci?ie aei
i?ia?aie eiinoeoooe?eii-aeaiie?aoe/ii? ia?o?? uiaei aea?aeaaiiai eaaeo:
?in?y iiaeiia noaoe aeaiie?aoe/iith ia?eaiaionueeith ?anioae?eith.
Oei/aniaee o?yae aeciaaaany ?aeeiith caeiiiaeaa/ith ? aeeiiaa/ith
aeaaeith.

A oiiaao c?inoaiiy iaoe?iiaeueii-aecaieueiiai ?ooo ia i?inoi?ao
?in?enueei? ?iia???, cie?aia oe?a?inueeiai, 9-12 o?aaiy 1917 ?.
a?aeaoany V??? c’?cae eiinoeoooe?eii-aeaiie?aoe/ii? ia?o??, ia yeiio
cia/ia oaaaa i?eae?eyeanue iaoe?iiaeueiiio ieoaiith. Ia oeueiio c’?cae?
O. O. Eieioe?i ca/eoaa aeiiia?aeue “Aaoiiii?y ? oaaea?aoe?y”, a ye?e
iaaieinea ia oiio, ui i?e ae??oaii? ieoaiiy i?i aaoiiii?th o?aaa
?ic??ciyoe aeaa iia’ycaieo i?ae niaith, aea aiaeii/an ? ie?aieo
i?eioeeie: i?eioeei aeaoeaio?ae?caoe?? (iaeania ieoaiiy) ? i?eioeei
naiiaecia/aiiy iaoe?iiaeueiinoae (iaoe?iiaeueia ieoaiiy).
Aeaoeaio?ae?caoe?y iiaea aooe caniaii iaoe?iiaeueiiai naiiaecia/aiiy,
aea aiia ia ? ?aeeiei iaoiaeii aeey oeueiai ? neoao? aeey caaeiaieaiiy
?ioeo iio?aa ia?iaeiiai aeeooy [4].

I?ino?? ?in?? ? ??ciiiai?oi?noue ?? i?noeaaeo oiia aeeeeeathoue iio?aao
ia o?eueee aeaoeaio?ae?caoe?? oi?aae?iiy, aea e caeiiiaeaanoaa o oi?i?
i?noeaai? aaoiiii??, oiaoi iaaeaiiy i?noeaaei i?aaenoaaieoeueeei
c?a?aiiyi o/ano? o caeiiiaeaanoa? c ieoaiue i?noeaaiai ainiiaea?nueeiai
? eoeueoo?iiai aeeooy.

Aeaoeaio?ae?caoe?y caeiiiaeaanoaa a ?in?? ia iiaea aooe cae?eniaia
oeyoii ia’?aeiaiiy eiaeii? c aieiaieo iaoe?iiaeueiinoae a iniaeea?
aaoiiiii? iaeeieoe?, ai i?e ia??aiii??i?e /enaeueiino? ie?aieo ia?iae?a
? ?ici???a oa?eoi??e, ye? aiie caeiathoue, oaea
iaoe?iiaeueii-oa?eoi??aeueia aaoiiii?y: 1) iaea a nai?i oaeoe/iei
iane?aeeii anoaiiaeaiiy ana?aaeei? aaeeeeo iaoe?iiaeueii-oa?eoi??aeueieo
iaeeieoeue, iai?eeeaae Aaeeei?in?? oa Oe?a?ie, ia aeaoeaio?ae?caoe??, a,
iaaiaee, oeaio?ae?caoe??; 2) c?iaeea a iaiiaeeeaith i?aai?caoe?th
ca’yceo i?ae ie?aieie iaoe?iiaeueii-oa?eoi??aeueieie iaeeieoeyie i? ia
canaaeao ?aeeii? aea?aeaae, i? ia canaaeao i?aaeeueii i?aai?ciaaii?
oaaea?aoeaii? aea?aeaae ? oiio i?ecaaea a aei ?oeioaaiiy aea?aeaaii?
?aeiino? ?in?? ? aei cai?iaaaeaeaiiy ia oaaea?aoe?? (nithcii?
aea?aeaae), a eiioaaea?aoe?? (nithco aea?aeaa) [5].

Ia aeoieo O. Eieioe?ia, iaoe?iiaeueiino?, ye? iaiieyaathoue ia
iaiao?aeiino? oaaea?aoe?? a ?in?? ca iaoe?iiaeueiei i?eioeeiii, oi/ooue
o iaeaooiueiio aea?aeaaiiio aeii? ?in?? iaeaoooaaoe aeey naaa oo /e ?ioo
e?iiaoo, i?enoiniaaio aei ?o aeiia. Aea aiie ?aii?othoue i?iaeaio
aea?aeaaiiai ono?ith a oe?eiio: “Ui noino?oueny an??? aoae?ae?, oi oea
aaoa ni?aaa, aoaeoeoa ye oi/aoa ? ye ai??oa, aeaeoa o?eueee iai oaeo
e?iiaoo, yeo ie oi/aii” [6].

Ca?aeii c aeiiia?aeaeth O. Eieioe?ia aeaoeaio?ae?caoe?y ?in?? iaea
??oiooaaoeny ia iaaeaii? i?aaiai naiioi?aae?iiy aeueo naiioi?aaieo
iaeeieoeue (aoaa?i?e aai iaeanoae) aaoiiiiieo i?aa o iaaieo noa?ao
ainiiaea?nueeiai ? eoeueoo?iiai aeeooy, i?e oiia? aeciaiiy ca
caaaeueiiaea?aeaaieie caeiiaie ia?aaaaeath/i? neee iaae i?noeaaeie, ? ia
caaacia/aii? ca aea?aeaaiith aeaaeith i?aaa eiio?ieth iaae i?noeaaei
caeiiiaeaanoaii o oi?i? “veto”. Aeuei naiioi?aaiei iaeeieoeyi o?aaa
iaaeaoe i?aai oeeaaeaoe i?ae niaith no?ieia? ? aacno?ieia? oaiaee aeey
cae?eniaiiy ni?eueieo caaaeaiue oa ooai?thaaoe aeey oeueiai oei/ania?
aai iino?ei? nithce. Ci?ia ei?aeii?a aoaa?i?e aai iaeanoae iiaeiia
cae?enithaaoenue a?aeiia?aeii aei caaaeueiiaea?aeaaiiai caeiiiaeaanoaa
[7].

Ia iniia? aenooio O. Eieioe?ia aoee aianai? ci?ie aei § 12, 24, 25
i?ia?aie eaaeao?a: i?e caa?aaeaii? caaaeueiiaea?aeaaiiai noaoono
?in?enueei? iiae o aea?aeaaieo onoaiiaao, a?i??, oeioo ia?aaeaa/aeinue
aeei?enoaiiy i?noeaaeo iia a?aeiia?aeii aei iaoe?iiaeueiiai neeaaeo
ianaeaiiy, cie?aia i?e caeiaooo? ii/aoeiai? ina?oe; aeuei
oa?eoi??aeueiei naiioi?aaiei nithcai (aoaa?inueeei aai iaeaniei
cainoaai) iaaeaaaeenue i?aaa i?ia?ioe?eii? aaoiiii?? (aeaeaiiy i?noeaaeo
caeii?a) o iaaieo noa?ao i?noeaaiai ainiiaea?nueeiai, eoeueoo?iiai ?
iaoe?iiaeueii-eoeueoo?iiai aeeooy, ?c aa?aiooaaiiyi aeey
caaaeueiiaea?aeaaii? aeaaee iiaeeeaino? i?eieiyoe aaaaeaiiy a ae?th
caeii?a, ye? ii?ooothoue anoaiiaeai? caaaeueiiaea?aeaaiith
eiinoeoooe??th iaae? aaoiiii??; i?e i?eeiyoo? eiinoeoooe?? ?in?enueei?
?anioae?ee i?aaa i?noeaai? aaoiiii?? iaaeathoueny i?aaiai
naiia?yaeoaaiiy aoaa?i?e ? a?aeiia?aeieo ?i oa?eoi??aeueieo iaeeieoeue
(iei? ?nioth/eo iaeanoae). Eiinoeoooe?y iiaeiia a?aee?eoe caeiiii??iee
oeyo aei caaeiaieaiiy iiaaaeaiue i?noeaaiai ianaeaiiy uiaei ia’?aeiaiiy
oa?eoi??aeueieo iaeeieoeue o a?eueo? nithce, iiae?e ?o ia iaio?
iaeeieoe? oa ci?io ?o ei?aeii?a [8].

Oaeei /eiii, ae??oaiiy iaoe?iiaeueiiai ieoaiiy caaeinue ia?o??th aei
?icoe?aiiy i?noeaaiai naiia?yaeoaaiiy, oiaoi “i?ia?ioe?eii? aaoiiii??”,
caia?a/aiiy iie?oe/ii? aaoiiii??. Oae? ei?aeoeae uiaei iaoe?iiaeueii?
i?iaeaie aeeeeeaee aeaaaoe ia can?aeaiiyo c’?caeo.

I. I. Iiaeeyinueeee a?aecia/ea, ui iaia? aeiaeii? oe?a?inueei?
i?ia?aneaii? ia?o??, eio?a a o nai?e i?ia?ai? ia iinoaaeea aeiiae
iaoe?iiaeueii-oa?eoi??aeueii? aaoiiii??, ? yeui eaaeaoe o naith i?ia?aio
oe??? aeiiae ia aianooue, oe?a?ioe? ia aoaeooue ?o i?aeo?eioaaoe. A?i
cai?iiiioaaa aianoe a § 25 i?ia?aie aeac?aeo ia aaoiiii?th Oe?a?ie a
oaeiio cia/aii?, a yeiio oeae ia?aa?ao aeacoaaa ia aaoiiii?th Iieueu?
[9].

I?aaenoaaiee Ee?anueeiai iaeaniiai eii?oaoo I. A. Aooaiei canoa??a
noiniaii aenooio O. Eieioe?ia, ui “aoaeeiie iiaoaeiaaiee e?aneai, aea ia
eiai o?iioii? iaien: oie, ooi aaaea? iaoe?iiaeueiiai ?icaeoeo, caoiaey/e
a oeae ae?i, caeeo iaae?th iacaaaeaee” [10]. Ia eiai aeoieo, yeae th?eno
aeaieinea na?e aenooi o Ee?a?, eiai a ni?eeiyee a ye aaeeei?in?enueeiai
iaoe?iiae?noa.

I?aaenoaaiee c Iieoaae ss. E. ?ioaiaoeueeee i?aee?aneea, ui,
iacaaaeath/e ia aaeeea iaoe?iiaeueia i?aeianaiiy, oe?a?inueeee ia?iae
caaaeaee cayaey?, ui i? i?i yea a?aeie?aieaiiy a?ae ?in?? ia iiaea aooe
e iiae. C oeei ona?aeiieaiiyi ia?iaeii? ni?eueiino? o?aaa ?aooaaoeny,
oe?ioaaoe eiai, ? c oe??th iaoith o?aaa aeacaoe oe?a?inueeiio ia?iaeia?
oeyo aei cae?eniaiiy eiai iaoe?iiaeueieo aeiia. Ca eiai
niinoa?aaeaiiyie, aanei “aaoiiii?y Oe?a?ie” iac?icoi?ea aeey oe?ieeo
aa?noa ianaeaiiy, aea aiie ?inoeieoeaii a?ae/oaathoue, ui a ieo ? ye?nue
oe?o? iaoe?iiaeuei? aeiiae, ? aaea ia ie?youeny eeoa c aeicaieii /eoaoe
eieae oe?a?inueeith iiaith. Iaaaciaea ?ic’?aeiaiiy ? ?iciaaeo aea?aeaae
noiniaii Oe?a?ie ia?aaeueia, ai ia iiaeia ?icae?eeoe oa?eoi??th Oe?a?ie
oa ?in?? oaeei /eiii, uia a Oe?a?i? ia caeeoeeinue aaaaoi ?in?yi, ?
iaaiaee. I?e ni?eueiiio i?iaeeaaii? ia?iae?a iaiiaeeeai nii?oaeeoe ?
eoeueoo?io no?io i?ae ieie [11].

*eai Oeaio?aeueiiai eii?oaoo (aeae? – OeE) I. I. A?iinueeee iacaaa on?
noii?ae oe?a?ioe?a iiieeeiaeie. Ia?aaoaath/e a Aaee/ei? ? a Ea?iaoao,
i?aoi? ia?aeiiaany, ui i?noeaaa ianaeaiiy /oaeiai ?icoi?ei
nieaeao-aaeeei?in?a. Oe?a?inueeee ia?iae, – cacia/ea a?i, – ? ia?iae
?in?enueeiai iioiaeaeaiiy, ? iaa?oue ?oneie a Aaee/ei? iaceaathoue naaa
“?onueth”, noa?ith iacaith, yea cono??/a?oueny a “Neia? i iieeo
?ai?aa?i”, ? i?eiooo? oe?a?ioe?a caeeoaoeny a i?a?o? ?in?enueeiai
aaeeeiai ieaiai?, aea aiie caeiathoue ??aia c on?ia i?noea. Ia eiai
aeoieo, nian?iiy oe?a?ioe?a a nithc? c aaeeei?inaie [12].

Iaoa?ao?aeaoeue ?. I. Aeoaina?nueeee caeeeeaa ia?o?th aaeeoe caoiae?a
aeey iiia?aaeaeaiiy ?icaaeo ia ie?a?iao, aeneiaethth/e iaae?th ia oa, ui
an? ia?iaee ?in?? caaiai?youe iaei??th iiaith – iiaith aeiiae ?aeeii?
aea?aeaae i?e oe?ieiio caaeiaieaii? iaoe?iiaeueieo aeiiaaaiue [13].

I?aaenoaaiee Iineae A. A. E??iia? a?ae/oa naia?aoenonuee? iioee a neiaao
I. Aooaiea. A?i aaaaeaa, ui i??yoe o?aaa ia i?i ie?ai? e?iiaoe, ia i?i
iaoeaioe?a ie?aieo iiia??a iaaeueiaaieo e?iiao, a i?i iaeei eoiie
aaeeei? ?in??, i?ae yeei aoaeooue aeeoe ia oa?eoi??aeueii ?icae?iaeai?,
a ia’?aeiai? ni?eueiith eoeueoo?ith ia?iaee ?in?? [14].

VII ? VIII c’?caee ia?o?? I. I?etheia ca cia/aiiyi i?e??aithaaa aei
i?aai?caoe?eieo c’?cae?a 1905 ?. ? 1906 ?., ine?eueee aiie aecia/eee
noaaeaiiy eaaeao?a aei iiai?ioieo ?noi?e/ieo iiiaio?a [15]. O iiaeo
?noi?e/ieo oiiaao iiceoe?y ia?o?? iiaeiia aacoaaoenue ia i?eioeeiao
?aeiino? aeaaee, e?ea?aeaoe?? aeaiaeaaeaey ? ni?ia ??cieo i?aai?caoe?e
eiieo?oaaoe ?c caeiiiei ? aeciaiei e?a?iith o?yaeii, neee aeaaee ? i?aaa
canoiniaoaaoe oeth neeo, aaaeaiiy a?eie aei ia?aiiaeiiai e?ioey ?
i?aeienaiiy ie?iiai aeiaiai?o. E?aea? eaaeao?a cacia/ea, ui ia?o?y aoaea
aeieeaaeaoe an?o coneeue, uia iiia?aaeeoe oe?aeeea? oeaio?ia?aei?
oaiaeaioe??, ye? c’yaeeeny a oiiaao ?ic?ooe. Eaaeaoe aeciathoue aeiiao
noai?aiiy i?noeaaeo naiino?eieo i?aai?a ? ia?aaeaa/athoue aaaaeaiiy
aaoiiii?? c i?aaii caeiiiaeaanoaa c aeayeeo ieoaiue. Iaeiae aiie i?ioe
iaaaeiiai noai?aiiy iaoe?iiaeueieo oa?eoi??e c oeie ?icoe?aieie i?aaaie
aea?aeaaii? aaoiiii??, ia yeeo iaiieyaaee ??ci? ia?iaee [16].

?noi?ee Ae. ssiaanueeee aaaaea?, ui aca?iia?aeiineie i?ae oeaio?ii –
Iao?ia?aaeii – ? oae caaieie “iaoe?iiaeueieie ?aeiiaie” ia iiaee ia
caaino?eoeny aiane?aeie ??oaiue uiaei i?aaa ia aaoiiiiiee ono??e oa ?io?
i?aaa iaoe?iiaeueiinoae, ooaaeaieo c’?caeii eaaeao?a [17]. C oe??th
aeoieith aaaeei ia iiaiaeeoenue, aaeaea, caeiath/e i?ia?aei? i?noey a
i?aaiao aeaaee, nai? i?ia?aii? i?eioeeie aiie noaaeee a iniiao
aea?aeaaii? oi?aae?inueei? iie?oeee. Oea i?inoaaeoaaeinue ? o noaaeaii?
eaaeao?a aei iie?oecaoe?? noni?eueiiai aeeooy ia Oe?a?i?, aei i?ioeano
oi?ioaaiiy oe?a?inueeeo i?aai?a aeaaee.

ssne?aaei i?eeeaaeii noaaeaiiy ?in?enueeeo eaaeao?a aei i?aaiaiue
oe?a?ioe?a noaea ?aaeoe?y o?yaeiai? eii?n?? o neeaae? e?aa?ae?a ia
aeaeaaaoe?th Oeaio?aeueii? ?aaee, yea ia /ie? c A. Aeiie/aieii o o?aai?
1917 ?. a?aea?aeaea Iao?ia?aae, iath/e ia iao? i?aaenoaaeoe ia ?icaeyae
o?yaeo nai? aeiiae ?, ianaiia?aae, aaoiiii?th Oe?a?ie. Aieiaa o?yaeo ei.
Eueaia, a?aeiiaeaoenue ?icaeyaeaoe i?ioaiiy aeaeaaao?a, ia?aaeaa ?o ia
?icaeyae niaoe?aeueii? o?yaeiai? eii?n??, aei yei? oa?eoee Ae. Uaie?i,
N. O?onia, N. Eioey?aanueeee, I. Eaca?aanueeee [18]. Cae?i/eeeny
cono??/? eii?n?? c aeaeaaaoe??th cayaith o?yaeiaoe?a, ui iio??aai /an ia
ae??oaiiy ieoaiiy, oiaoi aac?acoeueoaoii. Nai?ie a?aaeaiiyie a?ae
ia?aa?ao noiee/ieo ia?aaiai??a iiae?eeany A. Aeiie/aiei: “A oe?e
eiiaae?? a eaaeaonueeeo i?ioani??a i?ae /an caoiieaiiy aeaaaoaie
ieiiaie? c-i?ae no?iai? iaoeiai? iaio?? aece?ioei ?oi? neoa, aeaaeia,
ao?aeoacii-eeaniaa o?ei. Aei??thth/e oa?eoi??th iaeaooiuei? aaoiiii??
Oe?a?ie, aiie oi?eioeenue *i?iiai ii?y, Iaeane, Aeiiaoeueeiai ?aeiio,
Eaoa?eiineaaueie, Oa?niiueie, Oa?e?aueie. ? ooo a?ae iaeii? aeoiee, a?ae
iaeii? oyae, ui aeiiaoeueea ? oa?niinueea aoa?eey, ui eaoa?eiineaanueea
cae?ci, ui oa?e?anueea ?iaeono??y iai?iaoueny a ieo, aiie aei oiai
caoaeethaaeenue, ui caaoee i?i naith i?ioani?nueeo iaio?th, i?i naith
iaoeo, i?i aenie? Onoaiia/? Cai?e, ii/aee aeiaooaaoe ?oeaie,
?ico?enoaeenue ? aeyaeee anth nooue naiai ?onueeiai aeaaeeiai, aeaaeiiai
iaoe?iiae?cio” [19, n.167-168].

Io?eiaaoe /a?aiao a?aeiiao o?yaeo uiaei aaoiiii?? Oe?a?ie, ine?eueee
Oei/aniaee o?yae ia ? i?aai/eiiei ae??ooaaoe iaaeaiiy oaeiai noaoono, a
Oeaio?aeueia ?aaea ia ? i?aaenoaaieeii anueiai ianaeaiiy Oe?a?ie, 10
/a?aiy 1917 ?. Oeaio?aeueia ?aaea i?iaieineea ? Oi?aa?nae. Oeae
aeieoiaio aeeeeeaa ?aaeoe?th ??ciiai oa?aeoa?o: a?ae ue?iai,
iao??ioe/ii-aeoi?e/iiai caoiieaiiy oe?a?ioe?a aei inoaeo, ai?aiiai
caia?a/aiiy ?in?enueeei noni?euenoaii.

O eaaeaonuee?e aacao? “?a/ue” i?iaieioaiiy ? Oi?aa?naeo ?icoe?ithaaeinue
ye “aeeiiaiiy ua iaei??? eaiee i?iaoeueeiai ieaio ?iceeaaeo ?in??,
i?yiee cei/ei i?ioe caeiio, yeee aeiaaa? i?ioe naaa iaaaeiiai
canoinoaaiiy noai?eo caeiiieo iiea?aiue” [20].

O Aea?aeaaiiio a?o?a? ?in?enueei? Oaaea?aoe?? i?noeoueny oe?eaaee
aeieoiaio – caien ia?aaee /eai?a eiinoeoooe?eii-aeaiie?aoe/ii? ia?o?? c
ieoaiiy uiaei noaaeaiiy aei ? Oi?aa?naeo Oeaio?aeueii? ?aaee. Na?aae
o/aniee?a ia?aaee aoee I. Iiaai?iaeoeaa, O. ?iae?/aa, ss. ?ioaiaoeueeee,
I. A?iinueeee, ?. Aeaieaeia, Ae. A?eii, I. Iaioeeia, A. Aa?iaaenueeee,
O. Eieioe?i, C. O?aieaeue, I. Iae?ania, A. Oeiaa?ueia. Aeieoiaio ia
aeaoiaaiee, aea ca ci?noii iiaeia i?eionoeoe, ui can?aeaiiy i?enay/aia
naia iaaiai?aiith i?iaieioaiiy ? Oi?aa?naeo.

O. Eieioe?i i?aee?aneea, ui “iacaaeiaieaiiy aeeeeea? oa?eoi??aeueiee
aniaeo ? i?aaa ?aaee, eiiiaoaioe?y yei? aaciaaeia, oi/a iaa?oue a ooaoao
? iaiaaeaiiy iaaieie noa?aie. A ooo any aeaaea iaeaaeeoue
ia?eaiaionueeiio o?yaeo”. A?i canoa??aaa, ui i?iaeo iai?eeiyoiee: “Ie
ia?aae ?noi?e/iith iaaeath, caea?ii nai? iiceoe??. Aeiiaa Oe?a?ie
o?eueee (eo?nea o aeieoiaio? – E. U.) ia?oa: ca?ac ?io? ia?iaee
iinoaaeyoue ieoaiiy a o?e aea oi?i? ? aoaeooue aeiaaaoe iinooiie a oaeeo
naieo ae?acao” [21]. Na?aae iaeaooi?o aeiaaa/?a iacaaa Eeoao, A?oc?th,
Anoii?th, Eaoa?th, ionoeueiai. Ia eiai aeoieo, “o?aaa i?eeiyoe
aeieoiaio, yeee aecia? iiaiioo i?aaa iaoe?iiaeueii? eoeueoo?e,
naiiaecia/aiiy, iiae – iaaaeia cai?iaaaeaeaiiy a ae?eiaiaenoai i?noeaaeo
onoaiia ia ??aieo i?aaao ?c caaaeueiiaea?aeaaiei aeciaiiyi ? cae?eniaiiy
aaoiiiiieo i?noeaaeo onoaiia o i?noeaainoyo, canaeaieo oe?a?ioeyie,
oi?aae?iiy iiaeiii cae?enithaaoeny Oei/aniaei o?yaeii /a?ac i?noeaaeo
ethaeae, ye? ei?enoothoueny aeia??ith i?noeaaiai ianaeaiiy (ia
i?aai?caoe??) ? iiaeooue ia’?aeiaoe aeae?eueea aoaa?i?e ? noai?eoe
i?aai, iiai?noth caeaaeiee a?ae Oei/aniaiai o?yaeo, – aaia?aeueiee
eii?na? c ?aaeith ?c 7 in?a, ?c oe?oeie iiaiiaaaeaiiyie, i?ae cae/aeii,
i?e ?ica?aeiinoyo eii?oaoo ? ?aaee ieoaiiy ae??oothoueny o?yaeii. Aeae?
eoe ia iiaeia: oea ii?ooaiiy iaa?oue ia?aae oe?a?inueeei ia?iaeii, ai
?aaea i?eei ia aea?aia” [22].

I?iiiceoe?y O. Eieioe?ia ia aeaoooaaea I. Iiaai?iaeoeaaa, oiio ui ana
iaeii noai?ththoueny oi?ie iaeanii? aaoiiii??. A?i cai?iiiioaaa aeciaoe
?aaeo o?eueee a?iiaaenueeith i?aai?caoe??th.

O. ?iae?/aa o ieoaii? a?aeiiaeaiiy ?in?? iieeaaeaa iaae?th ia ai?ii?
oni?oe: “i?iiaea ?aei?noue ?in??, aea, yeui aoaeooue oni?oe a?i??, ie
iiaa?iaiiny. Oe?a?ioe? aaea oaia? oaa?ac?thoue. Iinooieo iiaeia caa?aoe
iacaae, eiee aiie iaeoiathoueny” [23].

ss. ?ioaiaoeueeee aaaaeaa, ui “o?yae ia caeaoai iiaeieaoe ?aaiethoe?eiee
aeo. A?i oe?aeeeaee, aea iaia? nee aei?aaeoe o?ae iiae?e, ye ie oi/aii”
[24].

I. A?iinueeee iaiieyaaa ia oiio, ui “oey i?nai?oieoey ia iiaea aooe
aeciaia ye aeo o?yaeo. Oea i?/iai c oi/ee ci?o aea?aeaaiiai i?aaa, aea
yeui ia oeae oeyo ia?aaiai??a noaee, oi o?aaa aeiiiaeyoeny i?i oeae
aeieoiaio ? aianoe ?aaeaeoe?ei? aei?aaeaiiy, ine?eueee a aeai?e oi?i? –
aeieoiaio cian?i iai?eeiyoiee. O?aaa iaiieyaaoe, uia Oi?aa?nae
a?aeiia?aeaa aeieoiaioo: ia aiai?eoe i?i a?aeiia?aeaeuei?noue. Ana
i?eeiaoe – ieae/a a?aeiino? o?yaeo” [25].

Ioaea, eaaeao?a eyeaea iiaeeea?noue ao?aoe Oe?a?ie, oaeo i?iaieioaiiy
aaoiiii?? ?icaeyaeaany ye yaeua iaaaoeaia, oei/aniaa, iaeii?eeiyoia.

Aeey iiooeo eiii?ii?niiai ??oaiiy aei Ee?aa i?eaoea o?yaeiaa
aeaeaaaoe?y: I. Ea?ainueeee, ?. Oea?aoae?, I. Oa?auaiei. Iane?aeeii
ia?aaiai??a 28-30 /a?aiy 1917 ?. noaee Aeaeea?aoe?y Oei/aniaiai o?yaeo,
o ye?e Aaia?aeueiee nae?aoa??ao aeciaaaany aeuei i?aaiii aeey oi?aae?iiy
e?aeiaeie ni?aaaie, ? ?? Oi?aa?nae Oeaio?aeueii? ?aaee.

Ia can?aeaii? OeE eaaeao?a 2 eeiiy iaaiai?thaaeinue noaaeaiiy ia?o??
aei oe?a?inueeiai ieoaiiy. Ia?aaea a?aeaoaaeanue ca o/anoth
i?aaenoaaiee?a a?ae oe?a?inueeeo eii?oao?a, cie?aia Ee?anueeiai. Aa?o/e
aei oaaae iiaaaeaiiy ianaeaiiy Oe?a?ie, i?iiiaoe? aeacoaaee, ui
aaoiiii?y iiaea aooe i?iaieioaia i?ney neeeeaiiy Onoaiia/eo Cai??a. O
ca’yceo c iaaecia/aieie oa?eoi??aeueieie ei?aeiiaie iaeano? ? iaaeaie
naii? aaoiiii?? eaaeaoe aaaaeaee ia?aae/aniei i?eeiyooy caaaeueiiai
i?eioeeio, ai “a?i iiaea noai?eoe i?aoeaaeaio aeey ?ioeo ia?iae?a ?in??
? oaeei /eiii ?icii/aoe aeciaiiy i?eioeeio ?ic/eaioaaiiy ?in?? ?
ia?aae??oaiiy caaaeueiiaea?aeaaiiai eaaeo” [26].

Ia can?aeaii? aoea i?eeiyoa ?aciethoe?y oaeiai ci?noo: “1) aeey ?icaeoeo
i?ia?aie ia?o?? i?eeiyoe i?eioeei iaeanii? aaoiiii?? Oe?a?ie; 2)
noai?eoe eii?n?th i?e Oeaio?aeueiiio Eii?oao? aeey ?ic?iaee ?c aianaiiyi
a Onoaiia/? Cai?e caeiiii?iaeoo iaeanii? aaoiiii?? ?c caa?aaeaiiyi
aea?aeaaii? ?aeiino? ?in?? ? i?e noai?iio caaacia/aii?
caaaeueiiaea?aeaaieo ?ioa?an?a” [27].

Oeae aeieoiaio eaaeaoe i?eianee 2 eeiiy ia can?aeaiiy Oei/aniaiai
o?yaeo, ia yeiio iaaiai?thaaany oaeno oaiaee c Oeaio?aeueiith ?aaeith.
?aciethoe?y iaea cana?ae/eoe ?oi? iiceoeaia, a i?eioeei?, noaaeaiiy aei
aaoiiii?? Oe?a?ie. Iaeiae i?ae /an aieinoaaiiy eaaeaoe aeneiaeeenue
i?ioe oaiaee, ? i?i?no? ia?iaeii? ina?oe I. Iaioeeia, i?i?no?
aea?aeaaii? ii?ee Ae. Oaoianueeee, i?i?no? o?iain?a A. Oeiaa?ueia aeeoee
c o?yaeo. I. I?etheia cacia/aa, ui “aeciaoe aac ci?i aacoi?iio oa
th?eaee/ii iaa?aiioio aeaeea?aoe?th Oa?auaiea ? Oea?aoae? aiie ia iiaee.
I?ney aieinoaaiiy eaaeaoe aeeoee ?c neeaaeo Oei/aniaiai o?yaeo,
iioeaoth/e oea oei, ui iinoaiiaa c oe?a?inueeiai ieoaiiy aiineoue oain o
a?aeiineie i?ae o?yaeii ? e?aeiaei i?aaiii ? a?aee?eaa? ?aae? iaeaea
caeiii? niiniae cae?eniaiiy yai/iei ii?yaeeii oe?a?inueei? aaoiiii??”
[28].

O nai?o niiaaaeao e?aea? eaaeao?a ienaa, ui i?i?no?e-eaaeaoe caeiaeenue
nai?th ni?aaith ? i?yeeo eiioe?eo?a ia ooeaee. Aea eiioe?eoia neooaoe?y
neeaeanue aeey ieo ye aeey eaaeao?a c iaoe?iiaeueiiai ieoaiiy. Ia eiai
aeoieo, aeaye? ia?iaee, ianaiia?aae O?ieyiae?y oa Oe?a?ia, i?aaioee
nei?enoaoeny ?in?enueeith niooith aeey iiaiiai a?aeie?aieaiiy a?ae
?in??. O?inuee? th?enoe aei oeueiai ?oee iaa?aaei?oa ? oiioa. “Oaiaoeee
oe?a?inueeiai ?ooo ia /ie? c i?ioani?ii A?ooaanueeei aea?aee oeyo
oaeoe/iiai caoiieaiiy aieiaieo iiceoe?e. Oeei oeyoii, ei?enooth/enue
iaia?ciai?noth ?in?enueei? aeaaee c ieoaiiyi, oe?a?inuee? iie?oeee
aeiaeeenue cia/ieo aeinyaiaiue, iaae?eyth/e nai? i?noeaa? onoaiiae
aea?aeaaieie i?aaaie. Aea aeieoiaio c?aaeaeoaaa ?ioa?ane ?in?? ?, e??i
oiai, aoa th?eaee/ii iaa?aiioiei” [29].

O nai?io caeeeeo, iioae?eiaaiiio 6 eeiiy 1917 ?., OeE
Eiinoeoooe?eii-aeaiie?aoe/ii? ia?o?? iiyniea i?e/eie aeoiaeo nai?o
i?aaenoaaiee?a c? neeaaeo Oei/aniaiai o?yaeo. Na?aae ieo:
iani?iiiaei?noue o?yaeo caaacia/eoe a e?a?i? ?aeeio aaoi?eoaoio aeaaeo,
?ica?aeiino? o aaaaoueio ieoaiiyo aioo??oiuei? ? ciai?oiuei? iie?oeee
i?ae i?aaenoaaieeaie ia?o?? ? a?eueo?noth o?yaeiaoe?a. Inoaii?i ?
iniaeeai yne?aaei i?eeeaaeii noaei i?eeiyooy o?yaeii o aioiaiio
aeaeyae?, aac iaaeaiiy iiaeeeaino? c?iaeoe ci?ie, oaiaee c oe?a?inueeith
?aaeith, oeeaaeaii? o?ueiia /eaiaie Oei/aniaiai o?yaeo, ye? ?caeeee aeey
iiia?aaei?o ia?aaiai??a o Ee?a.

Uiaei oe?a?inueeiai ieoaiiy, oi OeE aecia? iaiao?aei?noue aei?aoethaaiiy
i?iaeoo iaeanii? aaoiiii?? Oe?a?ie aeey aianaiiy a Onoaiia/? Cai?e. Aea
OeE aaaaea?, ui “iaaaeia noai?aiiy i?noeaai? aeaaee, a?aeiia?aeaeueii?
ia?aae i?noeaaith a?iiaaenueeith i?aai?caoe??th ? iieeeeaii?
ooieoe?iioaaoe c iaaecia/aieie iiaiiaaaeaiiyie ? ia iaaecia/ai?e
oa?eoi???, a oaeiae caa/ania ae?aaeaiiy o?yaeii ni?a/oooy i?iaeoo
iaeanii? aaoiiii??, ci?no yeiai caeeoa?oueny o?yaeo iaa?aeiiei, ?
iaaeiionoeiei ? iaaacia/iei i?aoeaaeaioii, yeee ?iaeoue c?icoi?eei
aieaaeyaeaiiy Onoaiia/eo Cai??a ? iniiai? ?ene iaeaooiueiai aea?aeaaiiai
eaaeo ?in??. OeE aaaaea?, ui eiai iaeiiaeoioe? a o?yae?, iicaaaeai?
iiaeeeaino? aieeaaoe ia ci?no aeoa ? i?eaanoe eiai o a?aeiia?aei?noue c
aeiiaaie iniiaieo ia/ae aea?aeaaiiai i?aaa oa c ?ioa?anaie ?in??, ia
iiaeooue ianoe a?aeiia?aeaeuei?noue ca oeae e?ie ? ca eiai iiaeeea?
iane?aeee” [30].

Ae?oeiaaiee i?aai oa?niinueeeo eaaeao?a oe?a?inueea ieoaiiy iacaaa
iaei??th c i?e/ei ?iceieo o neeaae? o?yaeo. Ia iath/e ia oa
iiaiiaaaeaiue, Oea?aoae? ? Oa?auaiei i?eaacee iacaaeia?eueio ca oi?iith
? ci?noii oaiaeo c ?aaeith. A. Oeiaa?ueia a?ae ?iai? i?i?no??a eaaeao?a
cayaea, ui aiie ia iiaeooue i?aeienaoe oeae aeieoiaio, ine?eueee
ii?ooaoue eeyoao aeiianoe anth iiaiioo aeaaee ? aeiaanoe ?in?th oe?eith
? iaooeiaeaeaiith aei Onoaiia/eo Cai??a, oiio neeaaeathoue iiaiiaaaeaiiy
/eai?a o?yaeo. “Oe?a?inueea ieoaiiy ia aoei o?eueee i?eaiaeii, aea
ni?aaaeiueith i?e/eiith, inoaiiueith e?aieath, yea ia?aiiaieea /aoo
oa?i?iiy ? cioneea ian aeeoe c eaa?iaoo. Ae??oaiiy oe?a?inueeiai ieoaiiy
iaei a cia/aiiy aeey ae??oaiiy iaoe?iiaeueiiai ieoaiiy acaaae? a ?in??.
Oiae? a c’yaeeanue iecea iiae?aieo aeiia a?ae ?ioeo iaoe?iiaeueiinoae”,
– cayaeya eaaeaonueeee aen-i?i?no?. Eiai eyeaei oa, ui i?aeienaiee o
Ee?a? aeieoiaio noaia i?e/eiith iiyae eii?e, ca yeeie aiie ciooai?
aoaeooue iieaoeoe oe? aaenae?. Oi/a o?yae ? yaeya niaith nia?ae?ciaaiee
i?aai?ci /a?ac noia?a/iino? i?ae a?eueo?noth ? iaio?noth, iiiaio
?iciaaeo ianoaa c oe?a?inueeiai ieoaiiy, yea noaei inoaiiueith eaieith a
eaioethc? eiioe?eo?a. “sseui ?ai?oa a ia aoei ?ioeo eiioe?eo?a, oi
oe?a?inueea ieoaiiy aoei a aeinoaoiueith i?e/eiith aeey iaoiai aeoiaeo”,
– i?aeaiaeea aeniiaee A. Oeiaa?ueia [31].

Aino??e e?eoeoe? i?aeaeaa aeaeea?aoe?th aa?ii A. Iieueaea, a?aeiiee
th?eno, aieiaiee aenia?o eiinoeoooe?eii-aeaiie?aoe/ii? ia?o?? c
i?aeia?iaeieo a?aeiinei: “Iaoaeaeei?o/, i?ae aeaiia ii?caeaie, o?e
?in?enueeeo i?i?no?e ? i?io. A?ooaanueeee aeiiiaeeenue i?i ooai?aiiy
oe?a?inueei? aea?aeaae”. Ia aeoieo A. Iieueaea, “i? Oe?a?ie, i? ?? ?aaee
a ?in?enueeiio i?aa? aei ii?caeee o?ueio i?i?no??a ia ?nioaaei” [32].
Aeaeea?aoe?y Oei/aniaiai o?yaeo a?ae 2 eeiiy oa Oi?aa?nae Oeaio?aeueii?
?aaee a?ae 3 eeiiy iaa’ycaee ia o?eueee ?aaeo Oe?a?i?, aea e Oe?a?io
?in??. ?in?enueeee th?eno caeeaiaaiee ?iciaoii iie?oe/ii? oai?/ino? oeeo
aeieoiaio?a, “a yeeo ia o?eueee iiaecia ? ni?eea?noue, a aacnoii?aiee
iaeiinoi?iii?e aeo aea?aeaaii-i?aaiaiai iaiaio, a yeiio, c iaeiiai aieo,
a?ae/oaa?oueny aeina?ae/aia ?oea noa?iai ?a?iiaenueeiai iie?oe/iiai
ai?oey, aeoiaaiiai o oeie? oiieeo iie?oe/ieo oi?ioe ? neeaaeii?
iie?oe/ii? ai?ioueae (I. N. A?ooaanueeee – E. U.), a c ?ioiai,
iaaeina?ae/aiee ? i?/ei ia aeoeieaiee “?aaiethoe?eiee aiooc?aci” [33].
Iaea?eueoa iaaaeiaieaiiy o A. Iieueaea aeeeeeaa ?iciiae?e aeaaee i?ae
?in??th oa Oe?a?iith, ine?eueee a?i ??oioo?oueny ia iiai?e e?ea?aeaoe??
iiaiiaaaeaiue ?in??, a oaeiae i?ioean iiiiaiaiiy ?aaee iiaeie /eaiaie.

Oe?a?inueeee aeine?aeiee A. Nieaeaoaiei ?icoe?ith? oe?a?inueea ieoaiiy,
niin?a eiai ?ica’ycaiiy I. Ea?ainueeei, I. Oa?auaieii oa ?. Oea?aoae?
nei??oa ye i?ea?ae, a ia i?e/eio aeey ??oo/iai e?ieo eaaeao?a. Ia eiai
aeoieo, o?yaeiao e?eco coiiaeee iie?oe/i? aia?oe?? eaaeao?a, ine?eueee
aiie “aoee i?ioe ?ica’ycaiiy oaei? aaaeeeai? ni?aae aac iiia?aaeiueiai
iiaiaeaeaiiy c ieie” [34]. ?noi?eee I. ?aio ? I. ?oaeueia aaaaeathoue,
ui naia ?acoeueoaoe ee?anueeeo ia?aaiai??a ni?e/eieee i?i?noa?nueeo
e?eco [35].

Aeine?aeiee I. sseoiia eeiiaao iie?oe/io e?eco iaceaa? oeaio?aeueiith
iiae??th o a?aeiineiao eaaeao?a c oe?a?inueeei ?ooii. Aeo?ae
i?i?no??a-eaaeao?a ?c Oei/aniaiai o?yaeo a ca’yceo c oe?a?inueeei
ieoaiiyi aeeeeeaa caeeoaiiy eaa ia?o?? aeayeeie eaaeaoaie-oe?a?iio?eaie,
ca?a no?io iaii?icoi?iiy i?ae OeE ? Ee?anueeei eii?oaoii ia?o??
ia?iaeii? naiaiaee. Eeiiaaa e?eca i?ae??aaea aaoi?eoao ia?o?? eaaeao?a o
ianooaaao on??? e?a?ie ? iineaaeea ?? iiceoe?? a nai?e Oe?a?i?. A?i
?iaeoue aeniiaie, ui iie?oe/ia e?eca eeiiy 1917 ?. noaea e?ecith
?aeaieia?? eaaeaonueei? ia?o??, yea a nai?io ?icaeoeo a?aenoaaaea a?ae
?icaeoeo noni?eueii? na?aeiiino? [36].

?i?oe?aoi? ee?anueeeo ia?aaiai??a ?. Oea?aoae? iiynithaaa aeieeiaiiy
e?ece oei, ui ea??aieee eaaeaonueei? ia?o?? ia?aeoee ia iiceoe??
aaeeeiaea?aeaaiiai oia?i?cio oa ?in?enueeiai iaoe?iiae?cio. Aenoioaoe
aanei ai?ioueae c aaoiiii?nonueeeie i?aaiaiiyie ia?iae?a ?in??, “aiie
niiae?aaeeny i?iaoaeeoe iaoe?iiae?noe/i? ?inoeieoe a ?in?enueeeo
ia?iaeieo ianao ? ciaeoe na?aae oeeo inoaii?o a oea?ei? iaoe?iiaeueiiai
ieoaiiy a?eueoa ni?a/oooy, i?ae o ieoaiiyo nioe?aeueiiai caeiiiaeaanoaa
/e aa?a?ieo caeii?a, aea ?o eeaniaa iiceoe?y a?aeooiaooaaea a?ae ieo
oe?ie? o?oaeyu? aa?noae ?in?enueeiai ia?iaeo” [37].

?aciethoe?y OeE eaaeao?a a?ae 2 eeiiy aoea caoaa?aeaeaia ye iinoaiiaa ia
?O ia?o?eiiio c’?cae? (23-28 eeiiy 1917 ?.), ia yeiio ciiao
aeooae?coaaeinue oe?a?inueea ieoaiiy [38]. Aeiiia?aea/ai c oe???
i?iaeaie aoa I. I?etheia, yeee i?aee?aneea, ui oae? naii/eii?
a?aeie?aieaiiy a?ae ?in?? aei ??oaiiy Onoaiia/eo Cai??a ia ? i?aaeeueiei
ae??oaiiyi iaoe?iiaeueiiai ieoaiiy, oiio iiceoe?y Oe?a?ie aeeeeeaea
i?ioanoe a na?aaeiaeu? eaaeao?a. A?i cayaea, ui “iao? oiaa?eo? ? OeE,
yeee noaaeea ?o niin?a ae?e, aaaaeaee, ui o anyeiio aeiaaeeo ae??ooaaoe
oe?a?inueea ieoaiiy oaeei /eiii, ye aiii aoei ae??oaia, oiaoi oeyoii
naieoe?? yai/iei ii?yaeeii ooai?aieo onoaiia iaaecia/aii? eiiiaoaioe??,
onoaiia, ye? caoiieee iaaecia/aio oa?eoi??th ? ia?aaoaaee o iaaecia/aieo
a?aeiineiao c oeaio?aeueieie onoaiiaaie e aeiaaaee naieoe?? o?eueee aeey
oiai, uia aeeeeeaoe oaeee naiee yai/iee ?icaeoie, ui oeae niin?a
ae??oaiiy iaeiiai c iaea?eueoeo iaoe?iiaeueieo ieoaiue ?in?? iaa?yae /e
i?aaeeueiee, ui a?i iiaea, o aeiaaeeo yeui oaeei niiniaii yai/iiai
ii?yaeeo aoaeooue ae??ooaaoe nai? iaoe?iiaeuei? ieoaiiy ?io?
iaoe?iiaeueiino? aea?aeaae, ni?e/eieoe ae??oaiiy oeyoii aeieiiaieo
oaeo?a oaeiai ieoaiiy, yea iiaea aooe ae??oaii o?eueee Onoaiia/eie
Cai?aie iaeii/anii aeey an??? ?in??” [39]. Iieaciaei ? oie oaeo, ui o
i?an? aoa iioae?eiaaiee nei?i/aiee aa??aio i?iiiae I?etheiaa,
iii’yeoaiee, a a?o?aia ni?aaa i?noeoue aanue oaeno aeiiia?ae?, aea
aeneiaethaaiiy i?i oe?a?inueea ieoaiiy iaaaaaoi ??ce?o?.

27 eeiiy 1917 ?. ia aa/??iueiio can?aeaii? OeE caeeaaeaii i?eioeeie
i?aai?caoe?? eii?n?? c oe?a?inueeiai ieoaiiy. Aei ?? neeaaeo iaee
aoiaeeoe /eaie OeE ? i?aaenoaaieee aoaa?inueeeo eii?oao?a ia?o?? (ii 2 c
eiaeiiai eii?oaoo) oaeeo aoaa?i?e: Ee?anueei?, Aieeinueei?,
Iiae?euenueei?, Aanna?aanueei?, Oa?niinueei?, Oaa??enueei?,
Iieoaanueei?, *a?i?a?anueei?, Oa?e?anueei?, Eaoa?eiineaanueei? ? a?ae
Eoaainueei? iaeano?. Uiaei o/ano? i?aaenoaaiee?a ia?o?? a Oeaio?aeuei?e
?aae? ae??oaii aeciaoe iiaeeeaith o/anoue ia?o?eieo i?aai?caoe?e a?ae
oeo aoaa?i?e, eii?oaoe yeeo aaaaeathoue iaiao?aeiith oaeo o/anoue,
ianaiia?aae Ee?anueeiai iaeaniiai eii?oaoo, aea ?iaioo /eai?a ia?o?? a
Aaia?aeueiiio nae?aoa??ao? aeciaii iaiiaeeeaith [40].

Oaeei /eiii, iiae?? Ethoiaai? ?aaiethoe??, iiaaeaiiy naiiaea?aeaanoaa
cioneee eiinoeoooe?eii-aeaiie?aoe/io ia?o?th aianoe ei?aeoeae aei nai??
i?ia?aie ?, cie?aia, ci?ieoe ioieoe, ui noinoaaeenue iaoe?iiaeueiiai
ieoaiiy. Iaeiae ci?ie ia i?noeee aeiia aaoiiiiiiai ono?ith Oe?a?ie, ye
ia oa niiae?aaeenue eaaeaoe-oe?a?iio?ee oa oe?a?ioe?, a?aoiaoth/e
i?aeianaiiy iaoe?iiaeueii-aecaieueiiai ?ooo, yeee aaea ia iaiaaeoaaany
o?eueee eoeueoo?ieie aeiiaaie, a aenoaaa aanei iie?oe/ii? aaoiiii??. O
aa?aci? 1917 ?. eaaeaoe aeciaee aeinoaoi?i iaaeaiiy i?aaiai i?noeaaiai
naiia?yaeoaaiiy i?aaa i?ia?ioe?eii? aaoiiii??, oiaoi iiaeeeaino?
iiaeaiiy ni?eueieo eeiiioaiue c ieoaiue ?o eiiiaoaioe?? aei
oeaio?aeueieo onoaiia oa aeaeaiiy ii?iaoeaieo aeo?a o noa?ao
ainiiaea?nueei? oa eoeueoo?ii? ae?yeueiino?. Oaeo ooai?aiiy
Oeaio?aeueii? ?aaee, i?iaieioaiiy ? Oi?aa?naeo iaaaoeaii ioe?ithaaeenue
eaaeaoaie ye iiae?? ia?aae/ani?, iacaeiii?, iaaacia/i? aeey oe?e?niino?
?in??. Oa?aeoa?ia aeey e?aa?ae?a ?eoi?eea i?i ??ai?noue i?aa iaoe?e ia
eoeueoo?ii-iaoe?iiaeueia naiiaecia/aiiy aoea cai?iaia caeeeeaie i?i
caa?aaeaiiy ?aeiino? ? iaiiae?eueiino? ?in??, ui aoei i?eoaiaiia aei
Ethoiaai? ?aaiethoe?? ianaiia?aae ?in?enueeei ia?o?yi iaoe?iiae?noe/iiai
ni?yioaaiiy. Aaaii?noue Oe?a?ie aeey caa?aaeaiiy oe?e?niino? ?in??
i?aeoaa?aeeea eeiiaaa o?yaeiaa e?eca, i?e/eiith yei? noaa aeo?ae c
eiae?oe?? i?i?no??a-eaaeao?a, eio?? ia iiaiaeeeenue c i?eioeeiii
aaoiiii?? Oe?a?ie. Noaaeaiiy ia?o?? aei oe?a?inueeiai ieoaiiy i?ioyaii
aa?aciy-eeiiy 1917 ?. cana?ae/eei aeaeea?aoeai?noue on?o iiia?aaei?o
iaoe?iiaeueieo aeiia eaaeao?a. Oe?a?inueeee ?oo ?icaeyaeaany
eiinoeoooe?eii-aeaiie?aoe/iith ia?o??th ye ?aaeueiee /eiiee ?iciaaeo
?in??, iaaacia/iee eaoae?caoi? caaino?aiiy aioo??oi?o i?ioe??/ o
aea?aeaa?.

E?oa?aoo?a:

1. Eiiei A. A. Enoi?ey iiiaue/ueeo, ao?aeoaciuo e iaeeiao?aeoaciuo
iieeoe/aneeo ia?oee a ?innee. – A 2 /. – *. 1. – Eaeeiei, 1970. – N.
196.

2. Ieioe E. E. Enoi?ey Aaeeeiai Ieoya?y. – A 3 o. – O. 2. – I., 1978. –
N. 514; Neaaei I. O. Ec enoi?ee etheueneiai iieeoe/aneiai e?ecena 1917
a.// Enoi?ey NNN?. – 1957. – ?2. – N. 133.

3. Aiiaea?aiei Ae. ss., E?anoianeay I. I. Ia?aaiai?u A?aiaiiiai
i?aaeoaeuenoaa e Oe?aeineie Oeaio?aeueiie ?aaeu aaniie e eaoii 1917
aiaea // Ioa/anoaaiiay enoi?ey. – 2002. – ? 2. – N. 83-96; Eoaeeae I. A.
Ia?aaiai?e Oeaio?aeueii? ?aaee ? i?aaenoaaiee?a Oei/aniaiai o?yaeo
(28-30 /a?aiy 1917 ?.) // Oe?a?inueeee ?noi?e/iee aeo?iae. – 1999. – ?
6. – N. 43-54; Nieaeaoaieia A. O. Oe?a?inueea ?aaiethoe?y. ?noi?e/iee
ia?en. – E., 1999. – 976 n.

4. Nuacaeu e eiioa?aioeee eiinoeoooeeiiii-aeaiie?aoe/aneie ia?oee. – A 3
o. -O. 3. – Ei. 1. – 1915-1917 aa. – I., 2000. – N. 551.

5. Oai naii. – N. 554.

6. Oai naii. – N. 559.

7. Oai naii. – N. 564-569.

8. Oai naii. – N. 660, 662.

9. VIII nuacae ia?oee Ia?iaeiie Naiaiaeu // Aanoiee ia?oee ia?iaeiie
naiaiaeu. – 1917. – ? 14-16. – N. 12.

10. Oai naii.

11. Oai naii. – N. 11.

12. Oai naii. – N. 15.

13. Oai naii. – N. 16.

14. Oai naii.

15. Ieetheia I. Eoiae VIII nuacaea ia?oee Ia?iaeiie Naiaiaeu // Aanoiee
ia?oee ia?iaeiie naiaiaeu. – 1917. – ? 2. – N. 1.

16. Oai naii. – N. 3.

17. ssiaanueeee Ae. Iie?oe/i? nenoaie Oe?a?ie 1917-1920 ?ie?a: ni?iae
oai?aiiy ? i?e/eie ii?acee. – E.,2003. – N. 93.

18. Aa?nothe A. O., Ai?iaaoeue A. I., Oiei/ei I. I. Oe?a?ia ? ?in?y a
?noi?e/i?e ?ao?iniaeoea?: Oe?a?inuee? i?iaeoe a ?in?enuee?e ?iia???. –
E., 2004. – N. 434.

19. Aeiie/aiei A. A?ae?iaeaeaiiy iaoe??. – E.,1990. – *. ?. – N.
167-168.

20. Oe?a?inueeee iaoe?iiaeueii-aecaieueiee ?oo. Aa?acaiue-eenoiiaae 1917
?ieo: Aeieoiaioe ? iaoa??aee. – E., 2003. – N. 430.

21. Ainoaea?noaaiiue a?oea ?inneeneie Oaaea?aoeee (aeaeueoa – AA?O), o.
523, ii. 2, ae. 24. – A?e. 1.

22. Oai naii. – A?e. 2.

23. Oai naii. – A?e. 3.

24. Oai naii. – A?e. 5.

25. Oai naii. – A?e. 7.

26. I?ioieieu Oeaio?aeueiiai Eiieoaoa e caa?aie/iuo a?oii
eiinoeoooeeiiii-aeaiie?aoe/aneie ia?oee. – A 6-oe o. – O. 3. 1915-1920.
– I., 1998. – N. 380.

27. Oai naii. – N. 381.

28. Ieetheia I. I. Enoi?ey aoi?ie ?onneie ?aaiethoeee. – Ii., 2002. – N.
202.

29. Ieetheia I. I. Ainiiieiaiey. – I., 2001. – N. 630-631.

30. Aiccaaiea Oeaio?aeueiiai eiieoaoa // Aanoiee ia?oee ia?iaeiie
naiaiaeu. – 1917. – ? 8-10. – N. 10; AA?O, o. 523, ii. 2, ni?. 22. –
a?e. 3-3 ia.

31. Iaioeeiaa A. A. Ii/aio eaaeaou ooee ecu ninoaaa A?aiaiiiai
i?aaeoaeuenoaa // Ia?iaeiay Naiaiaea. – 1917. – 17 ethey. – N. 2.

32. Iieueaea A. Y. Aeiaiai?u nu ?aaeie // ?a/ue. – 1917. – 7 ?they. –
N. 1.

33. Oai naii.

34. Nieaeaoaiei A. O. Iaca. i?aoey. – N. 250.

35. ?a?io I. I. O ?ia?oiyo ?noi?e/ii? iaoee. – E., 1999. – N. 58;
?oaeueia I. N., ?a?io I. I. Oe?a?inuee? aecaieuei? ciaaaiiy 1917-1921
??. – E., 1999. – N. 56.

36. sseoiia I. I. Ae?yeuei?noue eiinoeoooe?eii-aeaiie?aoe/ii? ia?o?? a
Oe?a?i? (1917-1918 ? ?.). Aaoi?aoa?ao ia caeiaoooy no. eaiae. ?no. iaoe.
– E., 1994. – N. 15.

37. Aa?nothe A. O., Ai?iaaoeue A. I., Oiei/ei I. I. Oe?a?ia ? ?in?y a
?noi?e/i?e ?ao?iniaeoea?: Oe?a?inuee? i?iaeoe a ?in?enuee?e ?iia???. –
E., 2004. – N. 442.

38. Iinoaiiaeaiey ?O nuacaea ia?oee ia?iaeiie naiaiaeu // Aanoiee ia?oee
ia?iaeiie naiaiaeu. – 1917. – ? 11-13. – N.12-13

39. AA?O, o. 579,ii. 1, ae. 745. – A?e. 1.

40. AA?O, o. 523, ii. 2, ae. 22. – A?e. 11.

Нашли опечатку? Выделите и нажмите CTRL+Enter

Похожие документы
Обсуждение

Ответить

Курсовые, Дипломы, Рефераты на заказ в кратчайшие сроки
Заказать реферат!
UkrReferat.com. Всі права захищені. 2000-2020