Організація контролю в управлінні діяльністю підприємств споживчої кооперації у сучасних умовах: Автореф. дис… канд. екон. наук / А.М. Ткаченко, НАН

IAOe?IIAEUeIA AEAAeAI?ss IAOE OE?A?IE

?INOEOOO AEIIII?EE I?IIENEIAINO?

Ia i?aaao ?oeiieno

OAeE: O29:O053.3

OEA*AIEI AEEA IEOAEE?AIA

I?aai?caoe?y eiio?ieth a oi?aae?ii? ae?yeuei?noth i?aei?e?inoa
niiaeea/i? eiiia?aoe?? o no/anieo oiiaao

Niaoe?aeuei?noue 08.06.01 – Aeiiii?ea i?aei?e?inoaa ? i?aai?caoe?y

ae?iaieoeoaa

Aaoi?aoa?ao

aeena?oaoe?? ia caeiaoooy iaoeiaiai

nooiaiy eaiaeeaeaoa aeiiii?/ieo iaoe

Aeiiaoeuee — 1999

Aeena?oaoe??th ? ?oeiien.

?iaioa aeeiiaia ia eaoaae?? aeiiii?ee ? i?aai?caoe?? ae?iaieoeoaa
Caii??cueei? aea?aeaaii? ?iaeaia?ii? aeaaeai?? I?i?noa?noaa ina?oe
Oe?a?ie (i. Caii??aeaey).

Iaoeiaee ea??aiee – aeieoi? aeiiii?/ieo iaoe, i?ioani?

Naiaiia A?eai??e Aioiiiae/,

Caii??cueea aea?aeaaia ?iaeaia?ia aeaaeai?y I?i?noa?noaa ina?oe Oe?a?ie,
caa?aeoaa/ eaoaae?e aeiiii?ee ? i?aai?caoe?? ae?iaieoeoaa

Io?oe?ei? iiiiaioe: aeieoi? aeiiii?/ieo iaoe, i?ioani?

Niiei Aaneeue Aaneeueiae/,

Ee?anueeee iaoe?iiaeueiee aeiiii?/iee oi?aa?neoao I?i?noa?noaa ina?oe
Oe?a?ie (i.Ee?a ),i?ioani? eaoaae?e iae?eo ? aoaeeoo i?iieneiaino?;

eaiaeeaeao aeiiii?/ieo iaoe, aeioeaio,

Caneoaeaiee i?aoe?aiee aeui? oeiee

Oaothoa Eaii?ae Eocueie/,

Caii??cueeee aea?aeaaiee oaoi?/iee

oi?aa?neoao I?i?noa?noaa ina?oe Oe?a?ie

(i.Caii??aeaey ), aeioeaio eaoaae?e aeiiii?ee oa i?aai?caoe??
ae?iaieoeoaa.

I?ia?aeia onoaiiaa — Aeiiaoeueea aea?aeaaia aeaaeai?y oi?aae?iiy

I?i?noa?noaa ina?oe Oe?a?ie (i. Aeiiaoeuee), eaoaae?a caaaeueiiai ?
aaei?i?no?aoeaiiai iaiaaeaeiaioo.

Caoeno a?aeaoaeaoueny «_21_» _aeiaoiy_1999 ?. i _16:00_aiaeei? ia
can?aeaii? niaoe?ae?ciaaii? a/aii? ?aaee Ae 11.151.01 a ?inoeooo?
aeiiii?ee i?iieneiaino? IAI Oe?a?ie ca aae?anith: 340048, Aeiiaoeuee-48,
aoe. Oi?aa?neoaonueea, 77.

C aeena?oaoe??th iiaeia iciaeiieoenue o a?ae?ioaoe? ?inoeoooo aeiiii?ee
i?iieneiaino? IAI Oe?a?ie ca aae?anith: 340048, Aeiiaoeuee-48, aoe.
Oi?aa?neoaonueea, 77.

Aaoi?aoa?ao ?ic?neaiee «_18_» _aa?aniy_ 1999 ?.

A/aiee nae?aoa?

niaoe?ae?ciaaii? a/aii? ?aaee Iieeiinueeee O.TH.

CAAAEUeIA OA?AEOA?ENOEEA AeENA?OAOe?EII? ?IAIOE

Aeooaeuei?noue oaie. Eiio?ieue ca noaiii aeiiii?ee o ia?ao?aeiee
ia??iae, a oiio /ene? o?iainiaee eiio?ieue, ? aaaeeeaith noa?ith
ae?yeueiino? ii oi?aae?iith ia?iaeiei ainiiaea?noaii. Eiai i?ecia/aiiy
iieyaa? o ni?eyii? oni?oi?e ?aae?caoe?? o?iainiai? iie?oeee iaoi?
aea?aeaae, caaacia/aii? i?ioeano oi?ioaaiiy ? aoaeoeaiiai aeei?enoaiiy
o?iainiaeo ?ano?n?a ? iioeiaeueiiai ?iciiae?eo aioo??oiueiai aaeiaiai
i?iaeoeoo.

A oiiaao oi?ioaaiiy iiaiai aeiiii?/iiai iaoai?cio, cia/ii c?inoathoue
aeiiae aei o?iainiaiai eiio?ieth, yeee ni?ey? e?ea?aeaoe?? ?
caiia?aaiith an?eyeeo ao?ao. Ii?yae ?c caaacia/aiiyi aeeiiaiiy iniiaii?
nai?? ooieoe?? – iiia?aaeaeaiiy i?i oaeoe/i? a?aeoeeaiiy eiio?ieueiaaieo
aaee/ei a?ae noni?eueii iaiao?aeiiai ??aiy ? aeiia aeiiii?/ieo caeii?a a
?eieiaeo oiiaao o?iainiaee eiio?ieue, a oiio ae /ene? ?aa?c?? ?
ia?aa??ee, ye ? aoaeue-yea ?ioa noa?a oi?aae?iiy o?iainaie, iiaeii? aooe
aeiiii?/ii iaa?oioiaai?, oiaoi ia?aae ?aa?c??th, ia?aa??eith ?
aoaeue-yeei ?ioei aeaeii o?iainiaiai eiio?ieth iinoa? caaaeaiiy
aeinyaiaiiy iaeneioio ei?eniiai aoaeoo o ?ic?aooieo ia eiaeio iaeeieoeth
cao?ao i?iaaaeaiiy eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eii? ?iaioe. Cacia/aia caaaeaiiy
iiaea aooe ae??oaia ca aeiiiiiaith ?ic?iaee i?ia?ai ? ai?iaaaeaeaiiy
eiii’thoa?ii? oaoi?ee, aeiiii?ei-iaoaiaoe/ieo iaoiae?a, a oaeiae
iaoeiai? i?aai?caoe?? i?aoe?, a oiio /ene? ii?ioaaiiy i?aoe? o noa??
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eii? ?iaioe.

O ia??iae oi?ioaaiiy ?eieiai? aeiiii?ee iiai?noth ci?ith?oueny no?oeoo?a
caaaeaiue, iiaeeaeth?oueny ?ioaa?aoe?y iaoeiai-ae?iaie/i? oi?aae?inueei?
ae?yeueiino?, ? o ca’yceo c oeei, aeieeea iaaaeueia iio?aaa iiooeo iiaeo
i?aeoiae?a aei aaeineiiaeaiiy i?aoe? oi?aae?inueeiai ia?niiaeo ?,
cie?aia, eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a. A oie aea /an i?iaaaeaiiy
?aoi?i a oi?aae?ii? aeiiii?eith na?ae/eoue i?i iii?oi? ?ica?aeiino? i?ae
i/?eoaaieie ? ?aaeueieie ?acoeueoaoaie. A oea, aac noii?ao, na?ae/eoue
ia o?eueee i?i neeaaei?noue ? aeeaeio ci?i, aea ? i?i iayai?noue
oai?aoe/ieo i?i?aooie?a, aeei?enoaiiy iaaeinoaoiuei iaa?oioiaaieo
iaoeiaeo i?aeoiae?a aei ?ica’ycaiiy iiaeo caaaeaiue. Aeiiii?/ia iaoea
aeyaeeanue iai?aeaioiaeaiith aei oaeeo ??ceeo ci?i, aiane?aeie /iai
i?aei?e?inoaa a?ae/oaathoue cia/iee aeao?oeeo iaoeiaeo ?ic?iaie ?
i?aeoe/ieo ?aeiiaiaeaoe?e a aaeoc? i?aai?caoe?? ? ii?ioaaiiy i?aoe?
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a.

Ia?ao?ae i?aai?caoe?e niiaeea/i? eiiia?aoe?? aei ?eieiaeo noinoie?a
aenoaa? ?yae i?iaeai i?aai?caoe?eiiai, oaoi?/iiai ? iaoiaeieia?/iiai
oa?aeoa?o, o neeaae? yeeo aaaeeeaiai cia/aiiy iaaoaa? i?iaeaia
ca?eueoaiiy aoaeoeaiino? eiio?ieth ca caa?aaeaiiyi eiiia?aoeaii?
aeaniino? ia iniia? aaeineiiaeaiiy i?aai?caoe?? ? ii?ioaaiiy i?aoe?
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a. Ia?oi/a?aiaa oaaaa o caaacia/aii?
caa?aaeaiiy eiiia?aoeaii? aeaniino? a oiiaao ia?aoiaeo aei ?eieo iiaeiia
i?eae?eyoeny aioo??oiuei-a?aeii/iio eiio?ieth, yeee cae?enith?oueny o
iiia?aaeiueiio, iioi/iiio ? iiaeaeueoiio ii?yaeeo. A oie aea /an
iaaeaiiy i?aei?e?inoaai ainiiaea?nueei? naiino?eiino? i?ecaaei aei
iaiaa?oioiaaiiai nei?i/aiiy /enaeueiino? eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo
i?aoe?aiee?a, a oea aeeeeeaei o ?yae? aeiaaee?a nei?i/aiiy ia?aa??ie ?
?aa?c?e aac aoaeue-yeeo i?aenoaa. Ia no/aniiio aoai? oiiae
ainiiaea?thaaiiy aeiaaathoue, a ia?oo /a?ao, aaeineiiaeaiiy
i?aai?caoe?eii? no?oeoo?e eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo neoaea, a ia
aaci?aenoaaiiai ?o nei?i/aiiy. Iaoeiai iaa?oioiaaiee i?aeo?ae aei
eiiieaeniiai aiae?co aieeao oeeo oaeoi??a ? ? aoaeoeaiith ia?aaeoiiaith
?ic?iaee iniiaieo iai?yie?a ?ai?aai?caoe?? eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo
neoaea. Iaoiaee/i? iniiae i?aai?caoe?? ? ii?ioaaiiy i?aoe?
a?aeia?aaeai? o ?iaioao aeine?aeiee?a: A?eooe I.O., Ae?noa?a A.I.,
Eo?ae N.A., Iieeiinueeiai O.TH., I?ieiiaiei I.Ae., Iiiiia?ueiaa ?.O.,
?aeeonueeeo A.I., Naiaiiaa A.A., Niiea A.A., *oia/aiei I.A. oa ?i.

A ?nioth/eo iaoiaee/ieo ?ic?iaeao ? ?aeiiaiaeaoe?yo ii ii?ioaaiith
i?aoe?, a oaeiae i?aai?caoe?? aioo??oiueia?aeii/iai eiio?ieth o
ii?aeiaii? c aioo??oi?ie ia?aa??eaie c aieo i?aei?e?inoaa, aeine?aeaeai?
ia an? i?iaeaie i?aai?caoe?? ? iaoiaeieia?? aioo??oiueiainiiaea?nueeiai
eiio?ieth, iniaeeai o ia?ao?aei?e aeiiii?oe?. Iaia? ?ic?iaie c
aecia/aiiy iioeiaeueiiai neeaaeo ? no?oeoo?e eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eiiai
a?aeae?eo. A oiiaao ooai?aiiy iiaeo i?aai?caoe?eieo oi?i eiio?ieth, ia
iniia? iiaiiai aini?ic?aooieo, aeieea? iaiao?aei?noue aaeineiiaeaiiy
ae?th/eo ? ?ic?iaee iiaeo niinia?a ? i?eeii?a eiio?ieth, aeei?enoaiiy
yeeo aeicaiey? aeyaeoe oaeoe i?eoiaoaaiiy ceiaaeeaaiue, ianoa/ ?
e?aae?aeie. Ana oea ? aecia/a? aeooaeuei?noue oaie aeena?oaoe??.

Ca’ycie ?iaioe c iaoeiaeie i?ia?aiaie. Ia?aiee iai?yiie aeine?aeaeaiiy,
eiai oai?aoe/i? ? iaoiaee/i? iieiaeaiiy iaa?oioiaai? i?ae /an ?ic?iaee
oaie ?13-11/97 “Aeine?aeaeaiiy i?iaeai aaeineiiaeaiiy
o?iainiai-aeiiii?/iiai aiae?co aeey iioeiaeueieo aa??aio?a
aoaeeoi?nueeeo iineoa c iaoith i?aeaeuaiiy aoaeoeaiino? ae?iaieoeoaa”,
aeeiiaieie a Caii??cuee?e aea?aeaai?e ?iaeaia?i?e aeaaeai?? I?i?noa?noaa
ina?oe Oe?a?ie.

Iaoa ? caaaeaiiy aeine?aeaeaiiy. Iaoith aeena?oaoe?eii? ?iaioe ?
aeine?aeaeaiiy eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eii? ?iaioe ? ?ic?iaea iaoeiai
iaoiaee/ieo iieiaeaiue ii aaeineiiaeaiith i?aai?caoe??, ii?ioaaiiy ?
ioe?iee ?acoeueoao?a ?iaioe neoaeaiaoe?a o aaeoc? niiaeea/i? eiiia?aoe??
?c canoinoaaiiyi aeiiii?ei-iaoaiaoe/ieo iaoiae?a ? ia/enethaaeueii?
oaoi?ee.

O a?aeiia?aeiino? c iaoith o ?iaio? aoei iinoaaeaii ? ?ica’ycaii oae?
iniiai? caaaeaiiy:

ocaaaeueiaii caeiiii??iino? ?icaeoeo i?aai?caoe?? oi?aae?iiy eiio?ieai
ia no/aniiio aoai?, a oaeiae iiaeeaeaii oai?aoe/i? iieiaeaiiy i?i
nooi?noue, niaoeeo?/i? iniaeeaino? ? i?eioeeie i?aai?caoe?? i?aoe?
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a niiaeea/i? eiiia?aoe?? a ia?ao?aeiee
ia??iae;

cai?iiiiiaaii i?eioeeie ii?ioaaiiy i?aoe? eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo
i?aoe?aiee?a c o?aooaaiiyi iniaeeainoae ?iaioe i?aei?e?inoa o ia??iae
ia?aoiaeo aei ?eieo;

aeine?aeaeaii iaoiaee/i? iieiaeaiiy ? ii?iaoeai? aeoe i?iaaaeaiiy
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eii? ?iaioe o niiaeea/?e eiiia?aoe?? o ia?ao?aeiee
ia??iae ? cai?iiiiiaaii iaoiaeeeo ia?aa??ee a oiiaao ianoaa?eueii?
?iaioe;

i?iaiae?ciaaii ?nioth/? ? iiaeeeai i?iaiiciaai? oaiaeaioe?? o ?icaeoeo
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eii? ?iaioe o ?eieiaeo oiiaao;

aeaii ioe?ieo ?nioth/iio noaio i?aai?caoe?? ? ii?ioaaiith
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a o nenoai? niiaeea/i? eiiia?aoe?? ?
aecia/aii oaeoi?e, ye? aieeaathoue ia /enaeuei?noue i?aoe?aiee?a;

?ic?iaeaii iaoiaeeeo ? aeiiii?ei-iaoaiaoe/ia iiaeaeue ?ic?aooieo ii?i
aeo?ao i?aoe? eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a c o?aooaaiiyi iniiaieo
oaeoi??a ?iaioe i?aei?e?inoa niiaeea/i? eiiia?aoe??;

oaeineiiaeaii nenoaio i?aai?caoe?? aioo??oiueia?aeii/iai eiio?ieth o
ii?aeiaii? c aioo??oi?ie ia?aa??eaie ? eiio?ieai c aieo i?aei?e?inoa;

cai?iiiiiaaii iaoiaee ? i?eeiie ?aoe?iiaeueii? i?aai?caoe??
aioo??oiueia?aeii/iai eiio?ieth a ?eieiaeo oiiaao ia iniia? iii?oi?eiao.

I?aaeiao ? ia’?eo aeine?aeaeaiiy. I?aaeiaoii aeine?aeaeaiiy ? iaoiaee
i?aai?caoe?? eiio?ieth, ii?ioaaiiy ? ioe?iee ?acoeueoao?a i?aoe?
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a niiaeea/i? eiiia?aoe?? o ia??iae
o?ainoi?iaoe?? aeiiii?ee. Ia’?eoii aeine?aeaeaiiy aeena?oaoe?eii? ?iaioe
? i?aei?e?inoaa niiaeea/i? eiiia?aoe?? ? ?o ie?ai? i?ae?icae?ee.

Iaoiaeieia?y ? iaoiaeeea aeine?aeaeaiiy. Oai?aoe/iith ? iaoiaeieia?/iith
iniiaith ?iaioe ? ia’?eoeai? aeiiii?/i? caeiie, eio?? ooieoe?iiothoue o
ia?ao?aei?e aeiiii?oe?, caeiiiaeaa/? ? ii?iaoeai? aeoe Oe?a?ie a aaeoc?
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eii? ?iaioe, iaoiaeieia?/i? ? iaoiaee/i? ?ic?iaee
a?o/eciyieo ? ca?oa?aeieo a/aieo a aaeoc? i?aai?caoe?? ae?iaieoeoaa ?
i?aoe? neoaeaiaoe?a, aeani? aeine?aeaeaiiy ? ?ic?iaee, aeeiiai? o
i?ioean? ?iaioe o eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aaiao niiaeea/i? eiiia?aoe??.

Iaoeiaa iiaecia io?eiaieo ?acoeueoao?a. Iaoeiaa iiaecia ?acoeueoao?a
aeine?aeaeaiue iieyaa? o ?ic?iaoe? iieiaeaiue ia iniia? aea/aiiy ?
ocaaaeueiaiiy iaoeiaeo ?ia?o a?o/eciyieo ? ca?oa?aeieo aeine?aeiee?a ii
i?aai?caoe?? ? ii?ioaaiith i?aoe? oi?aae?inueeiai ia?niiaeo noiniaii aei
oiia i?aoe? i?aoe?aiee?a niiaeea/i? eiiia?aoe??, ? cie?aia,
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a. ?ic?iaeai? i?iiiceoe?? ni?yiiaaii
ia i?aeaeuaiiy iaoeiaiai ??aiy eiio?ieth, ye ooieoe?? ? neeaaeiai?
/anoeie oi?aae?iiy i?aei?e?inoaaie niiaeea/i? eiiia?aoe??,
oaeineiiaeaiiy iaoiaeeee eiio?ieth ca caa?aaeaiiy eiiia?aoeaii?
aeaniino? a oiiaao eiii’thoa??caoe?? aooaaeoa?nueeiai iae?eo, iineeaiiy
ae??aino? aioo??oiueia?aeii/iai eiio?ieth a ii?aeiaii? c aioo??oi?ie
ia?aa??eaie.

Aei iaea?eueo aaaiieo ?acoeueoao?a, ye? a?aeia?aaeathoue aeaiaioe
iaoeiai? iiaecie, iaeaaeaoue oae? iieiaeaiiy:

aeine?aeaeaii ? ocaaaeueiaii iniiai? iai?yiee ?icaeoeo iaoeiaiai ??aiy
eiio?ieth ye ooieoe?? ? neeaaeiai? /anoeie oi?aae?iiy, ye nenoaie aieeao
ia ?acoeueoaoe ainiiaea?nueei? ae?yeueiino? i?aei?e?inoa niiaeea/i?
eiiia?aoe??;

a oiiaao ia?ao?aeii? aeiiii?ee aeiaaaeaii ia’?eoeaio iaiao?aei?noue
nenoaiiiai i?aeoiaeo, a?aoiaoth/e iaoiaee i?iaaaeaiiy ?aa?c?e ?
ia?aa??ie, /enaeuei?noue eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a a oiiaao
a?eueoi? naiino?eiino? i?aei?e?inoa;

aecia/aii no/ani? oaiaeaioe?? o aeei?enoaii? ?iai/iai /ano
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a o caeaaeiino? a?ae neeaaeiino?
i?iaaaeaiiy ?iaioe;

?ic?iaeaii iaoiaee/i? i?aeoiaee aei aecia/aiiy iioeiaeueiiai neeaaeo
i?aoe?aiee?a, ye? a?aoiaothoue ianya ? o?eaae?noue ?iaioe, no?oeoo?
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo a?aeae?e?a;

cai?iiiiiaaii iiao iaoiaeeeo eiiieaenii? ioe?iee ?acoeueoao?a i?aoe?
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a ia iniia? canoinoaaiiy eiao?oe??io?a
? aecia/aiiy ?o aianeo o e?ioeaa? ?acoeueoaoe ?iaioe niiaeea/i?
eiiia?aoe??;

aaeineiiaeaii iaoiaee/i? i?eeiie ? iaoiaee ?aoe?iiaeueii? i?aai?caoe??
aioo??oiueinenoaiiiai eiio?ieth ia iniia? iii?oi?eiao, yeee a?aoiao?
nenoaiiee i?aeo?ae aei aiae?co eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eii? ?iaioe,
a?aenoaaeaiiy a?aeoeeaiue ? aianaiiy i?iiiceoe?e c a?aeiia?aeiiai
ei?aeooaaiiy o?iainiai? ae?yeueiino?.

Oai?aoe/ia cia/aiiy io?eiaieo ?acoeueoao?a. Oai?aoe/ia oe?ii?noue
?acoeueoao?a aeine?aeaeaiiy iieyaa? a iaoeiaiio iaa?oiooaaii? ?icaeoeo
eiio?ieth ye ooieoe?? ? neeaaeiai? /anoeie oi?aae?iiy, ye nenoaie aieeao
ia ?acoeueoaoe ainiiaea?nueei? ae?yeueiino? i?aei?e?inoa. Aei /enea
?acoeueoao?a, ye? iathoue oai?aoe/ia cia/aiiy, iiaeia a?aeianoe nenoaio
iii?oi?eiao o?iainiai? ae?yeueiino?, iia? i?aeoiaee a?aenoaaeaiiy ?
ei?aaoaaiiy ?acoeueoao?a eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eii? ?iaioe a nenoai?
niiaeea/i? eiiia?aoe??.

I?aeoe/ia cia/ei?noue io?eiaieo ?acoeueoao?a. I?aeoe/ia cia/ei?noue
io?eiaieo ?acoeueoao?a iieyaa? o iiaeeeaino? ai?iaaaeaeaiiy ?ic?iaeaieo
aaoi?ii i?iiiceoe?e ii cae?eniaiith aioo??oiueia?aeii/iai eiio?ieth ca
caa?aaeaiiyi eiiia?aoeaii? aeaniino?, ni?yiiaaieo ia aaeineiiaeaiiy
iaoiae?a ? i?eeii?a eiio?ieth ? a oe?eiio ca?eueoaiiy aoaeoeaiino?
eiio?ieth.

Ai?iaaoe?y ?acoeueoao?a aeena?oaoe??. Iniiai? ?acoeueoaoe
aeena?oaoe?eii? ?iaioe iaaiai?thaaeeny ? aoei noaaeaii ia
?anioae?eainueeeo iaoeiaeo eiioa?aioe?yo o 1996-1998 ?ieao o
Caii??cueeiio aea?aeaaiiio oi?aa?neoao? ? Caii??cuee?e aea?aeaai?e
?iaeaia?i?e aeaaeai?? I?i?noa?noaa ina?oe Oe?a?ie.

Iniiai? iaoiaee/i? ?aeiiaiaeaoe?? ii aaeineiiaeaiith neeaaeo ? no?oeoo?e
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo neoaea ai?iaaaeaeaii o Caii??cueeiio ?
Aoeye-I?euenueeiio ?aeiiieo niiaeea/eo oiaa?enoaao. E??i oiai, aeniiaee
? i?iiiceoe?? aeena?oaoe?eii? ?iaioe iiaeooue aooe oni?oii aeei?enoaii o
?iaio? i?aei?e?inoa ?ioeo aaeocae, i?i ui na?ae/eoue ai?iaaaeaeaiiy ?o
ia NI «AaoiCAC-AeAO».

Ioae?eaoe??. Ca ?acoeueoaoaie aeeiiaieo aeine?aeaeaiue o a?aee?eo?e
i?an? iioae?eiaaii 9 ?ia?o, eio?? a?aeia?aaeathoue iniiaiee ci?no
aeena?oaoe??, caaaeueiei ianyaii 4,45 ae?oeiaaieo a?eoo?a, c yeeo aaoi?o
iaeaaeeoue 4,29 ae?oeiaaieo a?eoo?.

No?oeoo?a ? ianya ?iaioe. Aeena?oaoe?y neeaaea?oueny ?c anooio, o?ueio
?icae?e?a, aeniiae?a, nieneo aeei?enoaieo aeaea?ae, yeee iae?/o? 217
iaca, 19 ?enoie?a, 12 oaaeeoeue ? 7 aeiaeaoe?a. Ianya ?iaioe 176
noi??iie iaoeiiieniiai oaenoo.

INIIAIEE CI?NO AeENA?OAOe??

?icae?e 1. Noai i?aai?caoe?? eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eii? ?iaioe a niiaeea/?e
eiiia?aoe??.

Eiio?ieue — ?noi?e/ia eaoaai??y, ei?ai? eiai aeieeiaiiy nyaathoue /ano,
eiee aia?oa c’yaeany ?iciiae?e ?ioa?an?a i?ae oeie, ooi aaciina?aaeiuei
caeia?oueny oi?aae?iiyi i?aei?e?inoaaie, ? oeie, ooi aeeaaea? a?io? o
eiai ae?yeuei?noue.

O ia??iae ia?aoiaeo aei ?eieiaeo a?aeiinei aeiiii?/iee eiio?ieue, o ye?e
ae oi?i? a?i ia ?nioaaa, aenooia? aoaeoeaiei ?ino?oiaioii ao?eaiiy o
aeeooy aeiiii?/ieo ? nioe?aeueieo ia?aoai?aiue o e?a?i?. Aaaeeeaith
oiiaith ?aoe?iiaeueii? i?aai?caoe?? ? ooieoe?iioaaiiy nenoaie
eiiieaeniiai eiio?ieth o noni?euenoa? c ?eieiaith aeiiii?eith ?
canoinoaaiiy no/anieo oaoiieia?e eiio?ieth, ye? aeicaieythoue nei?ioeoe
/an eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eii? ?iaioe ia ia’?eo?: iai?eeeaae, ca ?aooiie
canoinoaaiiy aeiiii?ei-iaoaiaoe/ieo iaoiae?a eiio?ieth o ii?aeiaii? c
AII ? no/aniei eiio?ieueii-aei??thaaeueiei iniauaiiyi, aeiiii?/iee
eiio?ieue c aeiiiiiaith nenoaie aeiiii?/ieo noeioe?a ni?ey? i?aeaeuaiith
aoaeoeaiino? ae?iaie/i? ? o?iainiai-ainiiaea?nueei? ae?yeueiino?
i?aei?e?inoa c ??cieie oi?iaie aeaniino?. I?e oeueiio ceeaathoueny
?ioa?ane aea?aeaaiiai eiio?ieth (a inia? iiaeaoeiaeo aaei?i?no?aoe?e,
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo oi?aae?iue) ? aioo??oiueiai eiio?ieth aeanieea,
caoe?eaaeaieo o aeeiiaii? aea?aeaaieo caiiaeaiue, eiio?aeo?a, caaaeaiue
c iaoith ca?eueoaiiy aeiiii?/ii? aoaeoeaiino? ainiiaea?nueei?
ae?yeueiino?. Eiio?ieue ca aeeiiaiiyi oeeo caaaeaiue aea? iiaeeea?noue
anoaiiaeoe ?o iaoeiao iaa?oioiaai?noue, i?ia?aneai?noue, caaacia/aiiy
?ano?naie, oiaoi ye?noue oi?aae?inueeeo ??oaiue, ye? i?eeiathoueny
ea??aieeaie.

Cai?iiiiiaaii oiiae iiaoaeiae nenoaie iii?oi?eiao o?iainiai?
ae?yeueiino? i?aei?e?inoa aai ae a oe?eiio aaeoc?. Iii?oi?eia iioi/ii?
o?iainiai? ae?yeueiino? – oea iaoai?ci cae?eniaiiy niinoa?aaeaiue ca
iaeaaaeeea?oeie iioi/ieie ?acoeueoaoaie o?iainiai? ae?yeueiino?
i?aei?e?inoa (aaeoc?) a oiiaao iino?eii ci?iii? eii’thieoo?e o?iainiaiai
?eieo. Iii?oi?eia o?iainiaiai ?eieo — oea iaoai?ci cae?eniaiiy
o?iainiaeie iaiaaeaea?aie ae?yeueiino? i?aei?e?inoaa (aaeoc?) a oiiaao
ianoaa?eueiiai o?iainiaiai ?eieo. Nenoaia iii?oi?eiao o?iainiai?
ae?yeueiino? ia eiaeiiio ??ai? yaey? niaith iaoai?ci cae?eniaiiy
eiie?aoiiai niinoa?aaeaiiy ca iaeaaaeeea?oeie iioi/ieie ?acoeueoaoaie
oe??? ae?yeueiino? ia iniia? i?eioeei?a ? iieaciee?a cai?iiiiiaaieo
aaoi?ii (?en.1). Oea iiaeeeai ca oiia ?aoe?iiaeueiiai ii?aeiaiiy
aioo??oiuei-a?aeii/iai eiio?ieth c aieo a?aeiinoaa c aioo??oi?i
eiio?ieai c aieo ainiiaea?thth/iai noa’?eoa. Iniiaiith iaoith ?ic?iaee
nenoaie iii?oi?eia?a o?iainiai? ae?yeueiino? i?aei?e?inoaa, eiiieaeno
i?aei?e?inoa ? aaeoc? a oe?eiio, ? nai?/ania aeyaeaiiy a?aeoeeaiue
oaeoe/ieo ?acoeueoao?a oe??? ae?yeueiino? a?ae ia?aaeaa/aieo, ye?
aeeeeeathoue cieaeaiiy ?? aoaeoeaiino?, aeyaeaiiy i?e/ei, ye?
aeeeeeathoue oea a?aeoeeaiiy, ? ?ic?iaea i?iiiceoe?e c a?aeiia?aeiiai
ei?aeooaaiiy ie?aieo iai?yie?a o?iainiai? ae?yeueiino? c iaoith ??
ii?iae?caoe?? ? i?aeaeuaiiy aoaeoeaiino?.

A iniiao aoaeiae nenoaie iii?oi?eiao o?iainiai? ae?yeueiino?
i?aei?e?inoaa aai oe?ei? aaeoc? iiaeooue aooe iieeaaeai? oae? i?eioeeie:

i?eioeei aeai?o aeey niinoa?aaeaiiy ? eiio?ieth iaea?eueo aaaeeeaeo
iai?yie?a ? oe?eueiaeo iieaciee?a o?iainiai? ae?yeueiino?;

i?eioeei iiaoaeiae nenoaie ?ioi?iaoeaieo (ia?aeiieo) ca?oieo iieaciee?a
c eiaeiiai ?c iai?yie?a o?iainiai? ae?yeueiino? i?aei?e?inoaa /e aaeoc?
a oe?eiio;

Cai?iiiiiaaii iaoiaee iaoaiaoe/iiai iiaeaethaaiiy oi?a?aaeueieo ?
ae?iaie/eo i?ioean?a o niiaeea/?e eiiia?aoe??. Aeaii ioe?ieo aeiiii?/ieo
iaoiae?a eiio?ieth c a?aeia?aaeaiiyi ia?aaaa ? iaaeie?e?a oeeo iaoiae?a.

Iaaaaeai? ?acoeueoaoe aiae?co ? ioe?iee iiaeeeaeo iaoiae?a i?iaeooaaiiy
i?aai?caoe?e i?aoe? o eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?ei?e ?iaio?,
ae?iaie/i-o?iainia?e ae?yeueiino? i?aei?e?inoaa aoee aeei?enoai? i?e
aeai?? oiai /e ?ioiai iaoiaeo oi?aae?iiy eiie?aoieie /eiieeaie (a oiio
ae /ene? aeoeaaie ? ianeaaie), ui i?aaenoaaeai? o aeena?oaoe?ei?e ?iaio?
o no?oeoo?ii-eia?/i?e noai? no/aniiai i?aei?e?inoaa (ia’?aeiaiiy). I?e
aeai?? i?eeeaaeo canoinoaaiiy eiie?aoiiai iaoiaeo oi?aae?iiy eiie?aoieie
oaeoi?aie a?aoiaoaaeenue iiceoeai? iiiaioe, ia?o ca ana, iayai?noue
aenieeo ?acoeueoao?a ai?iaaoe?? iaoiaeo ? caaacia/aiiy aeinoaoiuei?
a??ia?aeiino? ?ic?iaeaieo oi?aae?inueeeo ??oaiue.

I?e ?ic?iaoe? i?iaeo?a oaeineiiaeaiiy i?aai?caoe?? i?aoe?
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo ?ia?o an? oi?ie, ye? aeeeaaeai? aeua, a?eueoith
/e iaioith i??ith iiaeii? aooe caae?yi?. Aei oiai ae ii?ioaaiiy
oi?aae?inueei? i?aoe?, a oiio /ene? e i?aoe? eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eiiai
aia?aoo, iiaeiii a?aeiia?aeaoe ?yaeo i?eioeei?a ? aeiia, ye?
aeicaieythoue io?eiaoe iaea?eueo iiai? ? aeinoia??i? ?acoeueoaoe. Ia
?en.2 cai?iiiiiaaii eiioeaiooaeueio iiaeaeue ii?ioaaiiy i?aoe?
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a.

Aeeeaaeai? i?aeoiaee aei aecia/aiiy ii?iaoeaii? o?oaeii?noeino? ie?aieo
aeae?a eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo ?ia?o i?aaii??i? ye i?e ciai?oiueiio, oa ?
i?e aioo??oiueiio eiio?ie?. I?ioa aacoth/enue ia aeeeaaeaieo
iieiaeaiiyo, iaiao?aeii oaeiae a?aoiaoaaoe aeaye? a?aei?ii? iniaeeaino?,
ye? ? o a?aecia/aieo aeaeao eiio?ieth.

?icae?e 2. Iaoiaee/i? iieiaeaiiy ii ?ic?iaoe? i?aai?caoe?? i?aoe?
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a.

Uia anoaiiaeoe aaciniaia?noue o aeeiiaii? eiio?ieueieo ooieoe?e,
?aa?ci?ai i?ae /an i?iaaaeaiiy eiiieaenii? ?aa?c??, iaiao?aeii neeaaeaoe
aeey ieo ?iai/? i?ia?aie. Aeaea?aeii neeaaeaiiy oeeo ?iai/eo i?ia?ai
iiaeii? aooe eeaneo?eaoe?? ?ia?o ?aa?ci??a ca ??aiai neeaaeiino?, ui
aeicaieeoue a?eueo ??aiii??ii ?iciiae?eyoe iaia’ycee i?ae ??cieie
aeeiiaaoeyie. Ci?no i?ia?ai iio??aii ocaiaeaeoaaoe c eaae?o?eaoe?eieie
aeiiaaie, ye? aenoaathoueny aei

aeeiiaaoey o??? /e ?ioi? ae?eyiee ?aa?c?eii? ?iaioe, a oaeiae oiiaaie
caioi/aiiy ca aeino?ieiaa ? ye?nia aeeiiaiiy iaaieo ?ia?o. C aeiiiiiaith
?iai/eo i?ia?ai caaacia/o?oueny noai?ee ?eoi ? iaae?ei?noue o ?iaio?
?aa?ci??a.

Aeey oiai, uia i?iaiae?coaaoe caeiyo?noue eiaeiiai ?aa?ci?a, aecia/eoe
iine?aeiai?noue eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo ae?e, aeyaeoe aeoaethaaiiy,
aeioe?eueii neeaaeaoe i?ia?aie aecia/aiiy caeiyoino? ?aa?ci??a o
i?ioean? aeieoiaioaeueii? ?aa?c??, yea i?aaenoaaeaia a oaae.1.

Oaaeeoey 1

I?ia?aia aecia/aiiy caeiyoino? ?aa?ci??a

?aaiaiei Ae.I. Iao?aiei A.E. Naa/aiei A.N.

Ieai Oaeo Ieai Oaeo Ieai Oaeo

Nai?/ania ii?eaooeoaaiiy ae?o/ee ? iaaeoiaeaeaiue a?ioae a eano,
ia?aa??ea eaniaeo iia?aoe?e Nooe?eueia ca 12 i?nyoe?a

Ooe?iea ? aeiioe?iea oiaa?ii-iaoa??aeueieo oe?iiinoae

Nooe?eueia ca 12 i?nyoe?a

Iacaieaiiaai? ao?aoe ? ao?aoe oiaa??a a?ae inoaaiiy ? iaaeeeoeiaeo
caeoe?a

Nooe?eueia ca 12 i?nyoe?a

Ia?aa??ea oo?ao?a, iai?, iaonoieie

Nooe?eueia ca 12 i?nyoe?a

Ia?aa??ea iaa?oiooaaiiy io?eiaiiy iiceee Nooe?eueia ca 12 i?nyoe?a

Ia?aa??ea oiaa?ieo iia?aoe?e ? o.ae.

Aea??eiaa ca 12 i?nyoe?a

Neeaaeaiiy ? aiae?c oaeeo i?ia?ai aea? iiaeeea?noue i?aaeeueii oa /?oei
aecia/eoe iaia’ycee i?ae aeeiiaaoeyie o i?ioean? eiiieaenii? ?aa?c??,
noai?ththoue oiiae aeey ?icaeoeo iiaeeaeaii? niaoe?ae?caoe?? ?aa?c?eii?
?iaioe ? i?aeaeuaiiy yeino? i?aoe? ?aa?ci??a.

I?aai?caoe?y i?aoe? ?aa?ci??a ia?aaeaa/a? caaacia/aiiy aoaeoeaiino?
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eii? ae?yeueiino? ia iniia? ?aoe?iiaeueiiai
aeei?enoaiiy ia o?eueee ciaiue, ai?iue ? aeina?aeo ?aa?ci??a, aea e
?icoe?aiiy noa?e ii?ioaaiiy i?aoe?. Aeaoe iiaio ioe?ieo noaio ii?ioaaiiy
i?aoe?, aecia/eoe oeyoe iiaeaeueoiai eiai iie?auaiiy, a oaeiae aea/eoe
iaoiaee eiio?ieth ca noaiii ii?ioaaiiy i?aoe?, iiaeeeai o?eueee ia
iniia? aeeaieiai aiae?co ??aiy i?aai?caoe?? ii?ioaaiiy i?aoe?.

Iaa?oioiaaii iaoiaeeeo ?ic?aooieo iioeiaeueiiai neeaaeo e?eueeino?
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a. A oiiaao noaiiaeaiiy ?eieiaeo
a?aeiinei iaiao?aeia eii?aeeiaoe?y ae?e oi?aae?inueeeo no?oeoo?. ? an?
i?aenoaae aaaaeaoe, ui eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?ei? neoaeae, aca?iiae?th/e c
?ioeie i?aaiaie, ni?eythoue ?aae?caoe?? ??oaiue i?aai?a aeaaee, ye?
ni?yiiaai? ia i?aai?caoe?th ? noaiiaeaiiy ?eieiaeo a?aeiinei. I?aeoeea
inoaii?o ?ie?a ainiiaea?thaaiiy iieaco? iianthaeia nei?i/aiiy
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a ? ?aa?ci??a o nenoai? niiaeea/i?
eiiia?aoe?? cie?aia.

Aea/aiiy aeina?aeo ?iaioe aea?aeaaiiai o?iainiaiai eiio?ieth ca
ei?aeiiii iieaco? iiieeeia?noue oyaeaiue aeayeeo a?o/eciyieo a/aieo-
aeiiii?no?a, ye? aaci?aenoaaii aaaaeathoue, ui a oiiaao ?eieo iaiao?aeii
??cei nei?ioeoe e?euee?noue eiio?ieueii ?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a aei
i?i?ioio, ia aa?o/e i?e oeueiio aei oaaae iaoeiai iaa?oioiaai? ii?iaoeae
e?eueeino?.

O?aaa cacia/eoe, ui ii?iaoeai? iaoa??aee ? iaoiaee/i? aeac?aee ii
?ic?iaoe? ii?i i?aoe? eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a acaaae? ?
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a niiaeea/i? eiiia?aoe?? cie?aia
aeiaaathoue iiaeaeueoiai aaeineiiaeaiiy, ine?eueee oeei ieoaiiyi o iao?e
e?a?i? ia a?aeaaaeaii iio??aii? oaaae.

Iniaeea?noth i?aoe? eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a ? aaeeea
ia??aiii??i?noue o caaaioaaeaii?, iayai?noue aaeeei? e?eueeino? ?ia?o,
yeeo ia iiaeia ia?aaeaa/eoe cacaeaeaa?aeue, a?aeaeaeai?noue a?ae
ia’?eo?a, eio?? ia?aa??ythoueny oa ?ioa, ? oea coiiaeth? iaiao?aei?noue
aeei?enoaiiy o ii?ioaaii? i?aoe? i?aoe?aiee?a iaoeiai iaa?oioiaaieo
/eiiee?a. Ii?iaoeae anoaiiaeththoueny ? ae?aoiaothoueny o
a?aeiia?aeiino? c aea?aieie /eiieeaie, ye? iaea?eueoa aieeaathoue ia
e?euee?noue i?aoe?aiee?a. Oae, cie?aia, ?ic?aooiie e?eueeino? ?aa?ci??a
aiae?oe/iei niiniaii iiaeia iiaeaoe, aeei?enoiaoth/e oi?ioeo oaeiai
aeaeo:

(1)

aea Ne – iaiao?aeia e?euee?noue ?aa?ci??a o ooao?
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eiiai oi?aae?iiy;

A – e?euee?noue aaeain?a;

A – oaeoe/iee na?aaei?e /an, yeee aeo?a/a?oueny ia i?iaaaeaiiy
iaei??? ?aa?c??;

? – ?ioa?aae i?iaaaeaiiy ?aa?c?e;

A – e?euee?noue ?aeiiieo niiaeea ni?eie;

O – /anoea /ano o ??/iiio ei?eniiio oiiae? ?iai/iai /ano
?aa?ci?a, ui aeo?a/a?oueny ia ?io? ia?aa??ee;

Ae – ??/iee ei?eniee oiiae ?iai/iai /ano ?aa?ci?a, aei?a.

Aeeeaaeaii iniiai? i?e/eie iineaaeaiiy o?iainiaiai eiio?ieth o
ia?ao?aeiee aei ?eieo ia??iae. Oae, cie?aia, iaei??th ?c i?e/ei
iaaeinoaoiuei? aoaeoeaiino? aioo??oiueiainiiaea?nueeiai eiio?ieth ia
aeayeeo i?aei?e?inoaao ? a?aenooi?noue iaeaaeii? a?aeiia?aeaeueiino?
ea??aiee?a ??cieo a?aeae?e?a ca aeeiiaiiyi ieie eiio?ieueieo ooieoe?e.
Iaiao?aeii i?aeaeueoe ae??a?noue aioo??oiueiai ainiiaea?nueeiai
eiio?ieth. Aeey ae??oaiiy oeueiai caaaeaiiy iaiao?aeii ia?o ca ana
noai?eoe i?aai?caoe?eio nenoaio eiio?ieth, yea a a?aeia?aaeaea
caaaeueiee, aacia?a?aiee o /an? ? nenoaiaoe/iee oa?aeoa?
aioo??oiuei-a?aeii/iai eiio?ieth. Noai?aiiy i?aai?caoe?eii? nenoaie
aioo??oiueiainiiaea?nueeiai eiio?ieth iiaea cae?enithaaoeny oeyoaie:
eii?aeeiaoe?? ? ocaiaeaeaiiy eiio?ieueieo ooieoe?e ??cieo a?aeae?e?a,
ae?iaeaiiy niaoe?aeueieo iaoiaeee cae?eniaiiy
aioo??oiueiainiiaea?nueeiai eiio?ieth.

A oiiaao ?eieo c?inoa? iio?aaa o aaeineiiaeaii? aioo??oiueiai
ainiiaea?nueeiai eiio?ieth ca caa?aaeaiiyi eiiia?aoeaii? aeaniino? ?
ci?oeiaiiyi ainiiaea?nueei-o?iainiai? aeenoeeie?ie, c?inoa? ?ieue
i?aoe?aiee?a eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo neoaea. E??i oiai, i?enei?aiiy
oaii?a iaoeiai oaoi?/iiai i?ia?ano aeiaaa? i?aai?caoe?? a?eueo
aeineiiaeeo oi?i ainiiaea?nueeiai ea??aieoeoaa ? eiio?ieth.

Aaaeeeaith oiiaith aaeineiiaeaiiy aioo??oiuei-ainiiaea?nueeiai eiio?ieth
? i?aeaeuaiiy eiai iia?aoeaiino?. Iia?aoeai?noue eiio?ieth i?iyaey?oueny
ia?o ca ana o oiio, ui a?i cae?enith?oueny o i?ioean? ioi?ieaiiy ?
?a?no?aoe?? ainiiaea?nueeeo iia?aoe?e a iae?eo, ui aea? iiaeeea?noue
nenoaiaoe/ii ?ice?eaaoe nooi?noue iia?aoe?e, iia’ycaieo c ?ooii oiaa?ii-
iaoa??aeueieo oe?iiinoae. Ia??iaee/i?noue eiio?ieth iia?aoe?e o i?ioean?
iaaeoiaeaeaiiy ? ?aae?caoe?? iaoa??aeueieo oe?iiinoae iieacaii o oaae.2.

?c oaae.2 aa/eii, ui eiio?ieue ca iaaeoiaeaeaiiyi oiaa?ii-iaoa??aeueieo
oe?iiinoae, a oaeiae ?o ?aae?caoe?? cae?enith?oueny o a?eueoino?
aeiaaee?a i?ae /an oi?ioaaiiy iieaciee?a ?ioi?iaoe?? ? aeeiiaiiy
iia?aoe?e. Oea na?ae/eoue i?i oa, ui o i?aeoeoe? ia?aaaaea? aacia?a?aiee
eiio?ieue ainiiaea?nueeeo iieaciee?a. Ai?ciaee/ii eiio?ieththoue eeoa o?
iieacieee, eio?? oi?iothoueny

Oaaeeoey 2

Ia??iaee/i?noue oi?ioaaiiy iieaciee?a ? eiio?ieth iioi/ii? ?ioi?iaoe?? o
i?ioean? iaaeoiaeaeaiiy ? ?aae?caoe?? iaoa??aeueieo oe?iiinoae

?ioi?iaoe?y i?i i?ioean aai iieaciee Oi?ioaaiiy iieaciee?a Eiio?ieue
iieaciee?a

Nenoaiaoe/ia

Ca ca?oi?e ia??iae Aacia?a?aia Ai?ciaee/ia Aacia?a?aiee Ai?ciaee/iee

Cao?eiea iaaeoiaeaeaiue oiaa?ii-iaoa??aeueieo oe?iiinoae

+

+

Caeeoee oiaa?ii-iaoa??aeueieo oe?iiinoae ia iioiaeo aacao

+

+

+

?icii?yaeaeaiiy ia a?aeione oiaa?o c aac o ?icae??ai? i?aei?e?inoaa

+

+

+

A?aeione oiaa??a c iioiaeo aac ia ae??ai? i?aei?e?inoaa

+

+

+

?aae?caoe?y oiaa?ii-iaoa??aeueieo oe?iiinoae niiaeeaa/ai

+

+

Caea/a ae?o/ee ca ?aae?ciaai? oiaa?ii-iaoa??aeuei? oe?iiino?

+

+

Caeeoee oiaa??a ia i?aei?e?inoaao aeaiiai niiaeea/iai oiaa?enoaa

+

+

ia nenoaiaoe/ii, a naia cao?eiee iaaeoiaeaeaiue oiaa?ii-iaoa??aeueieo
oe?iiinoae a?ae iinoa/aeueiee?a ? aeaye? ?io?. ?oo oiaa??a ? ?o
?aae?caoe?y eiio?ieththoueny, ye i?aaeei, aacia?a?aii.

O aeena?oaoe?ei?e ?iaio? a?aecia/aii, ui onoiaiiy iaaeie?e?a
aioo??oiueia?aeii/iai o?iainiaiai eiio?ieth ni?eyoeia aeeiiaiith
caaaeaiue, ye? noiyoue ia?aae iei, ? ia?o ca ana c?inoa ye?noue ?aa?c?e
? ia?aa??ie.

?icae?e 3. Aaeineiiaeaiiy i?aai?caoe?? oi?aae?iiy ?aa?c??th ? eiio?ieai
a nenoai? niiaeea/i? eiiia?aoe??.

?ic?iaeaii i?iiiceoe?? uiaei eiiieaeniiai noeioethaaiiy
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a, eio?? iiaeii? i???iooaaoeny ia
e?ioeaa? ?acoeueoaoe ?iaioe, a naia ca e?euee?noue i?iaaaeaieo ia?aa??ie
o aeaiiio ia??iae?, noio aeyaeaieo ianoa/, ?ico?ao ? e?aae?aeie, noio
iiaeaieo ia?aooaaiue iinaaeiaei ? iaoa??aeueii-a?aeiia?aeaeueiei iniaai
? o.ae. ? a caeaaeiino? a?ae aeyaeaieo ii?ooaiue iaiao?aeii
aeei?enoiaoaaoe ??ciiiai?oi? i?aeoiaee aei noeioethaaiiy ?aa?ci??a. ?yae
i?aei?e?inoa niiaeea/i? eiiia?aoe?? i?aeoeeothoue caioi/aiiy
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a ?c oiiaeo iaoa??aeueiiai caioi/aiiy,
ui ooai?th?oueny ca ?aooiie i?eaooe?a. Iniiaia ca?ia?oia ieaoiy
aeiea/o?oueny i?e oeueiio iii?ny/ii, anoaiiaeth?oueny ia i?aenoaa?
a?aeiia?aeieo ieeaae?a ? ia iia’ycaia c ?acoeueoaoaie i?aoe? eiie?aoiiai
i?aoe?aieea. Ca oe??th nenoaiith ?aa?ci?e neaai caoe?eaaeai? o e?ioeaaeo
?acoeueoaoao nai?? i?aoe?. O?oaeiaee aianie eiaeiiai i?aoe?aieea iiaeia
aecia/eoe e?euee?noth, ye?noth ? neeaaei?noth aeeiiaieo iei neoaeaiaeo
ooieoe?e ? o.ae. Aeey oeueiai aeioe?eueii aaanoe nenoaio aecia/aiiy
eiao?oe??ioa o?oaeiai? o/ano? (EOO) aeey eiaeiiai i?aoe?aieea a?aeae?eo
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eii? neoaeae. EOO ea??aiee?a ? niaoe?ae?no?a
aeioe?eueii aecia/aoe ca oi?ioeith (a?ae. iae):

n

EOOj=Ej(aji, (2)

i=1

Kij – eaae?o?eaoe?eiee eiao?oe??io j-ai i?aoe?aieea;

I=1,2…n – aaeoi? ?iaeaen?a eiao?oe??io?a ye?nieo oa?aeoa?enoee i?aoe?;

Kj2 – eiao?oe??io iiaiioe aeeiiaiiy iaia’yce?a, aianeo o aeeiiaiiy
ae?iaie/iai caaaeaiiy +;

Kj9 – eiao?oe??io o?oaeiai? aeoeaiino?, aeenoeeie?ie+;

Kj4 – eiao?oe??io aeio?eiaiiy oaoi?ee aaciaee, i?ioeiiaeaaeieo aeiia,
/enoioe ? iniauaiiy ?iai/iai i?noey;

Kj5 – eiao?oe??io i?yiioe ? yeino? aeeiiaiiy ?icii?yaeaeaiue aeuiai
ia/aeueieea;

Kj6 — eiao?oe??io iae?eo aeoiaeiaei?a+.

Iiooeo e?au?o ??oaiue o oe?e aaeoc? iiaea ni?eyoe aea/aiiy ca?oa?aeiiai
aeina?aeo, yeee, cae/aeii, ia iiaea eii?thaaoe o iaoeo oiiaao iaoai?/ii.
O ca?oa?aei?e i?aeoeoe? i?ae /an oi?ioaaiiy nenoaie iieaoe i?aoe?
ia?niiaeo oaeiae iiaeia a?aecia/eoe ??ciiiai?oi?noue i?aeoiae?a.

Aaeineiiaeaiiy nenoaie i?aai?caoe?? aioo??oiueia?aeii/iai eiio?ieth — o
ii?aeiaii? c aioo??oi?ie ia?aa??eaie. Ie?ai? aaoi?e ?ia?o c ?aa?c??
aaaaeathoue, ui ?? ci?noii ? o?eueee ia?aa??ea oiai, iane?eueee
iia?aoe?? i?aaeeueii ioi?ieai? aeieoiaioaeueii ? /e i?aaeeueii aiie
a?aeia?aaeaeenue ia ?aooieo aooaaeoa?nueeiai iae?eo. Ia aeoieo oeeo
aaoi??a, aeieoiaioe, ui ia?aa??ythoueny, iiaeooue aena?oeeoe onth
aaaaoiiai?oi?noue ainiiaea?nueei? ? o?iainiai? ae?yeueiino?
i?aei?e?inoaa. O oie aea /an i?aeoeeith i?aeoaa?aeaeo?oueny, ui
aeei?enoaiiy i?ae /an ?aa?c?e o?eueee aeieoiaio?a ?noioii cieaeo? ??
ye?noue ? ae??a?noue o ca’yceo c oei, ui ciai?oi?e a?e aeieoiaioa ?
ye?noue eiai ioi?ieaiiy i?aeoaa?aeaeothoue o?eueee aeae ainiiaea?nueei?
iia?aoe??, a ?? caeiii?noue iaiao?aeii ia?aa??yoe. ?aa?c?y eeoa ca
aeieoiaioaie ia caaacia/o? oi?aa?naeuei?noue eiio?ieth.

Niiniae ? i?eeiie eiio?ieth ia iiaeooue ?icaeyaeaoeny ye uinue iino?eia
? iaci?iia. O ca’yceo c iniaeeainoyie iioi/iiai ia??iaeo a aeeoo?
e?a?ie, ?icaeoeo oaoi?/iiai i?ia?ano, ci?i i?aai?caoe?eieo oi?i
ainiiaea?thaaiiy, aeieea? iaiao?aei?noue ?icoe?aiiy ? aaeineiiaeaiiy
niinia?a ? i?eeii?a eiio?ieth ca caa?aaeaiiyi eiiia?aoeaii? aeaniino?.
Nueiaiaei? eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?ei?e neoaea? aeiaiaeeoueny ?iaeoe aaaaoi
oiai, /iai ?ai?oa ?iaeoe ia aeiaiaeeeinue, ine?eueee nueiaiaei?
caoaa?aeaeaia Iieiaeaiiy i?i ii?yaeie ?a?no?aoe?? ? canoinoaaiiy
aeaeo?iiieo eiio?ieueii-eaniaeo aia?ao?a aeey ?ic?aooieo aio?aeith o
noa?? oi?a?ae?, a?iiaaenueeiai oa?/oaaiiy ? iineoa, aeoiaey/e c iueiai
an?i oiaa?ai, ye? iaaeoiaeyoue o i?iaeaae, i?enaith?oueny eiae, oiae? ca
i?aenoieaie eaniai? eieae ? iiaeeea?noue anoaiiaeoe e?euee?noue
?aae?ciaaiiai oiaa?o, ui oe?eaaeoue. Ia?aa??yth/e oiaa?ii-a?ioia? ca?oe,
? ei?enooth/enue oi?ioeith oi?aiaiai aaeaino (caeeoie ia ii/aoie iethn
iaaeoiaeaeaiiy i?ion ?aae?caoe?y aei??aith? e?ioeaaiio caeeoeo), iiaeia
c?iaeoe aeniiaee i?i oaeoe/io iayai?noue oiaa?o, ui ia?aa??y?oueny. Aac
noii?ao, ?iaioa ii anoaiiaeaiith oaeoe/ii i?iaeaiiai oiaa?o ca
aeiiiiiaith eaniaiai iae?eo aeoaea o?oaeii?noea ? aeiaaa? aaeeeeo aeo?ao
/ano, aea o ?ac? aeieeiaiiy iaiao?aeiino?, aea? aoaeoeaiee ?acoeueoao.

A oiiaao noaiiaeaiiy ?eieiaeo noinoie?a, eiee
iaoa??aeueii-a?aeiia?aeaeuei? iniae /e a?aeiia?aeaeuei? i?aoe?aieee
niiaeea/eo oiaa?enoa nai? anoaiiaeththoue i?iaeaaei? oe?ie, iaiao?aeii
iineeeoe eiio?ieue ca ii?eaooeoaaiiyi oi?aiai? iaaeaaaee. Aeey
oieeiaiiy oaeo?a e?aae?aeie ca ?aooiie iaii?eaooeiaaieo noi
oi?aiai? iaaeaaaee, iaiao?aeii cae?enithaaoe nooe?eueio ?o ia?aa??eo.
Oeth ae?eyieo eiio?ieth iaiao?aeii i?aeaeaoe nooe?euei?e a?eoiaoe/i?e,
aiae?oe/iee ? eia?/iee ia?aa??oe?. Iaiao?aeii ia?aa??eoe ia o?eueee noio
oi?aiaeo iaaeaaaie, yea aeacaia o iaeeaaei?e c a?eoiaoe/iiai aieo, aea ?
a?aeiia?aei?noue ?? caienai o ca?o? ye ca ie?aiei aeieoiaioii, oae ? o
caaaeueiiio i?aenoieo ca. ei?aniiiaeoth/ei ?aooieii, ? iio?i o
aeo?iae?-i?aea?? ? o aieiai?e eiec?. O i?aeoeoe? ?aa?c?eii? ?iaioe
a?aeii? aeiaaeee i?eoiaoaaiiy ceiaaeeaaiue ca ?aooiie oi?aiaeo iaaeaaaie
ia an?o noaae?yo iae?eo.

Caaacia/aiiy caa?aaeaiino? oiaa?ii-iaoa??aeueieo oe?iiinoae iiaea aooe
aeinyaiaia ia o?eueee i?e nooe?euei?e ?a?no?aoe?? oaeoe/ii? iayaiino? ?
?ooo oe?iiinoae, aea e o ?acoeueoao? aeoeaii? o/ano? niaoe?ae?no?a o
?ic?iaoe? caoiae?a, ye? caaacia/othoue ?o ?aoe?iiaeueia aeei?enoaiiy.

Cai?iiiiiaaii iaoiaee/i? i?eeiie aeieoiaioaeueiiai eiio?ieth.
O?iainiai-ainiiaea?nueeiio eiio?ieth, ye iniaeea?e aaeoc? iaoeiaeo
ciaiue, aeanoeaee iaaiee iaoiae aea/aiiy eiai niaoeeo?/iiai i?aaeiaoo. O
niaoe?aeuei?e e?oa?aoo?? iaia? iiaii? yniino? i?i nenoaio iaoiaee/ieo
i?eeii?a, ui canoiniaothoueny o eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?ei?e ?iaio?, a oea,
aac noii?ao, iaaaoeaii aieeaa? ia i?aeoe/io ae?yeuei?noue i?aoe?aiee?a,
ui cae?eniththoue ainiiaea?/ee eiio?ieue.

Ia iniia? ocaaaeueiaiiy ?nioth/eo o e?oa?aoo?? aeaieo, a oaeiae
aeoiaey/e c i?aeoeee i?iaaaeaiiy ?aa?c?e, cai?iiiiiaaii
iaoiaee/i? i?eeiie aeieoiaioaeueiiai eiio?ieth. Ia ?en.3 iaaaaeaia
eeaneo?eaoe?y iaoiaee/ieo i?eeii?a aeieoiaioaeueiiai eiio?ieth.

AENIIAEE

Ca ?acoeueoaoaie aeeiiaii? ?iaioe iaa?oioiaaii ? noi?ioeueiaaii oae?
iniiai? aeniiaee ? ?aeiiaiaeaoe??:

1. ?ice?eoi nooi?noue eiio?ieth. Aeiaaaeaii, ui a oiiaao ?eieiai?
aeiiii?ee eiio?ieue ? iaeiei ?c ao?eaoo?a aea?aeaaiiai ?
noni?eueii-iie?oe/iiai aeeooy.

Iaoeiai iaa?oioiaaii iniiai? aoaie aioo??oiueia?aeii/iai o?iainiaiai
eiio?ieth. Cai?iiiiiaaii oiiae iiaoaeiae nenoaie iii?oi?eiao o?iainiai?
ae?yeueiino? i?aei?e?inoa aai a aaeoc? a oe?eiio. Aeaii noaio aea/aiiy
yaeu ca aeiiiiiaith aeiiii?ei-iaoaiaoe/iiai iiaeaethaaiiy.

2. Ia i?aenoaa? aiae?co ?nioth/eo i?aeoiae?a aei ii?ioaaiiy
?ic?iaeaii eiioeaiooaeueio iiaeaeue ii?ioaaiiy i?aoe?
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a.

Cai?iiiiiaaii noaio ?iciiae?eo iaoiae?a aeiiii?/ieo aeine?aeaeaiue.
Aeaii ioe?ieo aeiiii?/ieo iaoiae?a c a?aeaeooyi ia?aaaa ? iaaeie?e?a
oeeo iaoiae?a.

3. Cai?iiiiiaaii iaoiaeeeo ?ic?aooieo iioeiaeueiiai neeaaeo e?eueeino?
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a. Aeeeaaeaii noaio iine?aeiaiino?
?ic?iaee ii?iaoea?a e?eueeino? eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a.
Iaoeiai iaa?oioiaaii iniiai? iai?yiee ? ?aca?ae i?aai?caoe?? i?aoe?
?aa?ci?nueeiai aia?aoo. Aeaii ioe?ieo noaio ii?ioaaiiy i?aoe? o iao?e
e?a?i? acaaae? ? niiaeea/?e eiiia?aoe?? cie?aia. Ocaaaeueiaii iaoiaee/i?
aniaeoe ?ic?iaee iioeiaeueieo ii?iaoea?a /ano Cai?iiiiiaaii i?ia?aio
aecia/aiiy caeiyoino? ?aa?ci??a. ?ic?iaeaii ‘ eeaneo?eaoe?th ii?i cao?ao
i?aoe? ? iaoiae?a aea/aiiy cao?ao ?iai/iai /ano. Noi?ioeueiaaii
no?oeoo?o cao?ao ?iai/iai /ano eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a.
?ic?iaeaii noaio iine?aeiaiino? ?aa?c?eiiai i?ioeano aeey i?iaaaeaiiy
eiiieaenii? ?aa?c??. Aeoiaey/e ?c o?iiiiao?aaeieo niinoa?aaeaiue iaoeiai
iaa?oioiaaii athaeaeao ?iai/iai /ano ?aa?ci?a. ?ic?iaeaii eeaneo?eaoe?th
iaoiae?a ? niinia?a ii?ioaaiiy cao?ao i?aoe?.

4. ?ic?iaeaii eeaneo?eaoe?th i?aai?caoe?eii? no?oeoo?e o?iainiaiai
eiio?ieth a Oe?a?i?, a oaeiae no?oeoo?o aioo??oiueia?aeii/eo i?aai?a
eiio?ieth o niiaeea/?e eiiia?aoe??. Noi?ioeueiaaii ia??iaee/i?noue
oi?ioaaiiy iieaciee?a ? eiio?ieth iioi/ii? ?ioi?iaoe?? o i?ioean?
iaaeoiaeaeaiiy ? ?aae?caoe?? iaoa??aeueieo oe?iiinoae. Aeeeaaeaii aeaye?
i?e/eie iineaaeaiiy o?iainiaiai eiio?ieth o ia?ao?aeiee ia??iae aei
?eieo. Cacia/aii, ui onoiaiiy iaaeie?e?a aioo??oiueia?aeii/iai ?
o?iainiaiai eiio?ieth aoaea ni?eyoe aeeiiaiith caaaeaiue, ui noiyoue
ia?aae iei, ?, ? ia?o ca ana, c?inoa ye?noue ?aa?c?e ? ia?aa??ie.

5. ?ic?iaeaii i?iiiceoe?? eiiieaeniiai noeioethaaiiy
eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a. Iae?aneaii caoiaee aeey ca?eueoaiiy
aoaeoeaiino? ? ae??aino? eiio?ieth o nenoaie niiaeea/i? eiiia?aoe??.

6. Iaoeiai iaa?oioiaaii iniiai? aeaiaioe eiiieaenii? aeieoiaioaeueii?
?aa?c??. : ?ic?iaeaii iaoiaee/i? ?aeiiaiaeaoe?? aeey cae?eniaiiy
eiio?ieth ca caa?aaeaiiyi oiaa?ii-iaoa??aeueieo oe?iiinoae o
oi?a?aaeueieo i?aei?e?inoaao niiaeea/i? eiiia?aoe??. ?ic?iaeaii
n?oueiaee a?ao?e i?iaaaeaiiy ?iaaioa??caoe?? oiaa??a ? oa?e a iaaacei?,
ocaaaeueiaii iaoiaeeeo eiio?ieueii? ia?aa??ee i?aaeeueiino? ?
i?iaaaeaieo ?iaaioa?ecaoe?e. Iaa?oioiaaii oeyoe nei?i/aiiy oa?i?i?a ) ?
i?iaaaeaiiy ?iaaioa?ecaoe??. Iaoeiai iaa?oioiaaii ?aeiiaiaeaoe?? aeey
caiia?aaiiy ? i?eoiaoaaiiy ianoa/.

7. ?ic?iaeaii iine?aeiai?noue i?iaaaeaiiy ?aa?c?e ? aiae?co o?iainiai?
ae?yeueiino? oi?aiaiai i?aei?e?inoaa, iaaeaii ioe?ieo i?eeii?a
aeieoiaioaeueiiai eiio?ieth.

NIENIE IIOAE?EIAAIEO AAOI?II I?AOeUe CA OAIITH AeENA?OAOe??:

Oea/aiei A.I. Nooi?noue, ci?no ? i?noea eiio?ieth a nenoai? oi?aae?iiy
//I?eaei?i?ianueeee iaoeiaee a?niee. Aeiiii?ea. ? 10 (77),
Aei?i?iiao?ianuee, «Iaoea ? ina?oa». — 1998. — N. 35-41.

Oea/aiei A., Aaeao E. Oeie/iua ioeaee e iaaeinoaoee a o/aoa oiaa?iuo
iia?aoeee //Aooaaeoa?neee o/ao e aoaeeo. — 1998. -? 1.-N. 28-30.

Oea/aiei A.I., Iaoiaee/aneea aniaeou ii?aaeaeaiey iioeiaeueiie
/eneaiiinoe eiio?ieueii-?aaeceiiiiai ioaeaea iaeiio?aanithca
//I?eaei?i?ianueeee iaoeiaee a?niee. Aeiiii?ea. ? 48 (115),
Aei?i?iiao?ianuee,»Iaoea ? ina?oa».–1998.-N.44-49.

Oea/aiei A.I. I?aaeiao, aeaeu e oi?iu i?iaeoia i?aaiecaoeee o?oaea
eiio?ieueii-?aaeceiiiuo ?aaioieeia // Iiaa ia?aaeeaia. Aeueiaiao
iaoeiaeo i?aoeue iieiaeeo a/aieo 3aii??cueeiai ?aa?iio. 3aii??aeaey, ?A
«Oaiaeai-O», –1998. — Aui. 7.- N.11-15.

Oea/aiei A.I. Niaa?oainoaiaaiea i?aaiecaoeee aioo?eaaaeiinoaaiiiai
eiio?iey a ni/aoaiee n aioo?aiieie i?iaa?eaie e eiio?ieai ni noi?iiu
i?aaei?eyoey.: Caii?iaeneay ainoaea?noaaiiay eiaeaia?iay aeaaeaiey. –
1998. – 22n. Aeai. a AIOA Oe?aeiu ?291 – oe.98 io 29.06.98.

Oea/aiei A.I. Niaa?oainoaiaaiea aioo?enenoaiiiai eiio?iey –
ia?aii/a?aaeiay caaea/a iio?aaeoaeueneie eiiia?aoeee //I?eaei?i?ianueeee
iaoeiaee a?niee. Aeiiii?ea. ? 87 (154), Aei?i?iiao?ianuee,»Iaoea ?
ina?oa».–1998.-N.18-22.

Oea/aiei A.I. Iaoiaeu ?aoeeiiaeueiie i?aaiecaoeee aioo?enenoaiiiai
eiio?iey.: Caii?iaeneay ainoaea?noaaiiay eiaeaia?iay aeaaeaiey – 1998. –
36n. Aeai. a AIOA Oe?aeiu ? 475 – oe. 98 io 30.11.98.

Oea/aiei A.I. Ooieoe??, ?ieue ? i?noea eiio?ieth a oi?aae?ii? //Iiaa
ia?aaeeaia.-Caii??aeaey: CAeO, 1999,-Aei.10.-N.31-35.

Oea/aiei A.I. Iino?iaiea nenoaiu iiieoi?eiaa oeiainiaie aeayoaeueiinoe
i?aaei?eyoey //Iiaa ia?aaeeaia.-Caii??aeaey: CAeO,
1999,-Aei.11.-N.20-27.

AIIOAOe?ss

Oea/aiei A.I. I?aai?caoe?y eiio?ieth a oi?aae?ii? ae?yeuei?noth
i?aei?e?inoa niiaeea/i? eiiia?aoe?? a no/anieo oiiaao. — ?oeiien.

Aeena?oaoe?y ia caeiaoooy iaoeiaiai nooiaiy eaiaeeaeaoa aeiiii?/ieo iaoe
?c niaoe?aeueiino? 08.06.01 — aeiiii?ea i?aei?e?inoaa ? i?aai?caoe?y
ae?iaieoeoaa. ?inoeooo aeiiii?ee i?iieneiaino? IAI Oe?a?ie, Aeiiaoeuee,
1999.

O aeena?oaoe?? aeine?aeaeaii i?iaeaie ? ae?iaeaii iai?yiee
aaeineiiaeaiiy i?aai?caoe?? ? ii?ioaaiiy i?aoe? eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo
i?aoe?aiee?a niiaeea/i? eiiia?aoe??. ?ice?eoi nooue eiio?ieth ?
cai?iiiiiaaii oiiae iiaoaeiae nenoaie iii?oi?eiao o?iainiai?
ae?yeueiino? i?aei?e?inoa, aai ae aaeoc? a oe?eiio. Nenoaiaoeciaaii
i?eioeeie ii?ioaaiiy i?aoe? ?aa?ci??a, aecia/aiiy ?o aianeo o e?ioeaa?
?acoeueoaoe ?iaioe i?aei?e?inoaa, cai?iiiiiaaii iaoiaeeeo ?ic?aooieo
iioeiaeueiiai neeaaeo e?eueeino? eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a.

Eeth/ia? neiaa: i?aai?caoe?y i?aoe?, ii?ioaaiiy, eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?ei?
i?aoe?aieee, niiaeea/a eiiia?aoe?y, nooue eiio?ieth, iii?oi?eia, i?aoey
?aa?ci??a.

ANNOTATION

Tkachenko A.M. Organization of control of consumer co-operation
enterprises’ management activity under modern conditions. — Manuscript.

Dissertation for a candidate’s scientific degree from economy by
speciality 08.06.01. — Economy of the enterprise and organization of
production. — National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, Donetsk , 1999.

The dissertation is devoted to the investigation of the problem and
formulation of the line of rationalization of inspectors’ labor
organization and regulation in the sphere of consumer cooperation. It
discovers the essence of control auditing and proposes the basis of
finance monitoring system activity organization for the enterprise taken
separately or for the branch as a whole. Principles of inspectors’ labor
regulation and measuring of their contribution to the final results of
the enterprise activity are systematized methods of optimum inspectors
calculation are proposed.

Key words: labor organization, regulation, inspectors, consumer
co-operation, essence of control, monitoring, inspectors’ labor.

AIIIOAOeEss

Oea/aiei A. I. I?aaiecaoeey eiio?iey a oi?aaeaiee aeayoaeueiinoueth
i?aaei?eyoee iio?aaeoaeueneie eiiia?aoeee a nia?aiaiiuo oneiaeyo. —
?oeiienue.

Aeenna?oaoeey ia nieneaiea o/aiie noaiaie eaiaeeaeaoa yeiiiie/aneeo iaoe
ii niaoeeaeueiinoe 08.06.01. — Yeiiiieea i?aaei?eyoey e i?aaiecaoeey
i?iecaiaenoaa. Einoeooo yeiiiieee i?iiuoeaiiinoe IAI Oe?aeiu, Aeiiaoee,
1999.

A aeenna?oaoeee ia iniiaaiee eco/aiey e iaiauaiey iao/iuo ?ac?aaioie
ioa/anoaaiiuo e ca?oaaaeiuo enneaaeiaaoaeae , a oaeaea nia?aiaiiiai
iiuoa ?ai?aaiecaoeee aeayoaeueiinoe i?aaei?eyoee iio?aaeoaeueneie
eiiia?aoeee au?aaioaiu iai?aaeaiey niaa?oainoaiaaiey i?aaiecaoeee e
ii?ie?iaaiey o?oaea eiio?ieueii-?aaeceiiiuo ?aaioieeia
iio?aaeiiia?aoeee. ?ane?uoa nouiinoue eiio?iey e i?aaeeiaeaiey oneiaee
iino?iaiey nenoaiu iiieoi?eiaa oeiainiaie aeayoaeueiinoe i?aaei?eyoee
eee aea a oeaeii io?anee. I?aaeeiaeaii i?eiaiaiea iaoaiaoe/aneiai
iiaeaee?iaaiey oi?aiauo e i?iecaiaenoaaiiuo i?ioeannia a
iio?aaeoaeueneie eiiia?aoeee. I?iecaaaeai aiaeec nouanoaothueo iaoiaeia
eiio?iey n io?aaeaieai i?aeiouanoa e iaaeinoaoeia yoeo iaoiaeia. Aeaia
ioeaiea ninoiyiey ii?ie?iaaiey o?oaea , a oaeaea i?aaeeiaeaia iaoiaeeea
iineaaeiaaoaeueiinoe ?ac?aaioee ii?iaoeaia /eneaiiinoe
eiio?ieueii-?aaeceiiiuo ?aaioieeia.

Aeieacaii, /oi aeey aiaeeca caiyoinoe eaaeaeiai ?aaeci?a iaiaoiaeeii
ii?aaeaeeoue iineaaeiaaoaeueiinoue eiio?ieueii-?aaeceiiiuo aeaenoaee,
auyaeoue aeoaee?iaaiea ianaienoaaiiuo eniieieoaeyi ooieoeee, a aeey
yoiai oeaeaniia?acii ninoaaeyoue i?ia?aiiu ii?aaeaeaiey caiyoinoe
?aaeci?ia a i?ioeanna aeieoiaioaeueiie ?aaecee.

Ii?aaeaeaii, /oi a oeaeyo noaiiaeaiey ?uii/iuo ioiioaiee iaiaoiaeeia
eii?aeeiaoeey aeaenoaee oi?aaeai/aneeo no?oeoo?. Anoue ana iniiaaiey
ooaa?aeaeaoue, /oi eiio?ieueii-?aaeceiiiua neoaeau,
acaeiiaeaenoaoy n ae?oaeie i?aaiaie oi?aaeaiey , niinianoaotho
?aaeecaoeee ?aoaiee i?aaiia aeanoe, iai?aaeaiiuo ia i?aaiecaoeeth e
noaiiaeaiea ?uii/iuo ioiioaiee.

Iainiiaai auaiae i oii, /oi ?an/ao ii?iaoeaiie /eneaiiinoe yaeyaony
ia?aui yoaiii iino?iaiey no?oeoo?u aiia?aoa oi?aaeaiey. I?e yoii aeey
oi?ie?iaaiey eiie?aoiuo no?oeoo?iuo iiae?acaeaeaiee, a /anoiinoe
eiio?ieueii-?aaeceiiiuo neoaea, ii?aaeaeaiey eo eiee/anoaa iaiaoiaeeiu
ii?iaoeau /eneaiiinoe ?aaioieeia eae ii a?oiiai ooieoeee oi?aaeaiey ,
oae e ii eaaeaeie ooieoeee. A ?aaioa eceiaeaia iineaaeiaaoaeueiinoue
?ac?aaioee ii?iaoeaia /eneaiiinoe. I?aaeeiaeaia iaoiaeeea ?an/aoa
iioeiaeueiiai ninoaaa /eneaiiinoe eiio?ieueii-?aaeceiiiuo ?aaioieeia.
Ioia/aii, /oi iniaaiiinoueth o?oaea eiio?ieueii-?aaeceiiiuo ?aaioieeia
yaeyaony aieueoay ia?aaiiia?iinoue a caa?ocea, iaee/ea aieueoiai
eiee/anoaa ?aaio, eioi?ua iaeuecy ca?aiaa i?aaeaeaeaoue. A /anoiinoe,
ioaeaeaiiinoue io i?iaa?yaiuo iauaeoia e ae?. Enoiaey ec i?aaeeiaeaiiie
iaoiaeeee ?an/aoa eiee/anoaa ?aaeci?ia aiaeeoe/aneei niiniaii,
i?iecaaaeai ?an/ao iaiaoiaeeiie /eneaiiinoe ii nenoaia Caii?iaeneiai
iaeiio?aanithca. Eceiaeaiu iaeioi?ua i?e/eiu ineaaeaiey oeiainiaiai
eiio?iey a ia?aoiaeiue ia?eiae e ?uieo. Ioia/aii, /oi ono?aiaiea
iaaeinoaoeia aioo?eaaaeiinoaaiiiai oeiainiaiai eiio?iey aoaeao
niinianoaiaaoue auiieiaieth caaea/ , noiyueo ia?aae iei, e i?aaeaea
anaai iiauneony ea/anoai ?aaecee e i?iaa?ie.

?ac?aaioaiu i?aaeeiaeaiey eiiieaeniiai noeioee?iaaiey
eiio?ieueii-?aaeceiiiuo ?aaioieeia caeeth/athueony a oii, /oi
noeioee?iaaiea aeieaeii i?eaioe?iaaoueny ia eiia/iue ?acoeueoao eo
?aaiou, a eiaiii, ca eiee/anoai i?iaaaeaiiuo i?iaa?ie a aeaiiii
ia?eiaea, noiio auyaeaiiuo iaaeinoa/ e oeuaiee, noiio
i?aaeuyaeaiiuo ia/aoia aeieaeiinoiui e
iaoa?eaeueiiioaaonoaaiiui eeoeai e o.ae. E a caaeneiinoe io
onoaiiaeaiiuo ia?ooaiee iaiaoiaeeii eniieueciaaoue ?aciiia?aciua
iiaeoiaeu e noeioee?iaaieth ?aaeci?ia.

Iao/ii iainiiaaiu iniiaiua yeaiaiou eiiieaeoiie
aeieoiaioaeueiie ?aaecee. ?ac?aaioaiu iaoiaee/aneea ?aeiiaiaeaoeee ii
inouanoaeaieth eiio?iey ca nio?aiiinoueth iaoa?eaeueiuo oeaiiinoae a
nenoaia iio?aaeoaeueneie eiiia?aoeee.

Iaiauaia aeeneonney ioiineoaeueii iaoiaee/aneeo i?eaiia eiio?iey, a
oaeaea iieacaiu ?ieue e cia/aiea yeiiiie/aneiai aiaeeca i?e
inouanoaeaiee eiio?iey oeiainiai-oicyenoaaiiie aeayoaeueiinoe
i?aaei?eyoee e i?aaiecaoeee. iio?aaeoaeueneie eiiia?aoeee. Aeaia
ioeaiea iaoiaee/aneeo i?eaiia aeieoiaioaeueiiai eiio?iey.

Iniiaiua iao/iua iieiaeaiey aiaae?aiu a Aoeye-Iieueneii e Caii?iaeneii
?AEII e ia NI“AaoiCaC-IA^II” n aiaeiaui yeiiiie/aneei yooaeoii 23,5
oun.a?i.

Eeth/aaua neiaa: i?aaiecaoeey o?oaea, ii?ie?iaaiea,
eiio?ieueii-?aaeceiiiua ?aaioieee, iio?aaeoaeueneay eiiia?aoeey,
nouiinoue eiio?iey, iiieoi?eia, o?oae ?aaeci?ia.

PAGE 11

I?eioeei aeai?o ? niinoa?aaeaiiy

I?eioeei iiaoaeiae ?ioaa?aeueieo ioe?ii/ieo iieaciee?a

I?eioeei iiaoaeiae nenoaie ?ioi?iaoe?eieo iieaciee?a

Oe?eueia? no?aoaa?/i? o?iainia? ii?iaoeae

Iieacieee o?iainiaiai noaio

Iieacieee nenoaie aeai?eoi?a

Iieacieee o?iainiaeo ieai?a ? athaeaeao?a

Iieacieee onoiaiiy a?aeoeeaiue

Iieacieee o?iainiai? no?eeino?

Iia?aoeai?noue ?ioi?iaoe?? (i?ny/ia, eaa?oaeueia, ??/ia)

Iieacieee a?aeoeeaiue a?ae ii?iaoea?a

Iieacieee a?aeoeeaiue o %

I?eioeei anoaiiaeaiiy ia??iaee/iino?

I?eioeei anoaiiaeaiiy nenoaie ae?e

I?eioeei aiae?co iniiaieo i?e/ei

I?eioeei anoaiiaeaiiy ?ici???a a?aeoeeaiue

I?eioeei i?eaaaeaiiy o a?aeiia?aei?noue nenoaie o?iainiaiai eiio?ieth

I?eioeei ia?aaeaa/aieo ?aca?a?a ii?iae?caoe?? o?iainiai? ae?yeueiino?

I?eioeei ia?aaeyaeo ? ci?i iieaciee?a

Iieacieee i?yieo noi?iiaaieo ?aca?a?a o?iainiaeo eioo?a

Iieacieee caaacia/aiiy ?aaeueieo aeaieo

Iieacieee ia i?yieo ?aca?a?a

Iieacieee iniiaieo i?iiiceoe?e

?en.1. Iii?oi?eia o?iainiai? ae?yeueiino? i?aei?e?inoa

E?eoa??? i?aai?caoe??

Eeaneo?eaoi? ii?i

Aeai?eoi eiiieaeniiai iaa?oiooaaiiy o?oaeii?noeino?

Ioiieaiiy /enaeueiino?

Iniiai? oaeoi?e

1. Iiaiioa ioiieaiiy ii?ioaaiiy

Oe?eueia? ooieoe??

I?aeaioia/? ?iaioe

Neeaae ? no?oeoo?a

3. Iaa?oiooaaiiy ii?iaoeaii? o?oaeii?noeino?

2. Nenoaiiee i?aeo?ae aei ?ica’ycaiiy caaaeaiue

8. Aeeiai?/i?noue ii?ioaaiiy i?aoe?

4. I?eioeei iaaecia/aiino?

5. Eiia??iee oa?aeoa? ii?ioaaiiy

Ii?iaoeaia o?oaeii?noe?noue

?en.2 Eiioeaiooaeueia iiaeaeue ii?ioaaiiy i?aoe? eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo
i?aoe?aiee?a

Ii?iaoeaia

aoaeoeai?noue

Eiiieaen ?ia?o

6. Yoaeoeai?noue nenoaie

7. O/anoue eiio?ieueii-?aa?c?eieo i?aoe?aiee?a o i?ioean? ii?ioaaiiy

Noeioethaaiiy ia?aaeyaeo ii?i

Cai?ia ii?i i?e ai?iaaaeaeaii? ii?ioaaiiy i?aoe?

Ia?aaeyae ii?i

I?eeiie ia?aa??ee ie?aiiai aeieoiaioa

?en. 3. Eeaneo?eaoe?y iaoiaee/ieo i?eeii?a aeieoiaioaeueiiai eiio?ieth

C?noaaeaiiy a?oi aeieoiaio?a, ye? a?aeia?aaea-thoue iaeiioeii? iia?aoe??

O?iiieia?/ia ia?aa??ea ?ooo oe?iiinoae

A?aeiiaeaiiy e?euee?nii-noiiaiai ?aooieo

Niin?a cai?ioiueiai ?aooieo

Aaeainia? oa’ycee ?ooo OIOe

?ioi?iaoe?eia

iiaeaethaaiiy

Aea??eiaa

ia?aa??ea

Aca?iiee

eiio?ieue

Ianooe?eueia

ia?aa??ea

Cono??/ia

ia?aa??ea

Nooe?eueia

ia?aa??ea

Iaoaiaoe/ia ia?aa??ea

Oi?iaeueia ia?aa??ea

Eia?/ia ia?aa??ea

Ii?iaoeaia ia?aa??ea

I?eeiie ia?aa??ee aeieoiaio?a, ye? a?aeia?aaeathoue ?oo iaeii??aeieo
oe?iiinoae

I?eeiie ia?aa??ee aeae?eueeio aeieoiaio?a, ye? a?aeia?aaeathoue iaeio ?
oo ae, aai aca?iiiia’ycai? iia?aoe??

Iaoiaee/i? i?eeiie aeieoiaioaeueiiai eiio?ieth

Добавить комментарий

Ваш e-mail не будет опубликован. Обязательные поля помечены *